Comparison of anaemia and parasitaemia as indicators of malaria control in household and EPI-health facility surveys in Malawi
© Mathanga et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2010
Received: 10 December 2009
Accepted: 21 April 2010
Published: 21 April 2010
The World Health Organization has recommended that anaemia be used as an additional indicator to monitor malaria burden at the community level as malaria interventions are nationally scaled up. To date, there are no published evaluations of this recommendation.
To evaluate this recommendation, a comparison of anaemia and parasitaemia among 6-30 month old children was made during two repeated cross-sectional household (HH) and health facility (HF) surveys in six districts across Malawi at baseline (2005) and in a follow-up survey (2008) after a scale up of malaria control interventions.
HH net ownership did not increase between the years (50.5% vs. 49.8%), but insecticide treated net (ITN) ownership increased modestly from 41.5% (95% CI: 37.2%-45.8%) in 2005 to 45.3% (95% CI: 42.6%-48.0%) in 2008. ITN use by children 6-30 months old, who were living in HH with at least one net, increased from 73.6% (95% CI:68.2%-79.1%) to 80.0% (95% CI:75.9%-84.1%) over the three-year period. This modest increase in ITN use was associated with a decrease in moderate to severe anaemia (Hb <8 g/dl) from 18.4% (95% CI:14.9%-21.8%) in 2005 to 15.4% (13.2%-17.7%) in 2008, while parasitaemia, measured as positive-slide microscopy, decreased from 18.9% (95% CI:14.7%-23.2%) to 16.9% (95% CI:13.8%-20.0%), a relative reduction of 16% and 11%, respectively. In HF surveys, anaemia prevalence decreased from 18.3% (95% CI: 14.9%-21.7%) to 15.4% (95% CI: 12.7%-18.2%), while parasitaemia decreased from 30.6% (95% CI: 25.7%-35.5%) to 13.2% (95% CI: 10.6%-15.8%), a relative reduction of 15% and 57%, respectively.
Increasing access to effective malaria prevention was associated with a reduced burden of malaria in young Malawian children. Anaemia measured at the HF level at time of routine vaccination may be a good surrogate indicator for its measurement at the HH level in evaluating national malaria control programmes.
The unprecedented increase of investment in the control of malaria in Africa means that over the coming years, there should be a substantial reduction in malaria-related morbidity and mortality in these settings. Unfortunately, there are still few affordable and reliable indicators that can be used to measure short-term, malaria-specific impact of the scale-up of various interventions at the community level. Malaria related mortality, an important overall malaria control target, is difficult to diagnose, define and measure at the population level . Its measurement is confined to health facilities - which capture only a small proportion of the malaria burden - and, at a population level, to selected, small-scale sentinel 'demographic surveillance' sites .
The World Health Organization (WHO) and Roll Back Malaria (RBM) Partnership have recommended that anaemia be used as an additional indicator to monitor malaria burden at the community level as interventions are nationally scaled-up . This recommendation is based on results of an extensive review conducted by Korenromp et al (2004) showing that, in areas of stable malaria transmission, moderate-to-severe anaemia (haemoglobin <8 g/dl) is more sensitive than is parasite prevalence, and may respond more quickly than mortality to changes in malaria exposure due to increasing coverage of malaria interventions such as insecticide-treated bed nets (ITNs), malarial prophylaxis, and indoor residual spraying . The review indicated that, in randomized controlled trials, the impact of ITNs on anaemia was more pronounced than on parasitaemia prevalence or clinical malaria.
Other reasons to include anaemia as an indicator for malaria control include: (a) its association with malaria in areas of high malaria transmission, (b) its ability to be measured and quantified in the field, (c) it has a morbidity burden, and (d) severe malarial anaemia, for young children and pregnant women, is on the pathway to mortality, which is the overall RBM target.
