Assessing the impact of differences in malaria transmission intensity on clinical and haematological indices in children with malaria

Background Malaria control interventions have led to a decline in transmission intensity in many endemic areas, and resulted in elimination in some areas. This decline, however, will lead to delayed acquisition of protective immunity and thus impact disease manifestation and outcomes. Therefore, the variation in clinical and haematological parameters in children with malaria was assessed across three areas in Ghana with varying transmission intensities. Methods A total of 568 children between the ages of 2 and 14 years with confirmed malaria were recruited in hospitals in three areas with varying transmission intensities (Kintampo > Navrongo > Accra) and a comprehensive analysis of parasitological, clinical, haematological and socio-economic parameters was performed. Results Areas of lower malaria transmission tended to have lower disease severity in children with malaria, characterized by lower parasitaemias and higher haemoglobin levels. In addition, total white cell counts and percent lymphocytes decreased with decreasing transmission intensity. The heterozygous sickle haemoglobin genotype was protective against disease severity in Kintampo (P = 0.016), although this was not significant in Accra and Navrongo. Parasitaemia levels were not a significant predictor of haemoglobin level after controlling for age and gender. However, higher haemoglobin levels in children were associated with certain socioeconomic factors, such as having fathers who had any type of employment (P < 0.05) and mothers who were teachers (P < 0.05). Conclusions The findings demonstrate significant differences in the haematological presentation and severity of malaria among areas with different transmission intensity in Ghana, indicating that these factors need to be considered in planning the management of the disease as the endemicity is expected to decline after control interventions.

artemisinin combination therapy (ACT), have significantly decreased malaria transmission. This has led to a greater than 50% decline in malaria-related mortality in the last decade, from over a million deaths to under 500,000 annually [1,5]. Since clinical manifestations of malaria vary with differences in transmission levels [6,7], it is likely that the decreasing transmission intensities will be accompanied by significant changes in clinical and haematological indicators of disease severity. Studies in north-eastern Tanzania have indicated that decreasing levels of malaria transmission results in an increase in the median age of children with malaria, a reduction in the incidence of malaria and an increase in case fatality [8]. Similar findings in the Gambia and Kenya confirm that average age and risk of fatal disease is highest among children living in low endemic areas, in comparison to areas of high endemicity [7]. Therefore, as many countries deploy malaria elimination strategies, a comprehensive analysis of the impact of decreasing malaria transmission on clinical and haematological indicators of disease is necessary to inform appropriate management of a changing malaria phenotype.
Given the significant effects of common haemoglobinopathies on malaria severity observed in a recent large cohort study [9], a comprehensive study of clinical and haematological parameters must include an investigation of the role of these genetic factors. Haemoglobin S (HbS) and haemoglobin C (HbC) variants are common in malaria-endemic populations in West Africa, with more than a quarter of the population carrying one variant or the other in many areas [9,10]. Heterozygous carriers of HbS (i.e. sickle cell trait, HbAS) are protected against severe and fatal forms of malaria [11,12]. This protection is thought to be achieved by preventing the development of high density parasitaemia [13][14][15], and accelerating the acquisition of natural immunity to malaria in carriers [16]. Studies conducted in Ghana [17] and elsewhere [12,13,18] have confirmed the protection conferred by sickle cell trait. However, the protective role of HbC remains has been less frequently demonstrated, although most studies show significant protective effects [19][20][21], whereas one study did not show significant evidence of protection [22]. In Ghana, studies have shown that HbC protects against malaria, though to a lesser extent compared to HbS [17,23].
This study took advantage of the significant differences in malaria transmission across ecological zones in Ghana, to analyse the variation in key clinical and haematological parameters in children with malaria exposed to different transmission intensity.

Sample collection
Study participants were recruited in hospitals in three ecologically distinct areas in Ghana, namely: the Ledzokuku Krowor municipal (LEKMA) hospital in Accra; War Memorial Hospital, Navrongo in the Kassena and Nankana districts in Northern Ghana, and Kintampo Municipal Hospital in the Kintampo Municipality in the middle belt of Ghana. Malaria transmission intensity as measured by the entomological inoculation rates [EIR reported as infective bites per person per year (ib/p/y)] are highest in Kintampo (>250 ib/p/y), followed by Navrongo (<200 ib/p/y), and lowest in Accra (<50 ib/p/y) [24][25][26]. A detailed description of the study sites is presented in a recent report [27].
Children between the ages of 2-14 years who had lived in the community for at least 6 months and presented with symptoms of malaria were screened for malaria with rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs) using a drop of blood from a finger prick. After obtaining informed consent from guardians of RDT-positive children, 0.5 mL of blood was collected into EDTA-coated vacutainer tubes (BD biosciences) for parasitological and haematological analysis.

