UvA-DARE ( Digital Academic Repository ) A thirteen-year analysis of Plasmodium falciparum populations reveals high conservation of the mutant pfcrt haplotype despite the withdrawal of chloroquine from national treatment guidelines in Gabon

Background: Chloroquine resistance (CR) decreased after the removal of chloroquine from national treatment guidelines in Malawi, Kenia and Tanzania. In this investigation the prevalence of the chloroquine resistance (CQR) conferring mutant pfcrt allele and its associated chromosomal haplotype were determined before and after the change in Gabonese national treatment guidelines from chloroquine (CQ) to artesunate plus amodiaquine (AQ) in 2003. Methods: The prevalence of the wild type pfcrt allele was assessed in 144 isolates from the years 2005 07 by PCR fragment restriction digest and direct sequencing. For haplotype analysis of the chromosomal regions flanking the pfcrt locus, microsatellite analysis was done on a total of 145 isolates obtained in 1995/96 (43 isolates), 2002 (47 isolates) and 2005 07 (55 isolates). Results: The prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele decreased from 100% in the years 1995/96 and 2002 to 97% in 2005 07. Haplotype analysis showed that in 1995/96 79% of the isolates carried the same microsatellite alleles in a chromosomal fragment spanning 39 kb surrounding the pfcrt locus. In 2002 and 2005 07 the prevalence of this haplotype was 62% and 58%, respectively. Pfcrt haplotype analysis showed that all wild type alleles were CVMNK. Conclusion: Four years after the withdrawal of CQ from national treatment guidelines the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele remains at 97%. The data suggest that the combination of artesunate plus AQ may result in continued selection for the mutant pfcrt haplotype even after discontinuance of CQ usage.


Background
The evolution of CQR has been a major obstacle to global public health [1]. CQR reached Africa in the late seventies and reached a high prevalence across the continent over the following decade [2]. Malawi was the first African country to discontinue the use of CQ in 1993 [3]. Interestingly, the prevalence of the resistant pfcrt allele 76T decreased drastically from 85% to 13% within the following eight years [3,4]. In 2005, a clinical trial showed a 100% efficacy of CQ for treatment of uncomplicated Plasmodium falciparum malaria in children [5]. Recently, Kenya and Tanzania have also reported a decline in CQR after replacement of CQ by sulphadoxine-pyrimethamine (SP), however, this decline occurred at a much slower rate than in Malawi [6,7]. The genetic cause of CQR was found to be a single point mutation changing the amino acid lysine (K) to threonine (T) at position 76 in the gene coding for the P. falciparum CQ resistance transporter (pfcrt) [8][9][10]. This mutation arose only in a small number of founder locations, from where the resistant parasites spread worldwide. As a consequence, the variability of the chromosomal regions flanking the pfcrt gene on chromosome 7 is strongly reduced in resistant parasites, a phenomenon referred to as selective sweep [11]. The chromosomal haplotype -a characterization of this part of the chromosome, assessed either by SNP or microsatellite analysis -is, therefore, highly conserved in resistant parasites and specific for the respective founder locations. In contrast, sensitive parasites generally have very diverse haplotypes [11,12].
In Gabon, CQ use was officially discontinued in 2003 and replaced by the combination of artesunate and AQ. Before the change in national treatment guidelines the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele 76T was repeatedly measured to be 100% [13][14][15]. The goal of this study is to investigate if this change was associated with a return of the wild type pfcrt allele -as has been observed in other African countries -and if it affected genetic diversity in the surrounding chromosomal areas.

Study site and population
All samples were taken from clinical studies conducted at the Albert-Schweitzer-Hospital in Lambaréné, Gabon. Malaria in Lambaréné is hyperendemic with stable transmission throughout the year, the predominant species is P. falciparum [16]. Patients had been recruited in Lambaréné and surroundings (radius approx. 60 km). Informed consent had been obtained by all patients or their guardians and all studies had been approved by the Ethics Committee of the International Foundation of the Albert Schweitzer Hospital. For the 1995/96 cohort, samples from the 1/95C study were analysed [17]. The 2002 cohort consisted of samples from the 2002 case control study [15,18]. For the years 2005 -07 samples were obtained from the Antigenic Diversity Study [19,20], the Ferroquine Tolerance Trial [21], the IPTi Study [22,23] and the SP Efficacy Trial [24].