To date, there is no published literature evaluating this recommendation, or whether measurement of these indicators at time of routine immunizations could serve as a comparable substitute to measurement at the household level. This paper presents the utility of two approaches to monitoring and evaluation recommended in the WHO/RBM guidelines. The success of interventions implemented under the National Malaria Control Programme (NMCP) and the Roll Back Malaria Malawi country plan were assessed using both parasitaemia and anaemia. The evaluation was also designed to determine if measurement of these indicators at the health facility level at time of Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI) visits could be a comparable substitute for measurement at the household level, information that is potentially very useful to Malawi and other malaria-endemic countries as it is logistically easier and cheaper to conduct health facility surveys than household surveys.
The study protocol was approved by Institutional Review Boards at the University of Malawi and the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
For the 2005 HH survey, 30 enumeration areas (EAs) were selected with probability proportional to estimated size (PPS) in each of the six districts. The sampling frame was developed through the use of global positioning system (GPS) linked with hand-held computers (PDAs) to allow rapid preliminary mapping of the EA from which a simple random sample of households was selected. This method involved: a) mapping every household in the selected EA using PDAs equipped with GPS, b) selecting a random sample of 11 households, and c) using the GPS to navigate back to the households and perform the interview . This translates to 330 households per district, or 1,980 households for all six districts. All selected households were invited to participate in the survey during which a questionnaire was administered collecting data on household economic status and net ownership/use, and children 6-30 months of age providing a blood sample for determination of parasitaemia and haemoglobin.
In the 2008 HH survey, a modified EPI cluster survey method, as described by Turner, was used to select households . A different method was used because of logistical difficulties encountered in the mapping and listing of households in many of the EAs in the 2005 HH survey. The modified cluster survey method involved: a) selection of the same EAs as the ones used in the 2005 HH survey, b) using EA maps which list the expected number of households and the distribution of the households on the maps (with field observation including confirmation of EA borders), (c) creating sub-clusters or segments of approximately equal size, d) randomly selecting one segment, and e) interviewing all households in the selected segment and obtaining blood samples from children 6-30 months of age. Listings were not needed because all HHs in the segment were included and the probability of selection was known.
The EPI-HF survey component was conducted in three of the six districts selected for the HH survey (Lilongwe, Blantyre, and Rumphi) immediately following the respective HH surveys in those districts. In each of the three districts, government health facilities, which provide EPI services, were chosen to attain a sample size of 540 children per district. Due to differences in enrolment rates, five health facilities were chosen in Blantyre, three in Rumphi and four in Lilongwe in order to meet the required sample size. The same health facilities were used in both the 2005 and 2008 surveys. Children 6-30 months of age attending the EPI clinic for a routine visit were systematically sampled from the clinic and invited to enrol.
Sample size was calculated based on assumption that 21% of all children 6-30 months old in the baseline survey would have Hb <8 g/dl (based on results from a 2003 household survey in Blantyre district). Sample sizes were calculated using 95% confidence limits, 80% power, and 10% adjustment for non-response to detect a 33% reduction in the prevalence of Hb <8 g/dl between two cross-sectional surveys. Using this estimate, a sample size of 1,900 households (712 children) was needed for the HH survey assuming 37% of households had children 6-30 months of age (DHS 2000) and a design effect of 1.32. A sample size of 1,617 children was required for the EPI-HF survey assuming a design effect of 3.0. The same sample size was applied for the 2005 and 2008 surveys.
Interview with parent/guardian
Structured interviews were conducted with household heads and/or parent/guardian of all children in selected households. Information was gathered on ownership of household assets, household net ownership, net use and health of children under five years of age; blood smears and haemoglobin results were obtained for children 6-30 months of age. Per national policy, children with an Hb<8 g/dl, or fever, or a history of fever in the previous two weeks, were treated with sulphadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP) (2005) or with artemether-lumefantrine (CoArtem®) (2008). All children with anaemia were treated with iron and albendazole as per national guidelines.
The questionnaire was designed in English and translated into two main languages spoken in the selected districts, namely Chichewa and Chitumbuka. Data were collected electronically using a PDA-based questionnaire developed using Visual CE 9.0 (Syware Inc., Cambridge, MA). During the survey, data were backed up onto a secure digital card every evening. Upon survey completion, PDAs were returned to Blantyre, where data were aggregated into a Microsoft Access database.
