Skip to main content

Table 3 Descriptive statistics for the combined dataset (N = 85,263)

From: Cooking outdoors or with cleaner fuels does not increase malarial risk in children under 5 years: a cross-sectional study of 17 sub-Saharan African countries

 

Malaria RDT result (N = 74,461)

Malaria Microscopy results (N = 48,491)

Negative N = 48,699 (65.4%)

Positive N = 25,761 (34.6%)

p value

Negative N = 34,802 (71.8%)

Positive N = 13,689 (28.2%)

p value

Proxies for HAP exposure levels

 Cooking fuel

 

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  Electricity

247 (0.5%)

47 (0.2%)

 

196 (0.6%)

22 (0.2%)

 

  LPG

2404 (4.9%)

295 (1.1%)

 

1287 (3.7%)

98 (0.7%)

 

  Natural gas

305 (0.6%)

9 (0.0%)

 

201 (0.6%)

7 (0.1%)

 

  Biogas

38 (0.1%)

8 (0.0%)

 

16 (0.0%)

7 (0.0%)

 

  Kerosene

1256 (2.6%)

220 (0.9%)

 

927 (2.7%)

107 (0.8%)

 

  Coal, lignite

155 (0.3%)

42 (0.2%)

 

103 (0.3%)

24 (0.2%)

 

  Charcoal

10,043 (20.7%)

2297 (8.9%)

 

6368 (18.3%)

1500 (11.0%)

 

  Wood

33,799 (69.5%)

22,397 (87.0%)

 

25,288 (72.8%)

11,602 (84.8%)

 

  Other biomass

370 (0.8%)

417 (1.6%)

 

358 (1.0%)

307 (2.2%)

 

  No food cooked in house

15 (0.0%)

8 (0.0%)

 

7 (0.0%)

2 (0.0%)

 

  Missing

68

22

 

50

13

 

 Cooking location

 

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  In the house

7108 (29.0%)

4129 (29.1%)

 

6326 (31.2%)

2830 (32.2%)

 

  In a separate building

9170 (37.5%)

5068 (35.7%)

 

6468 (31.9%)

2627 (29.9%)

 

  Outdoors

8196 (33.5%)

4994 (35.2%)

 

7482 (36.9%)

3321 (37.8%)

 

  Missing

24,226

11,571

 

14,526

4911

 

Contextual and contextual variables

 Place of residence

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  Urban

17,582 (36.1%)

4683 (18.2%)

 

11,635 (33.4%)

2669 (19.5%)

 

 Season

  

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  Dry

25,169 (51.7%)

11,776 (45.7%)

 

20,750 (59.6%)

6583 (48.1%)

 

 Malarial endemicity

 

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  Mesoendemic

42,772 (87.8%)

19,018 (73.8%)

 

29,351 (84.3%)

9457 (69.1%)

 

  Hyperendemic

5729 (11.8%)

6286 (24.4%)

 

5116 (14.7%)

3971 (29.0%)

 

  Holoendemic

198 (0.4%)

457 (1.8%)

 

335 (1.0%)

261 (1.9%)

 

 Cluster altitude

  

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  Median IQR

294 (85, 596)

321 (156, 590)

 

322 (149, 764)

324 (149, 588)

 

 Household level variables

 Modified Wealth Index

  

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  Lowest

8669 (17.8%)

7714 (29.9%)

 

6633 (19.1%)

3976 (29.0%)

 

  Low

9618 (19.7%)

7306 (28.4%)

 

6925 (19.9%)

3722 (27.2%)

 

  Middle

9919 (20.4%)

5698 (22.1%)

 

6949 (20.0%)

2908 (21.2%)

 

  High

10,886 (22.4%)

3802 (14.8%)

 

7724 (22.2%)

2225 (16.3%)

 

  Highest

9608 (19.7%)

1241 (4.8%)

 

6569 (18.9%)

859 (6.3%)

 

 Household smoking

 

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  No

20,049 (81.6%)

10,852 (76.1%)

 

16,195 (79.5%)

6631 (75.1%)

 

  Missing

24,119

11,497

 

14,430

4860

 

 Number of household members

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  ≤ 6

26,538 (54.6%)

13,007 (50.6%)

 

18,579 (53.5%)

6631 (48.5%)

 

  Missing

68

44

 

51

31

 

 Household insecticide spraying within last 12 months

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  No

18,189 (91.1%)

13,044 (94.9%)

 

17,582 (93.3%)

8527 (95.6%)

 

  Yes

1779 (8.9%)

703 (5.1%)

 

1260 (6.7%)

394 (4.4%)

 

  Missing

28,731

12,014

 

15,960

4768

 

 House construction

  

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  Traditional

28,361 (58.2%)

19,352 (75.1%)

 

20,902 (60.1%)

10,056 (73.5%)

 

  Modern

20,338 (41.8%)

6410 (24.9%)

 

13,900 (39.9%)

3634 (26.5%)

 

Child level variables

 Child’s age (years)

 

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  < 1

7643 (15.7%)

2282 (8.9%)

 

5319 (15.3%)

1272 (9.3%)

 

  1

10,335 (21.2%)

4404 (17.1%)

 

7359 (21.1%)

2186 (16.0%)

 

  2

11,266 (23.1%)

6328 (24.6%)

 

8127 (23.4%)

3239 (23.7%)

 

  3

10,254 (21.1%)

6497 (25.2%)

 

7425 (21.3%)

3568 (26.1%)

 

  4

9201 (18.9%)

6251 (24.3%)

 

6572 (18.9%)

3424 (25.0%)

 

 Birth order

 

< 0.001

   

  First born

14,376 (33.7%)

5338 (24.5%)

 

9392 (30.8%)

2553 (22.1%)

 

  Missing

6102

3993

 

4306

2164

 

 Child’s gender

 

0.068

   

  Male

24,535 (50.4%)

13,112 (50.9%)

 

17,489 (50.3%)

6971 (50.9%)

 

 Child slept under slept under mosquito net last night

< 0.001

  

< 0.001

  Did not sleep under a net

20,615 (42.3%)

12,078 (46.9%)

 

15,858 (45.6%)

6942 (50.7%)

 

  Only treated (ITN) nets

26,991 (55.4%)

13,204 (51.3%)

 

18,320 (52.6%)

6525 (47.7%)

 

  Only untreated nets

1093 (2.2%)

480 (1.9%)

 

624 (1.8%)

222 (1.6%)

 
  1. N: Number of observations; %: column percentage for categorical variables; IQR: interquartile range; ITN: insecticide-treated nets; RDT: rapid diagnostic test