DNA extraction
Parasite DNA was extracted either from whole blood samples or from dried filter blood spots using the QIAamp ® DNA Mini Kit or DNA Blood Mini Kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) according to the manufacturer's protocol. Extracted DNA was stored at -20°C.

Polymerase chain reaction and sequencing
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was carried out using 2.5 mM MgCl 2 , 0.2 mM denucleoside triphosphates, 0.5 μM forward and reverse primer, 1.5 U Taq polymerase and 5 μl DNA in a total volume of 50 μl. In case of nested PCRs 5 μl PCR product of the first amplification step was used as template in the second step. PCR reagents were obtained from Qiagen, primers were ordered from Operon (Cologne, Germany). Reactions were run in a Biometra Uno II Thermal Cycler (Biometra, Goettingen, Germany), a MyCycler Thermal Cycler (Bio-Rad, Munich, Germany) and a MJ Research PTC-200 (GMI, Ramsey, USA). PCR products were stained with SYBR Green (Biozym, Hess. Oldendorf, Germany) and run on a 1.5% agarose gel. PCR products submitted to sequencing were cut out of the gel, extracted and purified using the NucleoSpin Extract II Kit (Machery-Nagel, Dueren, Germany) according to the manufacturer's protocol. This was followed by a sequencing PCR using 1/10 BigDye Terminator (Applied Biosystems, Warrington, UK) and approx. 1.5 ng DNA/100 bp. 25 cycles were run consisting of melting at 94°C for 10 sec, annealing at 50°C for 5 sec and elongation at 60°C for 4 min. Obtained PCR products were purified using Sephadex 96-well plates (GE Healthcare, Little Chalfont, UK) and sequenced by a Abi Prism 3000 Gene Analyzer (Applied Biosystems). Sequences were displayed with the BioEdit software (Ibis Biosciences, Carlsbad, USA).

Detection of pfcrt mutations by restriction digest and sequencing
CQR of isolates was determined by detection of the mutant or wild type allele of the pfcrt gene at position 76. The CQR conferring mutation K76T as well as seven other resistance associated mutations (M74I, N75E, A220S, Q271E, N326S, I356T, R371I) were detected using a method consisting of a nested PCR followed by mutation specific restriction digestion as described by Djimde et al [25]. The mutations M74I and N75E were directly detected via PCR product sequencing.