Blood samples were collected from each child for on-the-spot measurement of haemoglobin concentration (HemoCue, Angelhom, Sweden). Thick blood smears were prepared for microscopic diagnosis of malaria parasites. Blood slides were stained with field stain and read by an expert microscopist at the College of Medicine. Slides were declared negative if no asexual parasites were found after examining 100 high-power fields. Slide reading was blinded and the external quality control consisted of having all positive slides and 10% of randomly selected negative slides read again by an independent microscopist.
Household was defined as a family, comprising the head of household (man or woman), husband or wife, children and immediate family members who shared income. An ITN was defined as any bed net that had been treated with insecticide in the previous 12 months or a long-lasting insecticidal net (a net treated during the manufacturing process). Adherence to net/ITN was defined as a child sleeping under a net/ITN the previous night in a HH that owns a net/ITN. Parasitaemia was defined as the presence of any asexual malaria parasites detected on a thick peripheral blood smear. A child with haemoglobin concentration 5 to <8 g/dL was classified as moderately anaemic, while those with haemoglobin <5 g/dL were classified as severely anaemic. For the purpose of analysis, anaemia was defined as any haemoglobin level <8 g/dL. Clinical malaria was defined as a documented axillary temperature ≥ 37.5°C in the presence of any asexual parasitaemia. Household wealth scores were developed using loading factors from the 2004 Malawi Demographic and Health Survey . This is a composite score obtained from a principle components model, including variables assessing household assets (electricity, bike, radio, type of floor material and toilet, source of drinking water, etc). These wealth scores were partitioned to create wealth quintiles.
Estimates of frequencies were calculated using SAS survey procedures (SAS v9.1.3) which use a Taylor series expansion to account for stratification, cluster sampling and unequal probabilities of selection. All analyses of HH data used weights equal to the inverse probability of selection. The EPI-HF survey was not a probability sample and could not be weighted. The outcome variable anaemia was considered as dichotomous (Hb < 8 g/dL or Hb >= 8 g/dL) and parasitaemia was measured as presence or absence of asexual parasites.
Multivariate logistic regression models were performed in SAS using Generalized Estimating Equations (GEE) with an exchangeable working correlation matrix to produce empirically corrected standard error estimates that account for clustering and unequal selection probabilities. Rao-Scott chi-square values were used to detect associations between the outcome variable and the predictors of anaemia such as net use, ITN use, and prompt and appropriate treatment of fever. To observe whether there were any statistically significant differences between HH and EPI-HF measurement in change of anaemia from 2005 and 2008, an interaction term between study year and an indicator variable identifying the survey type (HH or EPI-HF) was created. The final models for anaemia and parasitaemia were adjusted for age, ethnicity, SES, clinical malaria (in the case of anaemia), current fever (for parasitaemia), district, and whether or not the child had slept under an ITN the previous night.
The 2005 HH survey approached 1,739 HHs for participation over a four-week period, and recruited 926 children between the ages of 6-30 months; immediately following the HH survey, 12 EPI-HFs were surveyed over a two-week period to yield 1,637 children in this same age group. Children included in the HH survey were older, had a different distribution of ethnic groups, were less likely to have sought treatment within 24 hrs, and were less likely to have concurrent fever than children included in the EPI-HF survey (see Additional file 1, Table A: Characteristics of children participating in the 2005 and 2008 household and EPI-health facility surveys).
In 2008, 10,034 HHs were approached for participation, and 4,565 children between the ages of 6-30 months were recruited; the 12 EPI-HFs selected in 2005 were re-surveyed to yield 1,909 children in this same age group. Children included in the 2008 HH survey were poorer, older, of different ethnic distribution, less likely to have slept under a net or an ITN the previous night, more likely to have reported a history of fever in the past two weeks, and less likely to have sought treatment within 24 hrs than children included in the EPI-HF survey in 2008 (See Table A, additional file 1).
Between the 2005 and 2008 EPI-HF surveys, there was a significant increase from 36.7% [95% CI: 31.1% - 42.4%] to 49.4% [95% CI: 44.4% - 54.4%] in the proportion of children who reported sleeping under an ITN the previous night. Both the reported history of fever and current fever at the time of the survey were halved.
