Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 3 Comparison of daily mean of abundance, human biting rate (HBR) and entomological inoculation rate (EIR) between different ATSB configurations and control

From: Modelling optimum use of attractive toxic sugar bait stations for effective malaria vector control in Africa

Environment ATSB configuration Male abundance Female abundance HBR EIR
Means % decrease Means % decrease Means % decrease Means % decrease
Resource rich Control 239.375 0.00 380.781 0.00 6.69513 0.00 0.50085 0.00
7 × 7 10.06 95.80 6.791 98.22 0.03203 99.52 0.00007 99.99
5 × 5 31.285 86.93 28.168 92.60 0.18999 97.16 0.00088 99.82
Periphery 48 96.289 59.77 108.078 71.62 0.66992 89.99 0.00152 99.70
Periphery 24 99.447 58.46 111.905 70.61 0.69635 89.60 0.00176 99.65
Transect 50 66.742 72.12 71.676 81.18 0.50966 92.39 0.00101 99.80
Transect 25 70.795 70.43 75.996 80.04 0.56473 91.57 0.00089 99.82
Sugar 50 12.723 94.68 9.375 97.54 0.04629 99.31 0.00011 99.98
Sugar 25 29.25 87.78 26.644 93.00 0.17223 97.43 0.00042 99.92
House 50 103.22 56.88 118.499 68.88 0.79739 88.09 0.00157 99.69
House 25 104.922 56.17 121.827 68.01 0.83236 87.57 0.00185 99.63
Rest 50 16.056 93.29 12.249 96.78 0.0697 98.96 0.00029 99.94
Rest 25 36.883 84.59 35.806 90.60 0.27758 95.85 0.00198 99.60
Larval 50 22.01 90.81 20.23 94.69 0.15867 97.63 0.0018 99.64
Larval 25 49.956 79.13 53.629 85.92 0.51431 92.32 0.00763 98.48
Random 50 14.545 93.92 11.493 96.98 0.07178 98.93 0.00009 99.98
Random 25 42.344 82.31 43.48 88.58 0.37372 94.42 0.00643 98.72
F 94.61 185.46 474.6 42.86
P <0.0001 <0.0001 <0.0001 <0.0001
Resource poor Control 13.716 0.00 15.748 0.00 0.32559 0.00 0.01364 0.00
7 × 7 2.544 81.45 1.292 91.80 0.00603 98.15 0.00003 99.78
5 × 5 2.873 79.05 1.65 89.52 0.01071 96.71 0.00003 99.78
Periphery 48 2.809 79.52 1.974 87.47 0.00898 97.24 0.00015 98.90
Periphery 24 3.341 75.64 2.371 84.94 0.0113 96.53 0.00006 99.56
Transect 50 2.601 81.04 1.765 88.79 0.0091 97.21 0.00012 99.12
Transect 25 3.364 75.47 2.208 85.98 0.0123 96.22 0.0001 99.27
Sugar 50 3.183 76.79 1.985 87.40 0.01208 96.29 0.00006 99.56
Sugar 25 3.013 78.03 1.985 87.40 0.01162 96.43 0.00006 99.56
House 50 2.407 82.45 1.957 87.57 0.00985 96.97 0.00032 97.65
House 25 2.491 81.84 1.863 88.17 0.01057 96.75 0.00016 98.83
Rest 50 3.316 75.82 2.215 85.93 0.01626 95.01 0.00009 99.34
Rest 25 3.967 71.08 2.8 82.22 0.02411 92.59 0 100.00
Larval 50 5.133 62.58 4.245 73.04 0.04778 85.33 0.0014 89.74
Larval 25 5.609 59.11 4.48 71.55 0.04869 85.05 0.00099 92.74
Random 50 2.745 79.99 1.873 88.11 0.01463 95.51 0.0001 99.27
Random 25 4.234 69.13 3.316 78.94 0.03447 89.41 0.00004 99.71
F 4.17 9.46 19.2 6.46
P <0.0001 <0.0001 <0.0001 <0.0001