Haplotype analysis
The chromosomal haplotype was defined as the specific combination of the alleles of the following six microsatellite markers: PE14D (distance from the pfcrt gene -45 kb), B5M77 (-18 kb), 3E7 (-11 kb), 9B12 (+2 kb), 7A11 (+21 kb) and PE14F (+57 kb). Additionally, the microsatellite B5M47 (-0 kb) was analysed in several isolates of the years 2005 -07 but not taken into account for the haplotype analysis. The position of the individual microsatellites relative to pfcrt is calculated based on their coordinates on Chromosome 7 of the 3D7 genome strain (http://www.plasmodb.org). These differ somewhat from the originally reported distances by Wootton et al [11]. Alleles were determined as differences in repeat length. The repeat sequence motifs of the different microsatellites were as follows: PE14D (TAC)/ (TAA), B5M77 (TA), 3E7 (TA)/(T)/(TA), 9B12 (TA), 7A11 (TTATA), PE14F (TAA). In case of multiple infections only samples with a clear dominance of one microsatellite allele in the sequence ferrogram were included for further analysis [12].
Microsatellite markers were amplified via PCR and sequenced. Primers and conditions were adapted from Su et al [26] but resulted in suboptimal amplification in field isolates. Therefore conditions had to be modified for all microsatellites and in most cases a nested PCR approach had to be implemented (see Additional file 1). The strains 3D7, Dd2 and FCR3 were used as positive PCR controls. The consistency of primers and conditions was verified by sequencing of the PCR amplification products of the control strains and comparing the obtained microsatellite sequences with the known sequences deposited in the NCBI database, which always showed a perfect match of the repeat lengths.
Chromosomal haplotype studies were done on 171 resistant samples from the years 1995 -2007. Successful sequencing of the full set of microsatellites was achieved in 132 samples. In 145 samples at least the inner four microsatellites (B5M77, 3E7, 9B12, 7A11) covering a chromosomal fragment of approximately 40 kb could be sequenced. These samples consisted of 43 samples from the 1995/96 cohort, 47 samples of the 2002 cohort and 55 samples of the 2005 -7 cohort. All sequences were submitted to Genbank. Individual samples can be identified through their study specific label, consisting of a study specific combination of letters and an isolate specific running number, as indicated below: 1/95C study (M or S, followed by a number, i.e. M1), 2002 case control study (N followed by a number, i.e. N1), Antigenic Diversity Study (three individual letters, i.e. MOA), the Ferroquine Tolerance Trial (TDU or FED or TDR, followed by a number, i.e. TDU1), IPTi Study (IP followed by a number, i.e. IP1), SP Efficacy Trial (SP followed by a number, i.e. SP1). Genbank accession numbers are: 3E7 sequences: HQ417163 -HQ417327, 7A11 sequences: HQ417328 -HQ417497, 9B12 sequences: HQ417498-HQ417655, B5M77 sequences: HQ417656 -HQ417824, PE14D sequences: HQ417825 -HQ417986, PE14F sequences: HQ417987-HQ418152. Primers and conditions for an allele specific nested PCR were as described by [27]. MSP2 1 st step: forward primer F1 ATGAAGGTAATTAAAACATTGTCTAT-TATA and reverse primer F2 ATATGGCAAAAGAT AAAACAAGTGTTGCTG, 94°C for 5 min, followed by 30 cycles of 94°C for 10 sec, 57°C for 30 sec, 72°C for 30 sec, and a final extension step of 72°C for 2 min. MSP2 2 nd step FC allele: forward primer FC27 F2 GCAAATGAAGGTTCTAATACTAATAG and reverse primer FC27 R2 GCTTTGGGTCCTTCTTCAGTT-GATTC, MSP2 2 nd step 3D7 allele: forward primer 3D7 F2 GCAGAAAGTAAGCCTTCTACTGGTGCT and reverse primer 3D7 R2 GATTTGTTTCGGCATTAT-TATGA. PCR was carried out using the following conditions 94°C for 5 min, followed by 40 cycles of 94°C for 10 sec, 57°C for 30 sec, 72°C for 30 sec, and a final extension step of 72°C for 2 min.

Statistical analysis
Conservation of any marker or haplotype was defined as the prevalence of the dominant allele. Development of the degree of conservation over the years was analysed by logistic regression. A chi-square test was applied for assessment of significance. Allele diversity was described by the expected heterozygosity H e using the formula: with n being the number of isolates and p i the frequency of the ith allele [28]. Development of H e over the years was analysed by linear regression, an F test was applied for assessment of significance. In all applied tests p-values < 0.05 were regarded as significant.