Measuring change in anaemia and parasitaemia
Reduction in the crude prevalence of anaemia and parasitaemia among children 6-30 months of age in household and EPI-health facility surveys conducted in 2005 and 2008
Household (HH) survey
Health Facility (HF) surveys
Prevalence of anaemia (Hb<8 g/dl) in children 6-30 months;
% (95% CI)*
Prevalence of parasitaemia in children 6-30 months;
% (95% CI)*
Factors associated with anaemia and parasitaemia
Association of anaemia and parasitaemia with household and clinical characteristics among children 6-30 months of age enrolled into the 2005 HH and EPI-HF surveys (adjusted for clustering)
Household surveys (N = 926)
EPI-Health facility surveys (N = 1637)
Anaemia (Hb<8 g/dl)
History of fever
Slept under a net the previous night
Slept under ITN previous night
Association of anaemia and parasitaemia with household and clinical characteristics among children 6-30 months of age enrolled into the 2008 HH and EPI-HF surveys (adjusted for clustering).
Household surveys (N = 4565)
EPI-Health facility surveys (N = 1909)
Anaemia (Hb<8 g/dl)
History of fever
Slept under a net the previous night
Slept under ITN previous night
Association of survey type (HH vs. EPI-HF) and year (2005 vs. 2008) with prevalence of anaemia and parasitaemia among children 6-30 months of age in six districts in Malawi
OR (95% CI)
OR (95% CI)
OR (95% CI)
OR (95% CI)
P* = 0.36
P* = 0.45
P* = 0.16
P* = 0.17
The government of Malawi is rapidly scaling up a full range of existing evidence-based malaria prevention and control strategies. These strategies include use of ITNs, IPTp and prompt and effective case management, particularly among children who are sick with malaria. Between 2005 and 2008, 3,727,330 nets (PSI, personal communication) were distributed and a new malaria treatment policy was implemented countrywide, with artemether-lumefantrine replacing SP as the first-line drug. A modest, non-statistically significant increase in ITN household ownership (from 41.5% to 45.3%) and a statistically significant increase in adherence to any net (regardless of treatment status) were observed between 2005 and 2008. The results also show a moderate reduction in the odds of anaemia; the prevalence of anaemia decreased by a modest 15-16% from baseline, depending on the type of survey. In light of these data, and the very recent introduction of ACT, it can be argued that anaemia is a sensitive indicator to the scale up of malaria interventions and may thus be used as a proxy indicator to track the burden of malaria and demonstrate timely impact of malaria interventions in areas of high malaria This finding is important because existing impact indicators are either hard to measure at the national scale (e.g. all-cause under-five mortality, malaria-attributed mortality) or not sensitive enough to changes in malaria transmission (e.g. parasite prevalence). In contrast, anaemia is measurable and quantifiable in the field with the portable HemoCue haemoglobinometre using small volumes of capillary blood, it requires a smaller sample size, and gives more precise results than does measurement of all-cause mortality for children under-five years of age. However, anaemia may have limited utility in areas of lower malaria transmission where the attributable fraction of anaemia due to malaria is too low to reflect changes in malaria transmission/control.
Parasitaemia, another common indicator used to assess malaria control, was also evaluated in this study. The prevalence of parasitaemia was reduced by 11% in the HH survey and 57% in the EPI-HF survey. This observation supports the finding above that reduction in both anaemia and parasitaemia could have been due to the modest scale up of malaria interventions. The dramatic reduction in parasitaemia observed in the EPI-HF survey was unexpected but could be due to accidental inclusion of some sick children during the EPI-HF survey in 2005. This is supported by the data showing that the proportion of children who had fever at the time of recruitment into the EPI-HF survey was significantly decreased from 11.7% to 4.6% between 2005 and 2008 (p < 0.0001). A corresponding decrease was also observed in children presenting to the clinic with a history of fever in the past 48 hours (p < 0.0001)(see Table A, additional file 1). Adjusted analyses revealed that the reductions in the odds of parasitaemia in both types of surveys were not significantly different from each other.
