Skip to main content

Table 2 Adherence of healthcare providers to national malaria guidelines, Oct 2016—Jan 2017

From: Adherence of healthcare providers to malaria case management guidelines of the formal private sector in north-western Ethiopia: an implication for malaria control and elimination

Characteristics

PPM facilities

Non-PPM facilities

Chi-square

P-value

Frequency

%

Frequency

%

Diagnosis methods

 Microscopy n1 = 1330

150

83%

72

48%

45.74

0.001

 Multi-species RDTs n2 = 320

16

9%

36

24%

 Presumed malaria n3 = 1,376

14

8%

42

28%

Parasitological confirmed malaria

     

 P. falciparum

92

51.1%

52

46.8%

1.45

0.483

 P. vivax

46

25.6%

36

32.4%

 Mixed (P. f or both P. f and P. v)

28

15.6%

20

18.0%

Treatments adhered to guidelines

P. falciparum, mixed (P. f or both P. f and P. v) & presumed malaria

 AL plus primaquine (sld)

0

0.00%

0

0.00%

NA

NA

 Quinine plus primaquine (sld)

0

0.00%

0

0.00%

P. vivax

 Chloroquine

39

84.8%

29

80.56%

0.255

0.614

Treatments not adhered to guidelines

P. falciparum

 AL or quinine

82

89.1%

12

23.1%

83.31

0.001

 AL plus artemether injection and antibiotics

7

7.6%

0

0.0%

 Artemether injection

3

3.3%

40

76.9%

Mixed (P.f or both P. f and P. v)

 AL or quinine

10

35.7%

2

10.0%

14.1

0.001

 AL plus artemether injection and antibiotics

18

64.3%

8

40.0%

 Artemether injection

0

0.0%

10

50.0%

P. vivax

 AL or chloroquine plus primaquine

3

6.5%

0

0.0%

 

*1.000

 Chloroquine plus artemether injection and antibiotics

2

4.3%

4

11.1%

 Artemether injection

2

4.3%

3

8.3%

Presumed malaria

 AL or quinine

4

28.6%

18

42.9%

 

*0.756

 Artemether injection and antibiotics

1

7.1%

1

2.4%

 Chloroquine

9

64.3%

23

54.8%

  1. NB *Fisher exact test statistic value