Skip to main content

Table 4 A Percentage reduction of female Anopheles gambiae s.l. per trap per village observed comparing ATSB treated sites and control sites; 95% CIs of the mean difference are shown in Fig. 1A. B Reduction of An. gambiae s.l. male catches per trap in ATSB treated sites and control sites with 95% CIs of the mean difference is shown in Fig. 1A

From: Large-scale field trial of attractive toxic sugar baits (ATSB) for the control of malaria vector mosquitoes in Mali, West Africa

 

CDC ATSB sites vs CDC control sites

Malaise ATSB sites vs Malaise control sites

PSC ATSB sites vs PSC control sites

Month

Diff.

95% CI UL

95% CI LL

% reduct

P value

Diff.

95% CI UL

95% CI LL

% reduct

P value

Diff.

95% CI UL

95% CI LL

% reduct

P value

Aa

 Apr

0.06

0.41

0.00

N/A

0.8860

0.05

1.75

0.00

N/A

0.8300

2.30

6.35

0.00

N/A

0.1830

 May

0.11

0.58

0.00

N/A

0.9070

0.33

1.47

0.00

N/A

0.4170

1.63

6.02

0.00

N/A

0.2620

 Jun

0.72

1.19

0.00

94.74

0.0140

0.49

1.29

0.00

83.05

0.0184

1.31

5.96

0.00

71.20

0.0780

 Jul

7.54

17.01

0.00

85.39

0.0010

6.95

14.75

0.00

75.63

0.0030

4.85

9.50

0.20

64.15

0.0180

 Aug

24.95

34.42

15.48

60.47

0.0080

9.30

17.10

1.50

35.89

0.0171

4.44

9.09

0.00

38.18

0.0220

 Sept

30.85

40.34

21.38

57.38

0.0090

17.38

25.18

9.58

44.33

0.0460

9.47

14.12

4.82

48.66

0.0400

 Oct

28.36

37.83

18.89

67.75

0.0010

12.88

20.68

5.08

61.13

0.0060

5.95

10.60

1.30

65.67

0.0100

 Nov

11.48

20.95

2.01

82.18

0.0010

11.20

19.00

3.40

75.22

0.0010

4.07

8.72

0.00

79.18

0.0030

 Dec

4.7

14.17

0.00

91.09

0.0010

5.79

13.59

0.00

84.03

0.0010

2.53

7.18

0.00

87.24

0.0060

Bb

 Apr

0.29

2.54

− 3.12

N/A

0.9200

0.00

3.20

0.00

N/A

0.8300

0.10

1.29

0.00

N/A

0.1830

 May

0.21

2.62

− 3.04

N/A

0.5580

0.83

2.37

0.00

N/A

0.4170

0.10

1.09

0.00

N/A

0.2620

 Jun

0.63

3.46

− 2.20

94.03

0.0076

0.44

3.64

0.00

100.00

0.1840

0.00

1.19

0.00

0.00

0.0480

 Jul

0.01

2.84

− 2.82

0.83

0.0010

2.40

5.60

0.00

48.98

0.0030

1.70

2.89

0.51

56.67

0.0180

 Aug

4.19

7.02

1.36

30.56

0.0110

7.08

10.28

3.88

41.94

0.1710

3.50

4.69

2.31

50.72

0.0220

 Sept

2.81

5.64

− 0.02

28.07

0.0190

4.50

7.70

1.30

36.98

0.0760

4.10

5.29

2.91

45.56

0.0400

 Oct

2.48

5.31

− 0.35

52.99

0.0080

4.02

7.22

0.82

59.82

0.0060

2.10

3.29

0.91

67.74

0.0100

 Nov

0.67

3.50

− 2.16

72.83

0.0015

1.18

4.39

0.00

80.54

0.0001

1.30

2.49

0.11

86.67

0.0030

 Dec

5.14

7.97

2.30

99.73

0.0039

0.46

3.66

0.00

92.00

0.0010

0.30

1.49

0.00

100.00

0.0060

  1. Horizontal line—ATSB treatment
  2. N/A not applicable, pre-treatment monitoring period, Diff. difference between means, UL upper limit, LL lower limit
  3. aP values of the comparison between mean numbers of females caught per trap per village in Fig. 1A are also shown
  4. bP values of the comparison between mean numbers of males caught per trap in Fig. 1A are also shown