Determination of clinical and haematological indices
Haemoglobin levels, erythrocyte indices [red blood cell (RBC) counts, mean corpuscular volume (MCV), mean corpuscular haemoglobin (MCH), mean corpuscular haemoglobin concentration (MCHC), and red cell distribution width (RDW)], leucocyte indices [total white blood cell (WBC) count, percent lymphocytes (LYM%), percent monocytes (MON%), percent granulocytes (GRA%), and platelet indices [platelet count (PLT), mean platelet volume (MPV), and platelet distribution width (PDW)] were analysed using an automated haematology analyser. Thick blood smears were stained with Giemsa and examined for parasites using oil immersion microscopy. Parasite density per µL of blood was determined by counting the number of parasites per 200 WBCs and multiplying by the total WBC count obtained from an automated haematology analyser.

Determination of haemoglobin types
Haemoglobin types were determined by Hb electrophoresis according to manufacturer's instructions (Helena Laboratories, Beaumont, TX, USA). Briefly, whole blood was haemolysed using haemolysing reagent containing 0.005 M EDTA with 0.01% potassium cyanide. Patient haemolysates and controls were then loaded on to cellulose acetate plates and electrophoresed at 350 V for 25 min in a Tris-EDTA/boric acid buffer (pH 8.4, ionic strength 0.035). Hb electrophorotypes were identified by comparing to control bands.

Classification of disease severity
Studies have shown that the WHO definition of severe malarial anaemia of <5.0 g/dL with ≥10,000 parasites/ µL is restrictive as it excludes children who do not meet the criteria of >10,000 parasite/µL, but still have potentially fatal malarial anaemia [28]. In order to determine the true association between malarial anaemia and the clinical, haematological and socio-demographic factors examined in this study, a more inclusive criteria for severe malarial anaemia of <5.0 g/dL with any parasitaemia, was used, which has also be described by others [7]. Due to the low sample size of the severe malaria groups, children with severe malarial anaemia were grouped with those with moderate malarial anaemia in order to increase statistical power. Thus children with Hb < 8.0 g/dL with any parasitaemia were grouped as having moderate-to-severe malarial anaemia, since previous studies have identified this group as being at increased risk of malaria associated mortality [29]. Children recruited into this study were, therefore, classified into three categories based on the severity of malarial anaemia. The categories were defined as: (1) Uncomplicated malaria (UM): Children with a malaria-positive smear for P. falciparum parasitaemia (of any density) without anaemia (i.e., Hb ≥11.0 g/dL); (2) mild malarial anaemia (MMA): children with a malariapositive smear for P. falciparum parasitaemia (of any density) with 8.0 ≤ Hb < 11 g/dL; (3) Moderate-to-severe malarial anaemia (MSMA): children with a malaria-positive smear for P. falciparum parasitaemia (of any density) with Hb <8.0 g/dL. For some analyses, participants were classified according to parasite density, using ≥10,000 parasites/µL as definition for high-density parasitaemia.

Statistical analysis
Data were analysed using Minitab (version 17). Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests were used to determine normality of the data before application of further tests. One way ANOVA or Kruskal-Wallis tests were applied for across group comparisons for normally and non-normally distributed data respectively. Post-hoc tests of either student t test or Mann-Whitney U tests were applied for pairwise analysis where necessary. Chi square analysis was used to compare categorical variables and determine likelihood ratio for association. Univariate and multivariate regression analyses were carried out to determine the predictors of malaria severity. For all analyses, P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Comparison of clinical and demographic parameters across transmission areas
To investigate the variation in clinical presentation of malaria as transmission reduces, a total of 568 malaria positive children aged between 2 and 14 years, who were exposed to different intensities of P. falciparum transmission (Kintampo > Navrongo > Accra) were enrolled. While there was no difference in the proportion of females recruited at each site (Table 1), children enrolled in Accra were generally older than children recruited in Navrongo (P < 0.001) and Kintampo (P < 0.001). In addition, haemoglobin levels increased with decreasing transmission intensity, and were significantly higher in children in Accra compared to Navrongo and Kintampo (P < 0.001 for both comparisons; Table 1). Parasitaemia levels increased with transmission intensity, with the Kintampo group having the highest parasitaemia (P < 0.001 vs Navrongo and vs Accra). In addition, parasitaemia levels in children in Navrongo were significantly higher than in Accra (P = 0.007; Table 1). These data, therefore, suggest that clinical presentation of malaria shifts towards lower parasitaemias and higher haemoglobin levels as transmission intensity reduces.

