Validation of Plasmodium falciparum dUTPase as the target of 5′-tritylated deoxyuridine analogues with anti-malarial activity

Background Malaria remains as a major global problem, being one of the infectious diseases that engender highest mortality across the world. Due to the appearance of resistance and the lack of an effective vaccine, the search of novel anti-malarials is required. Deoxyuridine 5′-triphosphate nucleotido-hydrolase (dUTPase) is responsible for the hydrolysis of dUTP to dUMP within the parasite and has been proposed as an essential step in pyrimidine metabolism by providing dUMP for thymidylate biosynthesis. In this work, efforts to validate dUTPase as a drug target in Plasmodium falciparum are reported. Methods To investigate the role of PfdUTPase in cell survival different strategies to generate knockout mutants were used. For validation of PfdUTPase as the intracellular target of four inhibitors of the enzyme, mutants overexpressing PfdUTPase and HsdUTPase were created and the IC50 for each cell line with each compound was determined. The effect of these compounds on dUTP and dTTP levels from P. falciparum was measured using a DNA polymerase assay. Detailed localization studies by indirect immunofluorescence microscopy and live cell imaging were also performed using a cell line overexpressing a Pfdut-GFP fusion protein. Results Different attempts of disruption of the dut gene of P. falciparum were unsuccessful while a 3′ replacement construct could recombine correctly in the locus suggesting that the enzyme is essential. The four 5′-tritylated deoxyuridine analogues described are potent inhibitors of the P. falciparum dUTPase and exhibit antiplasmodial activity. Overexpression of the Plasmodium and human enzymes conferred resistance against selective compounds, providing chemical validation of the target and confirming that indeed dUTPase inhibition is involved in anti-malarial activity. In addition, incubation with these inhibitors was associated with a depletion of the dTTP pool corroborating the central role of dUTPase in dTTP synthesis. PfdUTPase is mainly localized in the cytosol. Conclusion These results strongly confirm the pivotal and essential role of dUTPase in pyrimidine biosynthesis of P. falciparum intraerythrocytic stages.


Background
Malaria, with approximately 216 million cases each year and more than 445,000 attributed deaths reported annually, remains a devastating global health problem. The disease in humans is caused by the infection of 5 different Plasmodium species, among which Plasmodium falciparum causes most mortality, mainly in children below the age of 5 [1]. Because of the appearance of resistance to the current anti-malarial drugs and the absence of an effective vaccine, there is an urgent need for new drugs to treat the disease.
The biosynthesis of nucleotides has been highlighted as a promising pathway in the search for new anti-malarial targets, due to the high dependence of nucleotides in the intraerythrocytic stages [2]. Certain enzymes, such as dihydroorotate dehydrogenase or purine nucleoside phosphorylase, have been extensively studied as drug targets yet the potential of other steps of the pathway remains unclear [3,4].
New anti-malarial strategies have included evaluation of the enzyme dUTPase (deoxyuridine 5′-triphosphate nucleotidohydrolase, E.C. 3.6.1.23) as a potential drug target. This enzyme is essential in both eukaryotes [5] and prokaryotes [6] and several inhibitors of the enzyme have been described that exhibit anti-malarial activity [7][8][9][10] although for certain derivatives the correlation between dUTPase inhibition and anti-malarial activity was poor. dUTPase performs a dual role by catalyzing the hydrolysis of dUTP to dUMP and PPi. It supplies the dUMP substrate for dTMP synthesis, as well as minimizes cellular levels of dUTP, avoiding misincorporation in DNA [11], which might otherwise be incorporated into DNA during replication giving rise to an activation of the base excision repair pathway and multiple cellular defects [11]. Several different oligomeric forms of the enzyme exist in nature, including monomers, dimers and trimers. Plasmodium falciparum and human cells contain a trimeric form of the enzyme yet selective inhibition is achievable. The trimeric dUTPases possess five highly conserved sequence motifs which participate in the active site and provide residues which are essential for activity [12]. The crystal structures of different dUTPases including the P. falciparum and human enzymes have been published to date [13,14] and the molecular and structural basis for the specific inhibition of a series of triphenyl uridine derivatives has been established [13].
While dUTPase has been extensively studied with the aim of inhibitor discovery, little information exists regarding its biological role and essentiality for cell survival in P. falciparum. A recent study performed in Plasmodium berghei has suggested that dUTPase null mutants are not viable [15]. It is reasonable to assume that dUTPase is crucial to the parasite given the high AT/ CG ratio (approximately 80%) in its genome and the fact that Plasmodium lacks dCMP/dCTP deaminase activities which would confer a central role to dUTPase in dUMP formation.
In this paper, efforts to perform gene disruption studies of the dut gene and to address chemical target validation of dUTPase inhibitors are described. The results suggest that the enzyme is essential for the proliferation of intraerythrocytic stage of Plasmodium falciparum and that dUTPase indeed is the target for certain inhibitors of the enzyme with anti-malarial activity. Detailed localization studies using different approaches have been also performed, and show that the enzyme has a ubiquitous intracellular localization appearing in cytosol, nuclei and mitochondria.