Not surprisingly, the reduction in the prevalence of anaemia and parasitaemia observed in this study was very modest. A similar household evaluation conducted among children under five years of age in Zambia has reported over 50% reduction in both parameters between 2006 and 2008, likely due to an increase of >20% in household ownership of at least one mosquito net following a mass distribution campaign . Household ITN ownership in the Malawian study only increased from 41.5% to 45.3% (p = 0.10) during the three-year interval. This modest and non-significant increase could be explained by several factors. First, between 2007 and 2008, the procurement and distribution of ITNs experienced a lot of logistical problems resulting in fewer subsidized nets being delivered to the target groups (PSI, personal communication). As a result, most of the ITNs during this period were only distributed after the 2008 follow up surveys. Secondly, there is the possibility that because the distribution of ITNs was targeted to only households with pregnant women or children aged less than five years, during the period between the two surveys, the same households were reached with ITNs as a result of the targeted distribution. This is supported by the fact that overall net ownership did not increase during this period. Population growth could also explain the modest increase in household ITN increase. While the number of new nets distributed is known, population growth in the communities surveyed is not known with a possibility that fewer nets were distributed compared to population growth. This failure to significantly scale up household ownership of ITNs has been reported in other surveys . In this survey, in households with at least one ITN, over 75% of the children slept under an ITN suggesting good adherence to nets among children under five as has been reported elsewhere . Therefore, in Malawi, more needs to be done to achieve the Roll Back Malaria target of protecting 80% of the population at risk by 2010. Rapid scale up of the ITN programme through mass distribution to achieve universal coverage could significantly reduce malaria morbidity, and especially malaria-related anaemia.
This study also shows that the reduction in anaemia, as measured during EPI-HF surveys, was similar to the reduction measured during the household surveys. Thus, anaemia measured at the EPI clinics at the facility level may be a good surrogate indicator of anaemia measurement at the household level. This finding has important programmatic implication because EPI-HF surveys have the advantage of being cheaper and logistically simpler to execute than household surveys. In addition, measurement of anaemia in the EPI clinic would be only a small burden for health workers since surveys would only be done periodically. The ability to measure the impact of malaria interventions through EPI clinics could afford District Health Management Teams the means to quickly evaluate the impact of the malaria programme and inform the efficient deployment of malaria interventions within the district.
The results of this evaluation should be interpreted in the context of the limitations of the study. The causes of anaemia are multifactorial; paediatric HIV infection and malnutrition are prominent ones [12–14]. As a result the reduction in the prevalence of anaemia observed in this study could be affected by improvements in coverage of non-malaria related interventions. This study did not collect information on other competing causes of anaemia, such as nutritional status, HIV, hookworm infection, helminths, or bacteraemia. However, between 2005 and 2008, there were no large scale nutritional interventions or other child health interventions that underwent rapid scale up in the selected districts which could have led to the decrease in the prevalence of anaemia. Children in the household surveys were significantly older than children in the EPI-health facility surveys (p < 0.0001). This difference in age may have introduced bias in the results; however, this is unlikely as the prevalence of anaemia in the EPI-HF survey compared very well to that in the household survey. Despite these limitations, it is reasonable to argue that the very modest decline in anaemia prevalence was as a result of the small increase in malaria control interventions, specifically the scale up of ITN coverage and the introduction of ACT, since other proxies for malaria such as fever in the last two weeks were also significantly reduced between 2005 and 2008.
The sampling strategies for the two household surveys were different from one another. In 2005, a simple random sample of households in each EA was selected, whereas in 2008, information was collected from all households in a randomly selected segment of each EA. Although both strategies have been validated [8, 9], both strategies experienced challenges in the application of the respective techniques because of the physical size of EAs in Malawi. If some households were inadvertently missed due to these challenges, it may result in a bias in the estimates presented here. The generalizability of these results is also limited by the fact that the selection of districts, although geographically representative of the different transmission strata in Malawi, was a convenience sample. Furthermore, the EPI-HF survey was restricted to only three districts due to financial and logistical constraints.
