Skip to main content

Table 1 Characteristics of studies included

From: Availability of malaria diagnostic tests, anti-malarial drugs, and the correctness of treatment: a systematic review and meta-analysis

First author

Year

Country(s)

Study design

Health facility (n)

Health worker type

Health workers (n)

Febrile patients

Malaria patients (n)

Risk of bias

Signorell [33]

2023

Congo

Cross-sectional

144

NR

NR

4208

3702

Low risk

Mohamoud [34]

2022

Somalia

Cross-sectional

106

95% non-physician

150

NR

50

Low risk

Otambo [35]

2022

Kenya

Cross-sectional

30

Physicians and health workers

NR

1131

257

Low risk

Kibira [36]

2021

Uganda

Cross-sectional

30

NR

NR

NR

330

Moderate risk

Abiodun [17]

2020

Nigeria

Cross-sectional

22

Clinicians and nurses

154

1807

431

Low risk

Cohen [20]

2020

sub-Saharan

Cross-sectional

6453

Physicians, paramedical, CHW, and nurses

7268

24,756

7340

Low risk

Garg [37]

2020

India

Cross-sectional

NR

CHWs

241

3087

825

Moderate risk

Aguemon [38]

2018

Benin

Cross-sectional

27

CHWs

93

NR

313

Low risk

Zurovac [21]

2018

Kenya

Cross-sectional

47

Physicians, nurse

182

1224

366

Low risk

Gallay [39]

2018

Tanzania

Cross-sectional

21

Non-physician, other health workers

187

248

140

Low risk

Plucinski [18]

2017

Angola

Cross-sectional

89

CHWs

212

790

293

Low risk

Namuyinga [19]

2017

Malawi

Cross-sectional

105

Medical assistant, nurse, attendant

150

1427

530

Moderate risk

Pulford [40]

2016

Papua New Guinea

Cross-sectional

NR

CHWs (65%) nurse (30%) others

265

771

122

Low risk

Bamiselu [41]

2016

Nigeria

Cross-sectional

144

70% non-physician

432

NR

NR

Low risk

Zurovac [42]

2015

Vanuatu

Cross-sectional

41

Nurse (80%), nurse aids and midwives (20%)

67

226

NR

Moderate risk

Landman [43]

2015

Haiti

Cross-sectional

30

NR

115

257

11

Low risk

Steinhardt [44]

2014

Malawi

Cross-sectional

107

Medical assistant (75%), clinical officer (25%)

136

1747

629

Moderate risk

Rowe [45]

2009

Angola

Cross-sectional

33

Nurses, physicians

93

177

59

Low risk

Total

7429

9745

41,856

15,398

  1. NR not reported; CHWs community health workers