Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of the included studies

From: Global prevalence and mortality of severe Plasmodium malariae infection: a systematic review and meta-analysis

No

Reference

Study area (years of the survey)

Research design

All Plasmodium spp.

Severe malaria

Deaths

Impaired consciousness

Severe anaemia

Renal impairment

Hyperbilirubinaemia

Pulmonary complications

Shock

1.

Bottieau et al. [26]

Belgium (2000–2005)

Prospective cohort study

P. vivax = 48

P. ovale = 34

P. malariae = 16

P. vivax = 8

P. malariae = 3

P. ovale = 4

    

P. vivax = 8

P. ovale = 4

P. malariae = 3

  

2.

Chaparro et al. [23]

Colombia (2010)

Medical records

P. vivax = 82,856

P. falciparum = 32,777

P. malariae = 47

Mixed = 1428

P. falciparum = 282

P. vivax = 293

P. malariae = 6

Mixed = 32

 

P. vivax = 44

P. falciparum = 59 P. malariae = 1

 

P. vivax = 66

P. falciparum = 88

P. malariae = 2

P. vivax = 130

P. falciparum = 99

P. malariae = 1

P. vivax = 34

P. falciparum = 31

P. malariae = 2

 

3.

Douglas et al. [21]

Indonesia (2004–2012)

Medical records

P. falciparum = 44,171

P. vivax = 28,841

P. ovale = 110

P. malariae = 4045

Mixed = 14,206

P. falciparum = 2444

P. vivax = 1050

P. malariae = 95

P. ovale = 0

Mixed = 718

  

P. falciparum = 2466

P. vivax = 1050

P. ovale = 0

P. malariae = 95

Mixed = 718

    

4.

Hwang et al. [24]

USA (1985–2011)

Medical records

P. falciparum = 15,272

P. vivax = 12,152

P. ovale = 903

P. malariae = 1254

Mixed = 226

P. falciparum = 1416

P. vivax = 163

P. malariae = 22

P. ovale = 18

Mixed = No report

P. falciparum = 122

P. vivax = 10

P. ovale = 2

P. malariae = 2

P. falciparum = 514

P. vivax = 37

P. ovale = 4

P. malariae = 2

P. falciparum = 140

P. vivax = 16

P. ovale = 6

P. malariae = 3

P. falciparum = 503

P. vivax = 48

P. ovale = 6

P. malariae = 7

 

P. falciparum = 176

P. vivax = 35

P. ovale = 4

P. malariae = 2

 

5.

Langford et al. [22]

Indonesia (2004–2013)

Medical records

P. falciparum = 100,078

P. vivax = 65,306

P. ovale = 120

P. malariae = 5097

Mixed = 25,779

P. falciparum = No report

P. vivax = No report

P. malariae = 232

P. ovale = No report

Mixed = No report

P. malariae = 16

 

P. falciparum = 2521

P. vivax = 1099

P. ovale = 0

P. malariae = 250

Mixed = 782

P. falciparum = 415

P. vivax = 81

P. ovale = 0

P. malariae = 16

Mixed = 84

 

P. falciparum = 1095

P. vivax = 938

P. ovale = 1

P. malariae = 44

Mixed = 343

 

6.

Wangdahl et al. [25]

Sweden (1995–2015)

Medical records

P. falciparum = 1548

P. vivax = 776

P. ovale = 188

P. malariae = 61

Mixed = 44

P. falciparum = 146

P. vivax = 60

P. malariae = 2

P. ovale = 10

Mixed = 8

P. falciparum = 3

P. vivax = 0

P. ovale = 0

P. malariae = 0

Mixed = 1

P. falciparum = 28

P. vivax = 1

P. ovale = 1

P. malariae = 0

Mixed = 1

P. falciparum = 16

P. vivax = 15

P. ovale = 0

P. malariae = 1

Mixed = 4

P. falciparum = 31

P. vivax = 1

P. ovale = 0

P. malariae = 0

Mixed = 3

P. falciparum = 66

P. vivax = 28

P. ovale = 6

P. malariae = 0

Mixed = 4

P. falciparum = 15

P. vivax = 4

P. ovale = 2

P. malariae = 0

Mixed = 0

P. falciparum = 33

P. vivax = 8

P. ovale = 2

P. malariae = 1

Mixed = 3

 

Total

  

P. falciparum = 93,768 (four studies: 2, 3, 4, 6)

P. vivax = 124,625 (five studies: 1, 2, 3, 4, 6)

P. malariae = 10,520 (all six studies)

P. ovale = 1235 (four studies: 1, 3, 4, 6)

Mixed = 15, 678 (three studies: 2, 3, 6)

P. falciparum = 4, 288 (four studies: 2,3,4,6)

P. vivax = 1574 (five studies: 1, 2, 3, 4, 6)

P. malariae = 360 (all six studies)

P. ovale = 32 (four studies: 1, 3, 4, 6),

Mixed = 758 (three studies: 2, 3, 6)

      Â