Assessment of Plasmodium falciparum anti-malarial drug resistance markers in pfcrt and pfmdr1 genes in isolates from Honduras and Nicaragua, 2018–2021

Background Central America and the island of Hispaniola have set out to eliminate malaria by 2030. However, since 2014 a notable upturn in the number of cases has been reported in the Mosquitia region shared by Nicaragua and Honduras. In addition, the proportion of Plasmodium falciparum malaria cases has increased significantly relative to vivax malaria. Chloroquine continues to be the first-line drug to treat uncomplicated malaria in the region. The objective of this study was to evaluate the emergence of chloroquine resistant strains of P. falciparum using a genetic approach. Plasmodium vivax populations are not analysed in this study. Methods 205 blood samples from patients infected with P. falciparum between 2018 and 2021 were analysed. The pfcrt gene fragment encompassing codons 72–76 was analysed. Likewise, three fragments of the pfmdr1 gene were analysed in 51 samples by nested PCR and sequencing. Results All samples revealed the CVMNK wild phenotype for the pfcrt gene and the N86, Y184F, S1034C, N1042D, D1246 phenotype for the pfmdr1 gene. Conclusions The increase in falciparum malaria cases in Nicaragua and Honduras cannot be attributed to the emergence of chloroquine-resistant mutants. Other possibilities should be investigated further. This is the first study to report the genotype of pfmdr1 for five loci of interest in Central America. Supplementary Information The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12936-021-03977-8.

According to these data, the current achievements for malaria control in Central America are heterogeneous and, in some cases, a significant setback has been reported. For instance, Nicaragua reported more than 25,000 cases of malaria in 2020, surpassing the figures of 2000, which indicates two decades lost in progress towards the control and elimination of the disease (Fig. 1) (Personal communication by the National Center for Diagnosis and Reference, Health Ministry, Nicaragua). Another worrying data is the proportional increase in the number of cases of Plasmodium falciparum malaria in the Mosquitia. Malaria due to P. falciparum was less than 10% in 2008 in both countries, and in 2020 it exceeded 50% in Nicaragua and 29% in Honduras.
There are several hypotheses that try to explain this alarming situation. One of them is related to the possible appearance of resistance of the parasite against anti-malarial drugs. The countries of northern Central America and the island of Hispaniola are the only region in the world using chloroquine (CQ) as firstline of treatment against uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria [1]. The first cases of CQ resistance emerged in the early 1960s in Asia [3,4], rendering it ineffective in almost all endemic territories in the tropics [5,6]. Resistance to CQ is associated with mutations in the gene encoding the PfCRT protein (P. falciparum chloroquine resistance transporter) that is found on the membrane of the digestive vacuole (DV) of the parasite and transports 4-aminoquinoline drugs out of the vacuole [7]. Mutant resistant alleles of PfCRT prevent CQ from concentrating within acidic DV and preventing its toxic action [8]. Mutations in codons 72-76 of pfcrt are responsible for the resistant phenotype (CQR), generating five haplotypes associated with resistance: CVIET, SVMNT, SVIET, CVMNT and CVTNT [9,10]. Despite the selective pressure exerted by the drug for decades, P. falciparum strains circulating in Central America have not developed resistance-associated mutations in the pfcrt gene [11][12][13][14] and they continue to hold the CVMNK susceptible wild genotype.
Along with pfcrt, although to a lesser degree, the pfmdr1 gene has been associated with CQR, especially when the 86Y mutation appears in addition to the 76T mutation in pfcrt [15,16]. pfmdr1 gene has been less studied than pfcrt in P. falciparum strains circulating in Central America, revealing up to now the wild type at position N86 and a fixed mutation at position 184F [11,14]. Mutations in other codons (1034, 1046 and 1246) reported to be associated with CQR have not been observed in P. falciparum strains in Central America.
Despite the lack of historical evidence of genetic mutations in the main markers of resistance to CQ in P. falciparum in the Central American Mosquitia, and the absence of anecdotal reports of therapeutic failure by physicians, this study aimed to support the active surveillance of recent genetic mutations to inform decision-makers about the potential emergence and spread of CQ-resistant strains in the region in the context of an increase in the number of cases especially in the Mosquitia.