Chemistry
Synthesis and analytical characterization of compounds 1-4 is contained in Additional file 1.

Plasmid design and construction
The Pfdut coding sequence previously isolated [13] was used as template for PCR to obtain the construct pHH1-dutKO. A 383 bp fragment was amplified for the KO construct, where a start codon (bold faced) at position 94 of the Pfdut open reading frame (motif 1) and a premature STOP codon (bold faced) at position 477 (motif 5) were introduced into the oligonucleotide. The 5′ primer AGA TCT ATG TTT ATT GTA AAA GATGA contains a BglII restriction site (underlined) and the 3′ primer CTC GAG TCA GGA AGT TTC ATC CAG TTC a XhoI restriction site (underlined) to allow directional cloning into the previously digested transfection plasmid pHH1 (5766 bp). For the KOkon construct, a 423 bp fragment of the Pfdut coding sequence lacking 93 bp at the 5′ region (GCGC AGA TCT ATT GTA AAA GAT GAA GTA CTG), but retaining the 3′ terminus of the Pfdut gene (CGCG CTC GAG TCA ATA TTT ATT ATT CGA TGT ) was cloned into pHH1.
The human dut coding sequence (497 bp) was amplified with the oligonucleotides GCGC AGA TCT ATG CCC TGC TCT GAA GAG and GCGC GCG GCC GCTTA ATT Keywords: Plasmodium falciparum, Deoxyuridine 5′-triphosphate nucleotido-hydrolase, 5′-tritylated deoxyuridine analogues, Mode of action CTT TCC AGT GAA ACC , which introduced BglII and NotI restriction sites (underlined) that allowed the directional cloning into the expression vector pHrBl. The coding sequence for human dUTPase (HsdUTPase) cloned in the pGEM-T vector was used as template for PCR amplification. It was also used as template for the amplification and subsequent cloning of Hsdut pHH2, replacing the green fluorescent protein (GFP) coding sequence present in the original plasmid. The specific oligonucleotides AGA TCT ATG CCC TGC TCT GAA GAG and CTG CAG TTA ATT CTT TCC AGT GG, containing the BglII and PstI restriction sites, respectively, were used for the amplification.
For the construct pHH2-Pfdut, the 524 bp fragment of the Pfdut coding sequence was amplified with the oligonucleotides AGA TCT ATG CAT TTA AAA ATT GTATG and CTG CAG TCA ATA TTT ATT ATT CGATG. The sense oligonucleotide contains a BglII restriction site (underlined), and the antisense oligonucleotide contains a PstI site (underlined) to allow directional cloning into the previously digested transfection plasmid pHH2 (6540 bp). The Pfdut gene was also amplified with the oligonucleotides AGA TCT ATG CAT TTA AAA ATT and CCT AGG ATA TTT ATT ATT CGA by PCR avoiding the STOP codon and cloned in pHH2 maintaining the GFP coding sequence to obtain the construct pHH2-Pfdut-GFP that allows for expression of PfdUTPase fused to GFP in transfected Plasmodium parasites.
The pHH1 and pHH2 series of plasmids contain a human DHFR fragment mutated to encode resistance to WR99210 which allow the selection of transfected parasites while pHrBl contains the blasticidine resistance gene. All PCR products were first cloned into pGEM-T (Invitrogen), where the sequences were verified, and then subcloned into the appropriate vectors.