Comparison of haematological parameters in children with malaria across transmission areas
The associations between transmission intensity and haematological indices was also investigated by comparing erythrocyte, leucocyte, and platelet indices in children with malaria across the study sites. RBC counts were significantly higher in areas of lower transmission, mirroring the pattern observed for haemoglobin levels (P < 0.001 for both Accra vs Navrongo and Accra vs Kintampo; Table 2). However, MCV was lowest in the area of lowest transmission, with levels in children in Accra being significantly lower than those in Navrongo (P < 0.001) and Kintampo

Table 1 Demographic and clinical characteristics of study participants
Relative malaria transmission intensities as measured by entomological inoculation rates in the areas are in the order Kintampo > Navrongo > Accra Data for age, haemoglobin, and parasitaemia are presented as means (standard error of the mean, SEM) * P value obtained from Chi square test, ** P value obtained from ANOVA  Table 2). MCHC and RDW did not appear to directly relate to transmission intensity, with both indices showing the highest levels in Navrongo (P < 0.001 for across group comparisons for both indices, Table 2). Total WBC counts, as well as percentage lymphocytes in children with malaria decreased with decreasing transmission intensity across the three sites (P = 0.029 and P < 0.001, respectively, Table 2). Percentage monocytes was significantly lower in children in Navrongo, compared to children in Kintampo (P < 0.001) and Accra (P < 0.001), while percentage granulocytes was lowest in Kintampo, compared to children in Navrongo (P < 0.001) and Accra (P < 0.001). Platelet counts and PDW were both highest in Navrongo (P = 0.008 and P < 0.001 across groups, respectively, Table 2), suggesting no direct relationship with transmission intensity. MPV increased with decreasing malaria transmission levels, with children from Accra showing significantly higher levels relative to Navrongo (P < 0.001) and Kintampo (P < 0.001; Table 2).

Impact of haemoglobin S and C on clinical and haematological indices
The impact of haemoglobins S and C on the clinical and haematological indicators of disease severity was investigated in the entire cohort of children with malaria. Haemoglobin levels differed between children with HbAS compared to HbAA genotype (P = 0.033). However, there was no significant difference in haemoglobin levels in children with HbC genotypes relative to those with the HbAA genotype (P = 0.975; Table 3). RBC counts were not significantly different across the haemoglobin genotypes, but RDW values were relatively higher in the HbAS group relative to the HbAA and HbAC genotypes (Table 3). On the other hand, MCV and MCH levels were lower in the HbAS and HbAS groups relative to the HbAA group. Platelets counts were significantly higher in HbAS relative to HbAA (P = 0.020), however, there was no difference between the HbAC and HbAA groups (P = 0.567; Table 3). MPV levels were lower in the HbAS and HbAC groups relative to HbAA. The remaining indices were not significantly different across the groups (Table 3). Additional analysis examined the relationship between haemoglobin genotypes and peripheral parasite densities in children recruited from the three study sites separately. These analyses showed a protective effect of HbAS ( Fig. 1), with parasite densities significantly lower in children with HbAS compared to the HbAA group (P = 0.016) in children from Kintampo, although the difference was not significant at the other sites.