Results
Prevalence of the mutant and wild type pfcrt allele before and after the withdrawal of chloroquine In order to display the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele after 2003, 144 samples from the years 2005 -07 were screened for the CQR conferring mutant 76T pfcrt allele. The restriction digest revealed only one sample with a wild type 76K pfcrt allele, thus a genetically sensitive isolate, in 90 samples from the years 2005/06 (1%) and three isolates with the wild type 76K pfcrt allele in 54 samples from 2007 (6%) (of the wild type isolates three were monoinfections and one was a mixed infection). Overall the prevalence of the mutant 76T pfcrt allele remained at 97% after the withdrawal of chloroquine from national treatment guidelines. Previous analysis of 151 samples from the years 1995/96 and 2002 had shown a prevalence of 100% for the mutant 76T allele [13][14][15]. For this investigation an additional 64 samples of these studies were analysed. The mutant 76T pfcrt allele was detected in all samples. Thus, in total all 215 analysed samples from the years 1995/96 and 2002 carried the mutant 76T pfcrt allele, confirming the very high prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele in this area prior to the change in national treatment guidelines (see Table 1).
Pfcrt haplotype analysis was conducted in the three wild type isolates that were monoinfections and 48 randomly picked mutant isolates from the years 2005 -7. Sequencing of the three monoinfections showed that all carried the original wild type pfcrt haplotype CVMNK at the codons 72-76 and AQNIR at the codons 220, 271, 326, 356, 371. The reappeared wild type pfcrt allele thus did not result from a simple back mutation from T to K at codon 76. Sequencing of 48 randomly picked mutant isolates from the years 2005-7 showed that they uniformly carried the CVIET haplotype at the codons 72-76.

Chromosome 7 haplotype characterization of mutant and wild type isolates
To assess the effect of chloroquine pressure on the chromosomal haplotype, microsatellite allele analysis was initally performed on isolates from 1995/6. For characterization of the chromosome fragment surrounding the pfcrt gene six microsatellite markers were sequenced (PE14D, B5M77, 3E7, 9B12, 7A11, PE14F) covering a chromosomal fragment of approximately 100 kb (see Figure 1). Analysis of the obtained haplotypes revealed the presence of two most prevalent haplotypes in 1995/96. One haplotype was identical to the haplotype of the resistant lab strain FCR3 [11] (assumed to represent the dominant resistant haplotype in Africa and differing from Dd2 at the microsatellite 7A11) at all six analysed microsatellites and was found in 21% of the samples. The other haplotype, termed "Lamba", showed a different allele at the most centromeric marker PE14F (see Figure 1) and was prevalent in 37%. Together we defined these two haplotypes as the dominant local resistant haplotypes.
To assess whether the newly appeared pfcrt sensitive isolates from the years 2005-7 represented immigrated strains or local formerly resistant strains that had reacquired the wild type pfcrt allele, haplotype analysis of the wild type isolates was performed. Haplotype analysis was possible in the three monoinfections (samples SP15, SP21, TDU28) of the four wild type isolates. The isolates SP21 and TDU28 carried haplotypes with no resemblance to the dominant local resistant haplotypes. In contrast, the haplotype of isolate SP15 was identical to the dominant local resistant haplotypes at the most telomeric microsatellites PE14D and B5M77 and only started to diverge at microsatellite 3E7, approximately 11 kb upstream of the pfcrt locus (see Figure 1). This suggested that SP15 might have resulted from a backcross of a wild type pfcrt allele into a local resistant isolate.  To assess genetic change in the chromosomal areas immediately adjacent to the pfcrt locus a local "inner" haplotype was defined as the chromosomal fragment defined by the four microsatellites B5M77, 3E7, 9B12, 7A11, covering a region of approximately 40 kb around the pfcrt locus. This revealed that in 1995/96 79% of the analysed isolates carried one identical haplotype in this chromosomal region. In analogy to the six-microsatellite-haplotype, the prevalence of this dominant local "inner" haplotype remained relatively high throughout the years, but showed a statistically significant decrease to 62% in 2002 and 58% in 2005 -07 (p = 0.03, see Table 3). Again, the decrease in conservation was most pronounced between 1995/6 and 2002, before the change in national treatment guidelines.
To evaluate the propensity for genetic change at the individual microsatellite markers, the change in conservation from 1995/6 to 2005 -07 was evaluated. This revealed a significant decrease in conservation at the two most centromeric microsatellites 7A11 (p = 0.04) and PE14F (p = 0.02) while the other microsatellite markers remained conserved.
In order to assess the degree of genetic diversity at the individual microsatellites over the years, their expected heterozygosity H e during the different time periods (see Figure 2) was determined. As expected, H e was smallest at the microsatellites directly adjacent to the pfcrt locus and largest at the most distant microsatellites. During all time periods H e increased with increasing distance from the pfcrt locus. Furthermore, H e was higher at the centromeric microsatellites 9B12, 7A11 and PE14F compared to the telomeric microsatellites 3E7, B5M77 and PE14D, again suggesting a higher degree of genetic variability in the centromeric microsatellites. A trend towards increasing diversity over time was apparent for the two most centromeric microsatellites 7A11 and PE14F, however this was not statistically significant.