Plasmodium falciparum cultures and transfection
Plasmodium falciparum asexual erythrocytic-stage parasites (3D7, a cloned line derived from isolate NF54) were cultured at 37 °C, 5% CO 2 in 5% haematocrit using human O-positive erythrocytes and fed every day with complete culture medium (RPMI 1640 (Gibco) supplemented with 0.2% NaHCO 3 , 0.15 mM hypoxanthine, 12.5 μg/ml gentamycin (Gibco), 2% heat inactivated human serum, and 0.5% Albumax II (Gibco) [16]. Synchronized ring-stage parasites (~ 5% parasitaemia) with 5% sorbitol, were transfected with 100 μg of circular purified plasmid DNA (HiSpeed plasmid maxi kit; Qiagen) in a Genepulser from BioRad, and drug cycling commenced according to methodology described previously by Crabb et al. [17]. Following transfection, the samples were immediately mixed with 10 ml culture medium and cultured in 25-cm 2 culture flasks until 5% parasitaemia for 48 h prior to selection with 5 nM WR99210 (Jacobus Pharmaceuticals). The parasites were maintained under drug pressure for 5 days and then the concentration of drug was decreased to 2.5 nM WR99210. The first parasites were observed after 25-28 days of selection in continuous culture. Drug cycling was performed in order to select for homologous recombination of the constructs and loss of episomal DNA. For this purpose, transfectants were cultured for 3 weeks without drug pressure followed by 4 days with WR99210 pressure. This selection cycle was repeated for several rounds, and at different stages parasite DNA was isolated and subjected to Southern blotting and PCR analyses to determine whether episomal DNA was present and if integration into the Pfdut gene locus had occurred.

Southern blot analysis
Parasitized erythrocytes (5 × 10 8 parasites per sample) were harvested by centrifugation, treated with 1.5 volumes of saponin 0.15% in PBS for 5 min at 4 °C and after adding another 5 volumes of PBS, cells were centrifuged at 5000 rpm for 10 min. Genomic DNA was isolated from parasite pellets using the QIAamp DNA Mini Kit (Qiagen). Manipulation of recombinant DNA and analysis of nucleic acids by Southern blot hybridization were carried out using standard procedures [18].

In vitro assays
In vitro inhibitory activity against the erythrocytic stages of P. falciparum of overexpressing mutants was determined by using the SYBR green assay [19] and the 3 H-hypoxanthine incorporation assay was used for IC50 determination as previously described [8]. Plasmodium falciparum 3D7 was cultured using standard methods, and synchronized using 5% sorbitol as previously described [20]. Compounds were dissolved in DMSO and added at different concentrations (8-500 ng/ ml) to 48 h post-synchronization parasites. The content in DMSO did not exceed 0.001% to avoid solvent toxicity. Chloroquine dissolved in water was used as standard drug. Experiments were carried out at least twice independently and the different concentrations were tested in duplicate. IC50 values were calculated using a fourparameter logistic regression model using data obtained from two or three independent experiments as indicated.

Measurement of intracellular uridine and thymidine nucleotides
The effect of different dUTPase inhibitors on dUTP and dTTP levels from P. falciparum cells was measured using a modified DNA polymerase assay [21]. The template sequence employed was the oligonucleotide 5′-TTT ATT TAT TTA TTT ATT TAG GCG GTG GAG GCGG-3′ and as primer sequence the oligonucleotide 5′-CCG CCT CCA CCG CC-3′ was used. Saponinisolated parasite pellets (5 × 10 8 parasites per sample) were repeatedly washed in PBS and frozen at − 80 °C. Frozen pellets were extracted with 200 μl of cold methanol/water (1:1, v/v) vigorously by vortexing, freezethawed twice and centrifuged. Supernatants were collected and pellets were re-extracted with the same volume of methanol/water as previously mentioned and newly centrifuged. The combined supernatants were dried under vacuum. The residues were dissolved in 40 μl either of dUTPase buffer (34 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.8, 5 mM MgCl 2 ) or dUTPase buffer plus 30 ng of HsdUTPase and incubated for 20 min at 37 °C. To stop the reaction, 60 μl of 100% methanol were added and the samples were incubated for 1 h at − 20 °C, followed by centrifugation for 20 min at 16,000×g. The supernatants were again dried under vacuum and the DNA polymerase assay used was modified from that of Horowitz et al. [21]. The DNA polymerase I buffer contained 34 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.8, and 50 mM MgCl 2 . After incubation with DNA polymerase I, 30 μl of each sample were incubated for 30 min at 4 °C with 470 μl of DNA polymerase I buffer containing 10% (v/v) trichloroacetic acid to precipitate the DNA. The solution was blotted onto a glass microfibre filter GF/C (Whatman) and each filter was washed under vacuum with 30 ml of a solution of 5% (v/v) trichloroacetic acid and 3 ml of ethanol, dried and the radioactivity was counted using a LS 6500 Multi-Purpose Scintillation Counter (Beckman Coulter).