Determinants of malaria severity
Since disease severity in this cohort was generally characterized by anaemia, the children with malaria were stratified into three categories based on haemoglobin levels: UM (Hb ≥ 11 g/dL, n = 194), MMA (8.0 ≤ Hb < 11 g/dL, n = 279) and MSMA (Hb < 8.0 g/

Table 2 Comparison of haematological indices in children with malaria across three transmission areas
Data are presented as medians (first quartile-third quartile) Relative malaria transmission intensities as measured by entomological inoculation rates in the areas are in the order Kintampo > Navrongo > Accra  dL n = 65). The relationship between malaria severity and various demographic, clinical and haematological parameters was then examined by comparing across the malaria groups. Children with UM were significantly older than children with MMA (P < 0.001) and MSMA (P < 0.001; Fig. 2a). Children with MSMA were also significantly younger than children with MMA (P = 0.003; Fig. 2a). Comparison across areas suggests that lower transmission was associated with less severity of malarial anaemia, such that the proportion of patients from Accra who had MSMA was significantly lower than that observed in Navrongo (P = 0.002) and Kintampo (P < 0.001; Fig. 2b), although differences in age distributions of children sampled in the different sites may account for this. Conversely, the proportion of children with UM in the Accra group was significantly higher than the corresponding proportions in Navrongo (P = 0.004) and Kintampo (P < 0.001; Fig. 2b). There were no significant differences in the proportions of children with MMA across the three sites (P = 0.104).  The relationships of anaemia severity with parasite density and haemoglobin types was also investigated. There was no significant relationship between high density parasitaemia (≥10,000 parasites/µL) and anaemia severity. There was however, evidence of the protective effects of HbAS, such that children with this genotype had a significantly lower proportion of MSMA (P = 0.011) and a higher proportion of UM (P < 0.001) compared to the HbAA group (Fig. 2d). There were no significant differences in proportions of disease in the HbAC group compared to HbAA group (P = 0.685, Fig. 2d), indicating that the protective effects were specific for HbAS only.

Relationship between haematological factors and anaemia severity
To determine indicators of disease severity, haematological indices were compared across the three categories. With the exception of RDW, all red cell indices examined were lower in the malarial anaemia groups compared to UM (Table 4), which was expected since anaemia is primarily a red cell-related disease. In particular, RBC counts and MCV decreased with increasing anaemia severity across the groups (P < 0.001 and P = 0.003; Table 4). In addition, MCH levels were significantly lower in children with MMA (P < 0.001) and MSMA (P < 0.001) compared to the UM group P = 0.002). MCHC levels were significantly lower in children with MMA compared to children with UM (P < 0.001); this was not the case in children with MSMA compared to children in the UM group (P = 0.075). However, RDW increased with increasing anaemia severity across the groups (Table 4), indicating an erythropoietic response. Leucocyte and platelet indices, including, GRA percent, PLT counts and PDW) also decreased with increasing anaemia severity, while LYM and MON percentages increased across the groups (Table 4). Total WBC counts were not significantly different in any of the malarial anaemia groups when compared to children with UM (Table 4).

Socio-demographic predictors of anaemia severity and parasitaemia
Multiple regression analyses were performed to determine the socio-demographic predictors of haemoglobin level and parasitaemia, as these are the main clinical indicators of anaemia severity in this cohort. Although Fig. 2 Determinants of malarial anaemia severity in children. Children with malaria were divided into three categories based on haemoglobin levels: UM (Hb ≥ 11 g/dL, n = 194), MMA (8.0 ≤ Hb < 11 g/dL, n = 279) and MSMA (Hb < 8.0 g/dL n = 65). The relationships between severity of malarial anaemia and a age b study area c parasite density and d haemoglobin genotype were investigated using Kruskal-Wallis test for age and Chi square analysis for study area, parasite density categories, and haemoglobin genotypes several factors were associated with haemoglobin levels in univariate analyses (unadjusted regression coefficients; Table 5), after adjusting for covariates including sickle cell trait and age, it was seen that the father's educational level as well as the occupations of both parents were significant predictors of haemoglobin levels (adjusted regression coefficients; Table 5). Females were more likely to have lower Hb levels, whilst children whose fathers had middle school education, or better, had higher haemoglobin levels (Table 5). Furthermore, children whose mothers were teachers, and those whose fathers had any kind of employment, were less likely to be anaemic (Table 5). More interestingly, after adjustment for covariates including age, transmission intensity was not a significant predictor of haemoglobin levels.
A significant predictor of parasite density was ecological zone (sampling site) and the self-reported use of bed nets. As expected, children in Navrongo and Kintampo were more likely to have higher parasitaemia, which is consistent with the reported EIR for these areas.