Genetic diversity at the msp2 gene
The analysis suggested that the genetic sweep on chromosome 7 persisted in the local parasite population despite the removal of CQ from the national treatment guidelines. To estimate the potential diversity in the Lambaréné parasite population, the expected heterozygosity at the locus coding for MSP2, a surface antigen with a presumably high diversity was also determined. The msp2 locus from 50 isolates of the years 2005 -07 was PCR amplified and the respective 3D7 (30) and FC27 (40) fragments were sequenced. A total of 48 different alleles were identified. The H e for the msp2 locus was calculated to be 0.98. In comparison, the mean genomic H e of African P. falciparum parasites was assessed to be 0.76 -0.8 [28]. Of the microsatellites analysed in the 2005 -07 population only the least conserved marker PE14F had a H e within that range (0.76). Contrasting, the microsatellite B5M47 lying directly adjacent to the pfcrt locus had a H e of 0.11 (see Table  4). Taken together, this shows that the potential for genetic diversity is very high in this population and highlights the high degree of genetic conservation surrounding the mutant pfcrt gene on chromosome 7.

Discussion
This is the first report analysing the effect of the withdrawal of CQ from the national treatment guidelines in 2003 on the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele in Lambaréné, Gabon. Prior to the change in national treatment policy the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele 76T had been 100% [13,14]. However, even in the years 2005 -07 the level of CQR was still as high as 97%. Thus the decrease of CQR after discontinuance of CQ use observed in Gabon is much smaller compared to the development in Malawi where resistance decreased within eight years from 85% to 13% [3,4], as well as compared to other African countries such as Kenya [7] and Tanzania [6] where recent reports also documented a decrease in CQR from 95% to 60% and 94% to 70% respectively, after national CQ stops. What explanations can be invoked to explain the differences in the decline of CQR in these countries and Gabon?
The resurgence of CQS in Malawi, Kenya and Tanzania was observed after changes in national treatment guidelines from CQ to SP. In contrast, Gabon changed its national treatment guidelines from CQ to the combination of artesunate plus AQ. AQ is structurally related to CQ with both belonging to the group of 4-aminoquinolines. A recent report from Ghana analysed the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele after a change in national treatment guidelines from CQ to artesunate and AQ. The authors observed a decrease in the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele only in the northern part of the country, raising the question if this effect truly represented a national trend [29]. In contrast, a recent report from the Gabonese region of Franceville showed no change in the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele after the change in national treatment guidelines [30]. Data from clinical trials and the 7G8xGB4 and HB3xDd2 genetic crosses clearly suggest that AQ strongly selects for the resistance conferring mutant pfcrt allele [31,32]. Analysis of progeny of the 7G8xGB4 genetic cross showed that the South American pfcrt haplotype SVMNT at the codons 72-76 is associated with high level resistance against monodesethylamodiaquine, the active metabolite of AQ. Reports from Angola [33] and Tanzania [34] have shown the presence of the SVMNT pfcrt haplotype following the use of artesunate and AQ or the single use AQ, suggesting that AQ may select for this haplotype [35]. However, none of the 48 randomly sequenced mutant pfcrt alelles from the years 2005 -07 carried the SVMNT haplotpype in this analysis of the Lambaréné parasite population. In view of the high conservation of the chromosomal regions flanking the pfcrt gene even in 2005 -07 this may simply reflect the continued selection of the most abundant pfcrt haplotype CVIET. The introduction of the SVMNT haplotype may thus be influenced by the specific characteristics of local parasite populations. Taken together the data suggest that in Gabon the introduction of artesunate plus AQ may have selected for continued conservation of the mutant pfcrt locus.