Generation of antibodies against HsdUTPase and PfdUTPase and Western blot analysis
Both proteins, PfdUTPase and HsdUTPase were purified as previously described [10]. Polyclonal antiserum against recombinant PfdUTPase and HsdUTPase was generated by immunizing rabbits with the purified protein. The monoclonal anti-PfdUTPase antibody, used for immunofluorescence analysis, was obtained as described previously [22]. Protein extracts were prepared from saponin-isolated parasites by sonication. Unless otherwise mentioned, the parasites were obtained from cultures of highly synchronized trophozoites. 10 µg of total extract of P. falciparum proteins were subjected to SDS-PAGE, blotted on an Immobilon-P membrane (Millipore) and incubated with 1:10,000 dilution of the anti-HsdUTPase antibody. Bound antibody was detected by reaction with horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-conjugate goat anti-rabbit IgG (Promega) at a dilution of 1:5000 and an ECL ™ immunodetection kit (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech).

Fluorescence microscopy
For indirect immunofluorescence microscopy, 10 ml of infected erythrocytes at 5% of parasitaemia were washed once in PBS then fixed with 4% paraformaldehyde and 0.0075% glutaraldehyde in PBS for 30 min. For visualization of the mitochondrion, cells were washed once with PBS, resuspended in the same medium containing 50 nM MitoTracker Red CMXRos (Molecular Probes), and incubated for 15 min at 37 °C before starting the fixation process. Fixed cells were washed once in PBS and then permeabilized with 0.1% Triton X-100/ PBS for 10 min. Cells were washed again in PBS and then treated with 0.1 mg/ml of sodium borohydride (NaBH 4 )/ PBS for 10 min to reduce any free aldehyde groups. Following another PBS wash, cells were blocked in 3% BSA/PBS for 1 h. Indirect immunofluorescence confocal microscopy using an anti-PfdUTPase monoclonal antibody or anti-HsdUTPase polyclonal antibody was performed in both wild-type cells and in overexpressing mutants. The anti-PfdUTPase monoclonal antibody (diluted 1:250) or anti-HsdUTPase polyclonal antibody (diluted 1:500) were added and incubated for 1 h. Cells were washed three times in PBS for 10 min each. Alexa Fluor goat anti-mouse 488 (Molecular Probes) diluted 1:200 or goat anti-rabbit IgG FITC-conjugate (Sigma) diluted 1:40 were added and allowed to bind for 1 h. Cells were washed three times in PBS. Cells were finally fixed with cold methanol (Merck). Samples were stained with Vectashield ® -DAPI (Vector Laboratories) and analysed with a Leica TCS SP5 confocal microscopy system. The colocalization analysis was performed with the image processing software ImageJ.
For live cell imaging, the parasites transfected with pHH2-Pfdut-GFP were incubated at 37 °C for 15 min in medium containing 100 μg/ml of Hoechst 33342 (Invitrogen) and 50 nM of MitoTracker Red CMXRos. After washing, cells were pelleted and resuspended in 2 volumes of medium and then mounted to perform microscopy. Cells were viewed with a confocal Leica TCS SP5 microscopy system.

