From: Malaria and the ‘last’ parasite: how can technology help?
Technology | Product | Developer | Description | Type of detection | Performance | Turn-around time | Sample type | Environmental requirements | Cost per test | Cost per instrument | Power/labour/infrastructure requirements | Result display and storage | Quality control |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Microscopy | Parasight | Sight Diagnostics Ltd, 2014 | Automated microscopy suitable for processing of multiple malaria | Slide reading | Under way | n/a | Blood smear | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | ||
Malaria RDTs** | Fio-net | Fio Corporation, 2012 | Universal RDT reader and cloud information services to improve malaria RDT quality assurance and malaria surveillance | Combination of mobile diagnostics (mobile universal reader) with cloud information services | Automated and customising reports Sensitivity and specificity are functions of the RDTs being read | RDTs processing time is dependent on manufacturer’s recommendation Data upload within minutes Daily quality control needed | Depending on RDTs’ manufacturers | Subject to RDTs manufacturers’ recommendations 5–40 °C | Similar to pre-paid cellphone plans | Battery powered Basic 1 day training needed | On screen and web portal | CE marked | |
UMT | Fyodor Biotechnologies, 2015 | A senstitive and specific lateral flow assay detecting novel Plasmodium proteins shed in the urine of febril malaria patients | Dipstick technology (lateral flow assay) | LOD 125 parasites/µL | ~ 20 min | 100 µL urine | n/a | n/a | Usable by lay people | n/a | n/a | ||
Holomic Rapid Diagnostic Reader | Holomic LLC, 2013 | Universal RDT reader attachment for smartphones and software to read RDTs and transmit result to a secure cloud information service | Portable, smartphone-based lateral flow immunoassay reader | Quantitative and qualitative | RDTs processing time is dependent on manufacturer’s recommendation Data upload within seconds | Depending on RDTs’ manufacturers | Subject to RDTs manufacturers’ 5–40 °C | Customisable | $US500 | Battery powered Basic < 0.5 day training needed | User interface of the smartphones application | Class I medical device | |
Nucleic acid detection | LAMP Malaria Diagnostic Kit | Eiken Chemical Ltd and FIND, 2012 | Commercial LAMP test kit containing primers and reagents needed to run assays using benchtop laboratory equipment | Isothermal DNA amplification Fluorescence of visual detection | For pan-LAMP: 97.0% sensitivity For Pf-LAMP: 93.3% sensitivity 85.0% specificity | 60 min | 30–60 µL blood | Stable for 12 months at < 30 °C | $US5 | $US10’000 | Electricity (batter-powered possible) 4 days of training required | Turbidimeter and software | CE marked Positive and negative controls included |
illumigene LAMP | Meridian Bioscience | An automated and compact LAMP technology to qualitatively detect Plasmodium spp. DNA in human whole blood samples | Isothermal DNA amplification | Sensitivity 100% Specificity 89.3% | < 50 min | Human whole blood | Stable for 12 months at 2–30 °C | n/a | Does not require specialised laboratory equipment | n/a | CE marked | ||
MicroPCR | Tulip Group and Bigtec Labs, 2013 | POC real-time quantitative PCR instrument | Fluorescent probe-based real-time PCR | > 99% sensitivity and specificity LOD 2 parasites/µL blood | 45–60 min | 100 µL blood | 15–30 °C | $US15 | $US8000 | Battery powered 1–2 days training required | 5000 test results can be stored internally, cloud information available | CE marked | |
Truelab | Molbio, 2013 | A quantitative micro PCR platform containing all equipment and reagents needed for point-of-care applications | Using the proprietary magnetic nanoparticles to capture DNA | n/a | < 60 min | Whole blood | n/a | n/a | A customised micro printer is available | n/a |