Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparison among malaria testing methods

From: Evaluation of an ultrasensitive HRP2–based rapid diagnostic test for detection of asymptomatic Plasmodium falciparum parasitaemia among children in western Kenya

 

Enrollment

(n = 240)

Follow-up

(n = 120)

All samples

(n = 360)

qPCR positive, n (%)

156 (65.0%)

64 (53.3%)

220 (61.1%)

qPCR density median [IQR] (calculated pRBCs/μL)

19.5 [1.5, 281.1]

13.3 [1.6, 164.4]

17.1 [1.5, 248.9]

Microscopy positive, n (%)

92 (38.3%)

24 (20.0%)

116 (32.2%)

us-RDT positive, n (%)

108 (45%)

45 (37.5%)

153 (42.5%)

Micro sensitivity (%) [95%CI]

53.8 [50.3, 57.3]

35.9 [26.4, 45.4]

48.6 [46.9, 50.3]

us-RDT sensitivity (%) [95%CI]

60.3 [54.6, 66.0]

50.0 [ 50.0, 50.0]

57.3 [53.4, 61.2]

Micro specificity (%) [95%CI]

90.5 [79.1, 100]

98.2 [80.6, 100]

93.6 [84.0, 100]

us-RDT specificity (%) [95%CI]

83.3 [73.0, 93.6]

76.8 [63.7, 89.9]

80.7 [72.6, 88.8]

Micro PPV (%) [95%CI]

91.3 [79.8, 100]

95.8 [78.7, 100]

92.2 [82.7, 100]

us-RDT PPV (%) [95%CI]

87.0 [76.1, 97.9]

71.1 [ 59.6, 82.7]

82.4 [74.1, 90.1]

Micro NPV (%) [95%CI]

51.4 [49.3, 53.5]

57.3 [ 50.4, 64.1]

53.7 [50.9, 56.5]

us-RDT NPV (%)[ 95%CI]

53.0 [49.9, 56.1]

57.3 [50.4, 64.1]

54.6 [51.5, 57.7]