Results
The dut gene is essential for asexual intraerythrocytic stages of P. falciparum To investigate the role of dUTPase in cell survival, the deletion of the gene in intraerytrocityc stages of P. falciparum was attempted. Different strategies were employed to replace the endogenous gene using approaches leading to single recombination as described [23,24]. PCR fragments for single homologous recombination of the dut locus were obtained by PCR and cloned into the vector pHH1. Figure 1, panels a and b, indicate the strategy designed. The pHH1 knockout construct (pHH1-dutKO) was truncated at its 5′ end, although an ATG start codon was introduced while at the 3′ end a premature STOP codon was introduced 237 bp upstream of the natural STOP codon. This would result in the formation of two incomplete and inactive Pfdut copies upon single crossover recombination of the plasmid in the gene locus. In contrast, the control construct (pHH1-dutKOkon) retains the 3′ region of the dut gene but lacks the 5′ region and thus would generate upon recombination a functional copy and a non-functional pseudogene. After transfection experiments with both constructs, transfected cells were readily obtained in both cases. Transfected parasite lines were taken through several drug selection cycles in order to favour/select the population of parasites where a single crossover event in the Pfdut locus had occurred. Genomic DNA was isolated and analysed by diagnostic Southern blotting to establish integration events into the parasite genome. In the case of pHH1-dutKO, Southern blot revealed the presence of endogenous Pfdut (1782 bp band) and linearized plasmid (5418 bp band), but no integration events into the parasite genome were detected after several drug cycles (Fig. 1c). However in the case of transfection with pHH1-dutKOkon, three rounds of drug removal resulted in the integration of the construct, with two new bands of 4985 and 2217 bp as shown in Fig. 1d.
The expression of a heterologous dut gene in Plasmodium cells that may allow for subsequent removal of the endogenous copy of Pfdut was used as a second knockout strategy. For this purpose, the trimeric HsdUTPase was chosen. The coding sequence of human dut was cloned into the expression vector pHrBl to yield pHrBl-Hsdut. This construct was cotransfected with pHH1-dutKO and cells resistant to blasticidine and to the human DHFR inhibitor WR99210 were obtained. The correct expression of HsdUTPase was tested using a specific antibody (Additional file 2a) while correct transfection with pHH1-dutKO was verified by Southern blot (Additional file 2b). Cells efficiently overexpressed the human enzyme and showed a normal growth profile. However, after several drug cycles, no integration events were detected by Southern blotting. All together these results suggest that, although the dut gene is targetable, no insertions are favored which may lead to gene disruption.

dUTPase overexpression induces resistance against inhibitors with anti-malarial activity
Four new inhibitors of plasmodial dUTPase were used. The structures of the compounds selected together with the Ki values for PfdUTPase and HsdUTPase are shown in Additional file 1 and Table 1 and are all trityl derivatives containing the uracil base. The IC50 values for intraerythrocytic stages of P. falciparum are also indicated. Compounds 1 and 3 contain the ribose ring while 2 and 4 are acyclic derivatives. These compounds inhibit Plasmodium dUTPase while are mostly inactive against the human enzyme yet exhibit anti-malarial activity in vitro at nanomolar concentrations. The most potent enzyme inhibitor against PfdUTPase was compound 3 (Ki 79 nM) while compound 1 was the least active (Ki 4.73 μM). Moreover, compounds 1 and 2 were the most active in vitro against the parasite with IC50 values of 40 and 60 nM respectively.
Evidence that inhibitors were acting on-target in Plasmodium was first sought for by creating Plasmodium mutants overexpressing PfdUTPase and HsdUTPase. After transfection, protein overexpression in these cell lines was confirmed by Western blot and the localization within the cell by immunofluorescence. Indirect inmunofluorescence was performed using anti-PfdUTPase and anti-HsdUTPase monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies (Fig. 2a). After the quantification of Western blot signals with ImageQuant software (GE healthcare), it was established that the levels of PfdUTPase were around sixfold higher in the PfdUTPase overexpressing line while HsdUTPase although detectable, overexpressed to a lesser degree (Fig. 2b). Subsequently, the IC50 for each cell line with each compound and the fold change relative to the 3D7 IC50 was calculated (Fig. 3a). For compound 3, one of the most potent dUTPase inhibitors with a Ki of 79 nM, overexpression resulted in a 3.8-fold reduction in potency in the case of PfdUTPase (Fig. 3a) and a 2.3 reduction when overexpressing HsdUTPase. In the case of compound 4, IC50 values were increased 4 and 2.5-fold in the PfdUTPase and HsdUTPase overexpressing lines respectively. However, IC50s for compounds 1 and 2, exhibited minor changes with values ranging between 1.55 and 1.10, suggesting that dUTPase is probably not the major target responsible for the anti-malarial effect of these latter analogues. The IC50 for chloroquine as a reference compound was also determined in overexpressing mutants. No significant effects were denoted indicating that changes in compound susceptibility are specific to dUTPase inhibitors.

