Skip to main content

Table 3 Sensitivity and specificity of HtLAMP-Pg/Pf for the detection of P. falciparum

From: A simple, high-throughput, colourimetric, field applicable loop-mediated isothermal amplification (HtLAMP) assay for malaria elimination

Origin

Assay

Diagnostic accuracy

 

No. of samples

Type of sample

PCR technique used for speciation

Pf

Pv

Pm

Pk

Po spp

Mixed infections

Negatives

Papua New Guinea

   

42

Filter paper

Multiplex PCR

12

9

0

0

0

5 (Pf/Pv)

16

HtLAMP-Pg

Sensitivity

77 % (20/26)

95 % CI 56–91

          
 

Specificity

81 % (13/16)

95 % CI 54–96

          

HtLAMP-Pf

Sensitivity

76 % (13/17)

95 % CI 50–93

          
 

Specificity

100 % (25/25)

95 % CI 86–100

          

Sabah, Malaysia

   

145

Filter paper

Multiplex PCR and nested PCR (Pk)

17

64

7

56

0

1 (Pv/Pk)

0

HtLAMP-Pg

Sensitivity

100 % (145/145)

95 % CI 97–100

          

HtLAMP-Pf

Sensitivity

100 % (17/17)

95 % CI 80–100

          
 

Specificity

95 % (123/128)

95 % CI 90–98

          

The Gambia

   

97

Whole blood

Nested PCR

94

NA

1

NA

0

0

2

HtLAMP-Pg

Sensitivity

100 % (95/95)

95 % CI 96–100

          
 

Specificity

100 % (2/2)

95 % CI 16–100

          

HtLAMP-Pf

Sensitivity

100 % (94/94)

95 % CI 96–100

          
 

Specificity

100 % (3/3)

95 % CI 29–100

          

TOTAL

   

284

  

124

73

8

56

0

6

18

HtLAMP-Pg

Sensitivity

98 % (260/266)

95 % CI 95–99

          
 

Specificity

83 % (15/18),

95 % CI 59–96

          
 

PPV

99 %, 95 % CI 97–100

          
 

NPV

71 %, 95 % CI 48–89

          

HtLAMP-Pf

Sensitivity

97 % (124/128)

95 % CI 92–99

          
 

Specificity

96 % (151/157)

95 % CI 92–99

          
 

PPV

95 %, 95 % CI 90–98

          
 

NPV

97 %, 95 % CI 94–99

          
  1. This table summarizes the features of each of the 3 sample sets, from Papua New Guinea, Sabah Malaysia and The Gambia, and a composite sensitivity and specificity of HtLAMP-Pg/Pf for the detection of P. falciparum