The results from this study suggest that anaemia may continue to be included as an important indicator for monitoring and evaluation in areas of moderate to high malaria transmission where the attributable fraction of anaemia due to malaria is high enough to reflect changes in malaria transmission and control. Anaemia (and maybe parasitaemia) measured at time of routine immunizations may be a good surrogate indicator for its measurement at the household level, and should be evaluated/verified in other settings.
We thank the parents, guardians and all children involved in this study for their cooperation and participation. We also wish to acknowledge the following people for their support of this project: Dr. Storn Kabuluzi at the Ministry of Health, Malawi and Prof. Cameron Bowie from the College of Medicine. Funding for this study was provided by the US Centers for Disease Control and the President Malaria Initiative. This article was supported by the Cooperative Agreement number 5 U01 CI000189 from the CDC. The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position of the funding agencies.
- Breman JG: The ears of the hippopotamus: manifestations, determinants, and estimates of the malaria burden. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2001, 64: 1-11.PubMed
- Rowe AK, Steketee RW, Arnold F, Wardlaw T, Basu S, Bakyaita N, Lama M, Winston CA, Lynch M, Cibulskis RE, Shibuya K, Ratcliffe AA, Nahlen BL, Roll Back Malaria Monitoring and Evaluation Reference Group: Viewpoint: evaluating the impact of malaria control efforts on mortality in sub-Saharan Africa. Trop Med Int Health. 2007, 12: 1524-1539.View ArticlePubMed
- World Health Organization: Minutes MERG Anaemia Task Force Meeting: 27-28th Oct 2003. Accessed on 6th December 2009, [http://www.rollbackmalaria.org/.../wg/wg.../MERG_Anaemia_tfm1_minutes.doc]
- Korenromp EL, Armstrong-Schellenberg JR, Williams BG, Nahlen BL, Snow RW: Impact of malaria control on childhood anaemia in Africa - a quantitative review. Trop Med Int Health. 2004, 9: 1050-1065. 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2004.01317.x.View ArticlePubMed
- National Statistical Office: Demographic Health Survey (DHS). Malawi. 2004
- UNICEF: Malawi Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey 2006. Malawi. 2006
- Ministry of Health (MoH): Malaria Strategic Plan 2005 - 2010: Scaling up Malaria Control Interventions. Malawi. 2005
- Vanden Eng JL, Wolkon A, Frolov AS, Terlouw DJ, Eliades MJ, Morgah K, Takpa V, Dare A, Sodahlon YK, Doumanou Y, Hawley WA, Hightower AW: Use of handheld computers with global positioning systems for probability sampling and data entry in household surveys. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007, 77: 393-399.PubMed
- Turner AG, Magnana RJ, Shuaib M: A not quite as quick but much cleaner alternative to the Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI) Cluster Survey design. Int J Epidemiol. 1996, 25: 198-203. 10.1093/ije/25.1.198.View ArticlePubMed
- Miller J: Rapid increase in insecticide-treated net coverage associated with reductions in malaria parasitemia and severe anemia in Zambia. 2006, American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene: 7-11 December 2008; New Orleans, -2008
- Baume CA, Marin MC: Intra-household mosquito net use in Ethiopia, Ghana, Mali, Nigeria, Senegal, and Zambia: are nets being used? Who in the household uses them?. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007, 77: 963-971.PubMed
- Ronald LA, Kenny SL, Klinkenberg E, Akoto AO, Boakye I, Barnish G, Donnelly MJ: Malaria and anaemia among children in two communities of Kumasi, Ghana: a cross-sectional survey. Malar J. 2006, 9: 5: 105-10.1186/1475-2875-5-105.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMed
- Clark TD, Mmiro F, Ndugwa C, Perry RT, Jackson JB, Melikian G, Semba RD: Risk factors and cumulative incidence of anaemia among human immunodeficiency virus-infected children in Uganda. Ann Trop Paediatr. 2002, 22: 11-17. 10.1179/027249302125000102.View ArticlePubMed
- Villamor E, Mbise R, Spiegelman D, Ndossi G, Fawzi WW: Vitamin A supplementation and other predictors of anemia among children from Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2000, 62: 590-597.PubMed
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.