Incubation with dUTPase inhibitors results in decreased dTTP and increased dUTP levels
Perturbation of the production of dUMP for dTTP biosynthesis by different dUTPase inhibitors was monitored by determining dTTP levels in parasites.
Considering the central role of dUTPase in the production of dUMP for dTMP synthesis via thymidylate synthase-dihydrofolate reductase, the incubation of P. falciparum with dUTPase inhibitors should produce a decrease in dTTP and an increase in dUTP pools in treated cells thus resulting in an imbalance in the dUTP/dTTP ratio. The levels of intracellular dTTP and dUTP were measured using the DNA polymerase based assay in Plasmodium cultures incubated with compounds 3 and 4. Parasites for dUTP and dTTP measurements were obtained from highly synchronized cultures in schizont stage after 20 h of treatment with concentrations of compound that corresponded with 1× and 3× the IC50 concentration. As shown in Fig. 3b both compounds induced a significant decrease in dTTP and an increase in the dUTP pool at high concentrations further supporting that inhibition of dUTPase has an impact on dNTP pools and subsequently on parasite replication.

PfdUTPase is mainly localized in the cytosol and expressed in a stage-dependent manner
Indirect immunofluorescence (Fig. 2a) allowed for quantification of the intracellular distribution of the enzyme. In trophozoites the signal can be associated mostly with the cytosol although a certain overlap occurs with both mitochondria and nuclei. Intracellular localization of dUTPase in mutants overexpressing PfdUTPase (Fig. 2a) was also analysed and appeared to be similar to what was observed in the parental cell line.
Additionally, analysis was performed with a cell line overexpressing a Pfdut-GFP fusion protein and live cell fluorescence microscopy allowing for direct observation of dUTPase. In this case MitoTracker Red was used for mitochondria visualization and Hoechst33342 for nuclei. As shown in Fig. 4a, a similar protein distribution to the one observed using indirect immunofluorescence was obtained. The correct expression of the fusion protein was confirmed by Western blot with polyclonal anti-PfdUTPase antibody (Fig. 4b). A single band of approximately 20 kDa was detected in the 3D7 parental line, while two bands, one corresponding to the native PfdUTPase and a second of approximately 47 kDa corresponding to the PfdUTPase-GFP fusion Images were taken with a confocal Leica TCS SP5 microscopy system and show a single optical plane. b Western blotting of extracts of parasites overexpressing PfdUTPase-GFP using a polyclonal anti-PfdUTPase antibody. A band of approximately 46.5 kDa appears only in transfected parasites (PfdUTPase GFP OE), corresponding to the fusion protein dUTPase-GFP. c Expression of PfdUTPase in 3D7 wild-type cells throughout the intraerythrocytic cycle. Protein extracts of parasites in ring (R), trophozoite (T) and schizont (S) stages were subjected to Western blotting with the polyclonal dUTPase antibody. Anti-Hsp70 was used as loading control protein, could be detected in pHH2-Pfdut-GFP transfected parasites.
Finally, Western blotting allowed for quantification with ImageQuant software (GE healthcare) during the life cycle using extracts of highly synchronized 3D7 wild-type parasites and showed that PfdUTPase levels in trophozoites and schizonts (3D7 cells) were 3.3 and 3.8 times respectively those observed in ring forms (Fig. 4c).