Interestingly, a decrease in conservation of the local resistant chromosomal haplotypes was observed between 1995/96 and 2002, prior to the removal of CQ from the national treatment guidelines. A similar phenomenon was observed in Kenya, where CQR started to decline prior to the official change in national treatment guidelines, possibly as a consequence of declining use due to decreased clinical effectiveness. Similarly, local treatment guidelines at the Albert Schweitzer Hospital were already changed in 1994 -from CQ to SP. A decrease in CQ pressure might thus have contributed to more genetic diversity surrounding the pfcrt locus, however the resurgence of CQS might have been precluded due to the continued use of CQ in the surrounding areas. This is supported by an overall increase of different resistant haplotypes from 1995 to 2002 and by the decrease in prevalence of the most common "local resistant haplotypes". What could be the mechanism that led to the reappearance of the wild type pfcrt allele? None of seven point mutations in the pfcrt gene commonly found in CQR strains from Africa and Asia [11,36] were present in any of the genetically sensitive isolates, who thus appear to be genuine wild type pfcrt alleles. This rules out the possibility that the sensitive isolates originated from a simple back mutation at the crucial position 76 of the pfcrt gene in former resistant parasites and is consistent with the results of others [3][4][5]. The implication of this finding is that the wild type pfcrt allele must have been reintroduced into the current population through import from another geographic area, or by reexpansion of sensitive parasites that were under the detection level of previous investigations. However, given the persistently high prevalence of the resistant haplotypes the former possibility appears more likely. Chromosome 7 haplotype analysis of the three sensitive monoinfections showed no conservation of microsatellite alleles. Comparison to the local resistant population showed that one (isolate SP15) shared the two microsatellites PE14D and B5M77 at the most telomeric end of the analysed haplotype with the dominant local resistant haplotypes. To estimate the likelihood that the SP15 haplotype resulted from a cross of a local resistant and a sensitive isolate, the number of resistant parasites with the same PE14D and B5M77 alleles as SP15 was quantified. Of the 172 haplotypes analysed in the study, 107 carried the exactly same PE14D-7A11 microsatellite alleles as SP15, suggesting that SP15 might represent a genetic cross between a sensitive strain and a formerly resistant strain of the local population.

Conclusions
The data presented in this manuscript show that four years after the discontinuance of CQ as first-line therapy in Gabon the prevalence of the mutant pfcrt allele is still extremely high in the Lambaréné area. This finding stands in marked contrast to a more pronounced development towards CQS in some other African countries. One possible explanation may be an ongoing selection for the mutant pfcrt allele by AQ as part of an artemisinin-based combination therapy. It has repeatedly been proposed that CQ may return to clinical use in the future. The results of this investigation and the result of others [6,7] sound a note of caution and clearly show that this can only be contemplated in areas where the return of CQ sensitivity has clearly been demonstrated by molecular drug sensitivity monitoring.

Additional material
Additional file 1: Primers and conditions for microsatellite PCR amplification. Authors' contributions MF conceived the study and designed the experiments, NL carried out the molecular genetic studies on microsatellites and on the msp2 gene, PM carried out part of the msp2 analysis and extracted the DNA of part of the 1995/6 and 2002 samples, FN supervised part of the msp2 analysis, DUK and MDB conducted the Antigenic Diversity Study, JG, GMN, MG conducted the IPTi study and the SP Efficacy trial, GMN, CS, BL conducted the Ferroquine tolerance trial, KD performed the statistical analysis, PK coordinated the study and provided conceptual advice. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.