Discussion
As a result of concerted intervention strategies, malaria transmission in endemic areas has been declining in the last decade, resulting in a cumulative drop in the incidence of malaria cases worldwide [1]. However, since clinical manifestations of malaria appear to be significantly influenced by transmission intensity [6,7], the impact of the decreasing transmission on clinical and haematological indices during malaria should be an important consideration in planning for the long-term management of the disease. Using the varying transmission intensity across three well-characterized areas in Ghana as a model, data presented here demonstrate that decreasing transmission leads to a shift in the vulnerable group to slightly older children. This shift was accompanied by a reduced disease severity in children with malaria, characterized by lower parasitaemias, higher haemoglobin levels and higher erythrocyte counts. Previous studies conducted in high transmission areas have shown that anaemia severity was not associated with parasite burden [30,31]. This study confirms that high density parasitaemia is not necessarily a predictor of anaemia severity, as the proportion of children with and without high density parasitaemia was not different in each of the three categories of malaria. This finding is consistent with previous reports in high transmission settings which have shown a lack of association between parasitaemia and severity of malarial anaemia [30][31][32]. However, studies in low transmission settings have shown a correlation between parasite density and malaria severity [33,34], indicating the importance of transmission intensity as an important factor in determining malaria severity. Although parasite density did not significantly correlate with haemoglobin levels in any of the three sites in this study, the relationship between

Table 4 Relationship between haematological indices and severity of anaemia in children with malaria
Data are presented as medians (first quartile-third quartile)  the two was still evident in the data showing that children in the higher transmission areas (Kintampo and Navrongo) had much higher parasitaemias and were more susceptible to moderate-to-severe anaemia compared to those in Accra. This suggest a complex interplay of factors involving transmission intensity, parasite density, and haemoglobin levels.

Haematological indices Severity of malarial anaemia
Malarial anaemia severity was significantly associated with erythropenia, lymphocytosis, monocytosis, agranulosis, reticulocytosis and thrombocytopenia. Thrombocytopaenia is commonly associated with malaria, and is a marker of malaria severity [31,35]. Reduction in platelet count has been associated with splenomegaly [31], a complication in severe malaria that may lead to death. Consistent with previous reports [12][13][14][15]18], the protective effect of sickle cell trait against malarial anaemia was evident in this cohort. Children with the HbAS genotype had a significantly lower rate of MSMA and higher rate of UM compared to those with normal haemoglobin genotype (HbAA). These patterns were not observed in the HbAC genotypic group, indicating that the mechanisms of protection of the two haemoglobinopathies are likely distinct. In vitro studies have demonstrated that there is inhibition of parasite growth and reduced invasion into HbS erythrocytes [11,36], and that sickle cell trait accelerates the acquisition of natural immunity [16]. Additional analyses of parasitaemia levels showed that the protective effect of HbAS on parasite density appeared to be specific to only the holoendemic area (Kintampo). This apparent disappearance of the protective effect in lower transmission areas may be a potentially important finding, with significant implications for susceptibility to severe disease in sickle cell carriers in endemic areas as control interventions continue to reduce transmission.
Multivariate analysis revealed that the educational status of the father as well as the economic status of the household are major predictors of the severity of anaemia. Typically in African households, decision-making is the responsibility of the father and hence his level of education and understanding of malaria, as well as the availability of funds would determine whether healthcare would be sought early. In addition, better education may influence nutritional choices, such as intake of vitamins and minerals, which have an impact on haemoglobin levels. Recent reports by Diiro and colleagues in Kenya have shown that households headed by males with a higher level of education were at lower risk of malaria [37]. Children of parents with less than secondary level education are more likely to come from low economic backgrounds, which has been shown to put these children at higher risk of severe malaria [38].

Conclusion
The results presented in this study demonstrate significant changes in the clinical manifestations as well as the determinants of diseases severity of malaria as transmission intensity decreases. As transmission intensity decreases, the average age of children presenting to hospital with malaria increases while the risk of developing anaemia decreases. Children living in households where the head-of household had Middle school education or better were less likely to develop high density parasitaemia.
Authors' contributions GAA and DJC conceived the study and its design. JA, KPA, DD and FA were responsible for data collection, management and quality assurance of datasets used in analysis. HEMB and DD performed the statistical analysis. HEMB and GAA drafted the manuscript. GAA and DJ secured funding for the study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.