Discussion
Nucleotide metabolism has been highlighted as a source of enzymes for target-based drug development in Plasmodium [25]. Plasmodium falciparum dUTPase had been extensively studied in the search of potent inhibitors showing anti-malarial properties [7,8,10] yet, while presumed to be indispensable for growth considering its central role in providing dUMP for thymidylate biosynthesis, its essential character has not been demonstrated. Trimeric dUTPases have been shown to be essential for viability in several organisms, such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae [5], Escherichia coli [6], or Mycobacterium smegmatis [26]. Likewise, knockout mutants for the dimeric enzymes present a growth defective phenotype [27]. The loss of viability has been associated with an imbalance in the dUTP/dTTP ratio. Thus in the absence of dUTPase an increase in this ratio results in massive incorporation of uracil during replication due to an expansion of the dUTP pool. Indeed Saccharomyces cerevisiae [5] and Trypanosoma brucei [28] knockout mutants are thymidine auxotrophs. Human and Plasmodium dUTPases share a similar overall fold yet selective inhibition has been shown to be feasible. Thus, a series of trityl and deoxyuridine derivatives and their acyclic analogues can inhibit P. falciparum dUTPase and show anti-malarial activity [8]. Structural data obtained for enzyme-inhibitor complexes evidenced that the triphenylmethane group of these compounds interacts with the side chains of residues Phe46 and Ile117 that are part of a hydrophobic pocket present in Plasmodium dUTPase different from the phosphate binding site [13]. These residues are replaced by Val42 and Gly87 in the human enzyme [13]. The present study provides genetic evidence suggesting that PfdUTPase is indeed indispensable for erythrocytic stages of P. falciparum. The dut locus could not be disrupted, yet could be correctly targeted. The inability to knockout the gene using a simple crossover strategy has been understood as evidence that supports the essentiality of the gene [29]. Alternative strategies such as the complementation by HsdUTPase in a KO background were not feasible. Several reasons may explain this observation. Thus, it is possible that levels of human enzyme are inadequate to sustain dTMP biosynthesis. In addition, the existence of protein-protein interactions specific to PfdUTPase and that are essential for parasite viability cannot be discarded. In support of the essential character of Pfdut, a recent study using transposon mutagenesis has defined the mutability and fitness costs for over 87% of P. falciparum genes and established 2680 genes as essential for optimal growth of asexual blood stages in vitro [30]. The coding sequence for PfdUTPase appeared in this study as non-mutable. Since the absence of insertions in the CDS was considered as an indicator that disruptions are lethal, the data is also indicative of Pfdut being essential [30]. In addition, the enzyme appears to be essential in P. berghei since deletion of dUTPase failed after several attempts suggesting a crucial role during intraerythrocytic development [15].
While multiple studies have shown that PfdUTPase can be efficiently inhibited in vitro and that enzyme inhibitors also exhibit antiplasmodial activity, no study has been performed in order to validate that indeed the intracellular target of these compounds is dUTPase. Most inhibitors discovered to date are uracil-based compounds that interact with the substrate binding site. Specifically, 5′-tritylated nucleosides are selective inhibitors of the P. falciparum enzyme versus the HsdUTPase [31]. Further modifications of 5′-tritylated deoxyuridine derivatives gave rise to a generation of acyclic analogues that showed a good correlation between enzyme inhibition and antiparasitic activity [8,10].
For chemical validation, different compounds that exhibit inhibition of both PfdUTPase and antiplasmodial activity were chosen. Mutants overexpressing PfdUT-Pase or HsdUTPase are expected to confer resistance if the enzyme is the primary target. When comparing the fold change in IC50 of the different compounds tested, the action of compounds 3 and 4 was clearly dependent on enzyme levels. Compound 3 is a 3′carbamate and a potent inhibitor of Plasmodium dUTPase while compound 4 is an acyclic 3′ urea that appears to be eightfold less active against the enzyme than compound 3 although both share the characteristic of exhibiting a bulky carboxybenzene substituent in the 3′ position. Both exhibit significant antiplasmodial activity in vitro and are selective versus the human enzyme. The lower ability of HsdUTPase to counteract the effect of the inhibitor, although still doubling the original IC50, can be due to low protein levels or a reduced ability of HsdUTPase to substitute the Plasmodium enzyme. While not performed in the present study, overexpression of a catalytic mutant would not confer resistance to the inhibitors thus reinforcing the concept that dUTPase is the target of compounds 3 and 4.
In the case of compounds 1 and 2 (3′ urea derivatives) dUTPase inhibition does not appear to relate to the antiplasmodial activity. Indeed, the Ki values for PfdUTPase for compounds 1 and 2 are respectively nearly two and one orders of magnitude higher than their anti-malarial activity in vitro pointing towards the existence of other intracellular targets. Hence, while certain compounds clearly involve inhibition of dUTPase as their main target within the cells, for others additional modes of action should be invoked, although these remain to be established. The pronounced decrease in dTTP and increase in dUTP in treated Plasmodium cultures further reinforces the idea that compounds 3 and 4 are acting through inhibition of dUTPase. Depletion of nucleotide pools upon incubation with specific inhibitors also underscores not only the importance of dUTPase in keeping low levels of dUTP, but also its key role in providing dUMP for dTTP biosynthesis (Additional file 3).

Conclusion
In summary, here evidence is provided that dUTPase is a valuable target to be considered for target-based drug design. The information presented will contribute to the design of potent PfdUTPase inhibitors with anti-malarial activity. The future challenge resides in the identification of selective, stable drug-like compounds with potent activity that may present features that allow for their use in vivo.