Skip to main content

Table 4 Reported data about pfhrp2, pfhrp3 and pfhrp2/3 deletions among RDT false

From: Impact of Plasmodium falciparum pfhrp2 and pfhrp3 gene deletions on malaria control worldwide: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Study WHO region N HRP2-RDT sensitivity (%) False negative rate (%) Negative like-hood ratio P (%) of pfhrp2 deletion (%) P (%) of pfhrp3 deletion (%) P (%) of pfhrp2/3 deletions (%)
Amoah et al. [74] Africa 38 72.66 27.33 0.49 15.79 NR NR
Berhane et al. [14] Africa 31 38 62 NA 100 100 100
Berzosa et al. [21] Africa 122 84.38 15.62 0.18 75.41 78.69 66.39
Beshir et al. [49] Africa 7 82.44 17.5 0.15 85.71 14.29 NR
Bharti et al. [24] Asia 50 76 NA NA 72.00 54.00 50.00
Funwei et al. [69] Africa 31 88.53 9.11 0.001 25.81 12.90 12.90
Gupta et al. [22] Africa 69 85.89 14.11 0.14 1.45 NR 0.0
Koita et al. [28] Africa 26 95 5.16 0.063 38.46 NR 0.0
Kobayashi et al. [52] Africa 69 NA 1.7 NA 4.35 0.00 0.0
Kozycki et al. [11] Africa 140 91.8 NA NA 22.86 NR NR
Kumar et al. [50] Asia 2 95.83 4.17 NA 100 100 100
Maltha et al. [13] South America 21 71.60 28.38 NA 90.48 0.00 90.48
Nderu et al. [9] Africa 91 93.8 6 0.08 0 0.00 NR
Owusu et al. [47] Africa 138 80.78 20.97 0.002 4.35 5.80 4.35
Parr et al. [46] Africa 783 71.55 28.45 NA 19.03 NR NR
Pati et al. [25] Asia 58 84.90 15.1 0.155 48.28 41.38 29.31
Plucinski et al. [51] Africa 5 81 NA NA 40.00 NR 20.00
Thomson et al. [12] Africa 173 89.34 10.66 0.1368 5.20 1.73 1.73
Willie et al. [30] Africa 8 96 12.9 0.144 0.00 NR NR
Wurtz et al. [16] Africa 7 94.07 5.90 NA 42.86 85.71 28.57
  1. N sample size, P prevalence among RDT with negative results, NA not applicable, NR not reported