Skip to main content

TableĀ 1 Comparison of performance of the six experimental arms against wild Anopheles fluviatilis in experimental huts

From: An experimental hut evaluation of Olyset Plus, a long-lasting insecticidal net treated with a mixture of permethrin and piperonyl butoxide, against Anopheles fluviatilis in Odisha State, India

Arms

Untreated polyester net

Unwashed Olyset Net

Conventionally treated polyester net

Olyset Net washed 20 times

Olyset Plus washed 20 times

Unwashed Olyset Plus

Number of collections

72

72

72

72

72

72

Number of females entered/caught

303

49

41

54

36

32

Number of females caught per night

4.2a

0.7b

0.6b

0.8b

0.5b

0.4b

Deterrence inĀ % (95Ā % CI)

ā€“

83.8a (79.7, 88.0)

86.5a (82.6, 90.3)

82.2a (77.9, 86.5)

88.1a (84.5, 91.8)

89.4a (86.0, 92.9)

Exit rate inĀ % (95Ā % CI)

44.2a (38.6, 49.8)

69.4b (56.5, 82.3)

82.9b (71.4, 94.4)

70.4b (58.2, 82.5)

77.8b (64.2, 91.4)

56.3ab (39.1, 73.4)

Blood feeding inĀ % (95Ā % CI)

77.6a (72.9, 82.3)

26.5b (14.2, 38.9)

7.3b (1.5, 19.9)*

29.6b (17.5, 41.8)

30.6b (15.5, 45.6)

18.8b (5.2, 32.3)

Blood feeding inhibition inĀ % (95Ā % CI)

ā€“

65.9a (45.3, 78.6)

90.6a (71.9, 96.8)

61.9a (42.1, 74.8)

60.6a (35.3, 76.0)

75.8a (50.1, 88.3)

Total mortality inĀ % (95Ā % CI)

2.0a (0.4, 3.5)

100.0b (100, 100)

100.0b (100, 100)

96.3b (87.2, 99.6)*

97.2b (85.5, 99.9)*

100.0b (100, 100)

  1. Numbers in the same row sharing a letter superscript do not differ significantly (PĀ >Ā 0.05)
  2. Total mortalityĀ =Ā Immediate mortalityĀ +Ā Delayed mortality
  3. Confidential intervals (CIs) for percentages are based on normal approximation to binomial distribution, except the CIs marked with asterisk that are based on exact binomial distribution