Modelling optimum use of attractive toxic sugar bait stations for effective malaria vector control in Africa

Zhu, Lin; Marshall, John M.; Qualls, Whitney A.; Schlein, Yosef; McManus, John W.; Arheart, Kris L.; Hlaing, WayWay M.; Traore, Sekou F.; Doumbia, Seydou; Müller, Günter C.; Beier, John C.

doi:10.1186/s12936-015-1012-9

Malaria Journal

Table 3 Comparison of daily mean of abundance, human biting rate (HBR) and entomological inoculation rate (EIR) between different ATSB configurations and control

From: Modelling optimum use of attractive toxic sugar bait stations for effective malaria vector control in Africa

Environment	ATSB configuration	Male abundance		Female abundance		HBR		EIR
Environment	ATSB configuration	Means	% decrease	Means	% decrease	Means	% decrease	Means	% decrease
Resource rich	Control	239.375	0.00	380.781	0.00	6.69513	0.00	0.50085	0.00
	7 × 7	10.06	95.80	6.791	98.22	0.03203	99.52	0.00007	99.99
	5 × 5	31.285	86.93	28.168	92.60	0.18999	97.16	0.00088	99.82
	Periphery 48	96.289	59.77	108.078	71.62	0.66992	89.99	0.00152	99.70
	Periphery 24	99.447	58.46	111.905	70.61	0.69635	89.60	0.00176	99.65
	Transect 50	66.742	72.12	71.676	81.18	0.50966	92.39	0.00101	99.80
	Transect 25	70.795	70.43	75.996	80.04	0.56473	91.57	0.00089	99.82
	Sugar 50	12.723	94.68	9.375	97.54	0.04629	99.31	0.00011	99.98
	Sugar 25	29.25	87.78	26.644	93.00	0.17223	97.43	0.00042	99.92
	House 50	103.22	56.88	118.499	68.88	0.79739	88.09	0.00157	99.69
	House 25	104.922	56.17	121.827	68.01	0.83236	87.57	0.00185	99.63
	Rest 50	16.056	93.29	12.249	96.78	0.0697	98.96	0.00029	99.94
	Rest 25	36.883	84.59	35.806	90.60	0.27758	95.85	0.00198	99.60
	Larval 50	22.01	90.81	20.23	94.69	0.15867	97.63	0.0018	99.64
	Larval 25	49.956	79.13	53.629	85.92	0.51431	92.32	0.00763	98.48
	Random 50	14.545	93.92	11.493	96.98	0.07178	98.93	0.00009	99.98
	Random 25	42.344	82.31	43.48	88.58	0.37372	94.42	0.00643	98.72
	F	94.61		185.46		474.6		42.86
	P	<0.0001		<0.0001		<0.0001		<0.0001
Resource poor	Control	13.716	0.00	15.748	0.00	0.32559	0.00	0.01364	0.00
	7 × 7	2.544	81.45	1.292	91.80	0.00603	98.15	0.00003	99.78
	5 × 5	2.873	79.05	1.65	89.52	0.01071	96.71	0.00003	99.78
	Periphery 48	2.809	79.52	1.974	87.47	0.00898	97.24	0.00015	98.90
	Periphery 24	3.341	75.64	2.371	84.94	0.0113	96.53	0.00006	99.56
	Transect 50	2.601	81.04	1.765	88.79	0.0091	97.21	0.00012	99.12
	Transect 25	3.364	75.47	2.208	85.98	0.0123	96.22	0.0001	99.27
	Sugar 50	3.183	76.79	1.985	87.40	0.01208	96.29	0.00006	99.56
	Sugar 25	3.013	78.03	1.985	87.40	0.01162	96.43	0.00006	99.56
	House 50	2.407	82.45	1.957	87.57	0.00985	96.97	0.00032	97.65
	House 25	2.491	81.84	1.863	88.17	0.01057	96.75	0.00016	98.83
	Rest 50	3.316	75.82	2.215	85.93	0.01626	95.01	0.00009	99.34
	Rest 25	3.967	71.08	2.8	82.22	0.02411	92.59	0	100.00
	Larval 50	5.133	62.58	4.245	73.04	0.04778	85.33	0.0014	89.74
	Larval 25	5.609	59.11	4.48	71.55	0.04869	85.05	0.00099	92.74
	Random 50	2.745	79.99	1.873	88.11	0.01463	95.51	0.0001	99.27
	Random 25	4.234	69.13	3.316	78.94	0.03447	89.41	0.00004	99.71
	F	4.17		9.46		19.2		6.46
	P	<0.0001		<0.0001		<0.0001		<0.0001

Back to article page

ISSN: 1475-2875

Contact us

Submission enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com