Sample collection, ethics, and parasitological diagnosis
This descriptive cross-sectional study included 205 blood samples from febrile patients diagnosed with malaria and who sought medical assistance in national sanitary facilities in four municipalities of Honduras (95 samples) and five municipalities of Nicaragua (110 samples) (Fig. 2). Blood samples for molecular analysis were collected by fingerstick on Whatman FTA filter paper at the time of patient recruitment. In addition, blood samples were collected from febrile patients for the microscopic diagnosis of malaria by thick smear, before administering any anti-malarial treatment. The thick smear reading was performed by trained personnel according to the routine diagnostic protocols of both countries [17].

DNA extraction and molecular confirmation of P. falciparum infections
DNA was extracted from blood on filter paper cards using a Chelex-100 based method (Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc, EE. UU.) [18]. Microscopic diagnosis of the parasite species was confirmed by amplification of the 18S rRNA gene as described in Singh et al. [19].

Amplification of pfcrt and pfmdr1 gene fragments
A fragment of the pfcrt gene encompassing codons 72-76 was amplified by nested PCR. Briefly, for the first round of PCR, 10 µL of genomic DNA was used in a volume of 50 µL containing 25 µL of Taq Master Mix and 2 µL of each primer [13,20] (Table 1) at a concentration of 10 µM and a remaining volume of nuclease free water. The reaction was mixed and subjected to the following program: initial denaturation at 94 °C for 10 min, followed by 35 cycles of 94 °C for 30 s, 59 °C for 30 s, and 72 °C for 30 s, and a final extension at 72 °C for 10 min. For the 2nd round of PCR, 2.0 μL of PCR products with 25.0 μL Taq Master Mix, 1.0 μL of each primer (10 μM), and dd H 2 O (up to 50.0 μl) were mixed and subjected to the following programme: initial denaturation at 94 °C for 10 min, followed by 30 cycles of 95 °C for 30 s, 56 °C for 30 s, and 72 °C for 30 s, and a final extension at 72 °C for 10 min.
In addition, three regions of the pfmdr1 gene were amplified to identify five polymorphisms at codons 86 and 184 (first segment), 1034 and 1046 (second segment), and 1246 (third segment) (Additional file 1: Fig. S1). The three regions were amplified by nested PCRs. In the first rounds of PCR, 2 µL of genomic DNA, 12.5 µL of Taq Master Mix, 1 µL of each primer (10 µM) ( Table 1) and 8.5 µL of dd H 2 O were added. The second rounds of PCR used 2 μL of products from the first round, 25 μL of Taq Master Mix, 2 μL of each primer (10 μM), and 19 μL of dd H 2 O. The same amplification program was used for all reactions except the annealing temperature (52 °C for the first round and 54 °C for the second round): initial denaturation at 95 °C for 3 min, followed by 35 cycles of 95 °C for 30 s, annealing for 30 s, and 72 °C for 1 min, and a final extension at 72 °C for 5 min. PCR products were resolved on 2% agarose gels stained with ethidium bromide and visualized under UV transillumination.

Sequence analysis
Purification and sequencing of gene fragments were carried out on both strands with their respective nested primers using a commercial service (Psomagen, Inc., Maryland, USA). Sequences were trimmed at both 5′ and 3′ ends with the Geneious ® 9.1.7 software and queried against international databases contained in the National Centre for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) to confirm the identity of the sequences. Subsequently, the sequences were analysed in search of target polymorphisms of interest for both genes. The sequences obtained were deposited in the NCBI database.

Ethical considerations
The ethics committee (CEI-MEIZ) of the National Autonomous University of Honduras (UNAH) reviewed and approved the study under protocol number 03-2020. Consent to participate was waived for the following reasons: (a) No personal information was included. (b) The study was beneficial to public health and (c) does not harm the participants. Blood filter paper samples were collected for parasite species identification and analysis of genes associated with drug resistance, in accordance with national regulations and for routine malaria surveillance purposes.

Results
In this study, 205 blood samples on filter paper collected for routine malaria diagnosis in Honduras and Nicaragua were analysed. None of the cases were imported from outside the region. Seven samples from 2018, 44 samples from 2019, 113 from 2020 and 41 samples from 2021 were analysed (Additional file 2: Table S1). Of 205 samples diagnosed by microscopic examination as P. falciparum, 201 were confirmed by PCR as P. falciparum and four samples (1.95%) were identified as mixed infections (P. falciparum and P. vivax). All samples were successfully amplified for the pfcrt gene fragment encompassing codons 72-76. Three segments of interest in the pfmdr1 gene were amplified for 51 of the 205 samples (40 from Honduras and 11 from Nicaragua).
All 205 samples were wild type for pfcrt (72-CVMNK-76) and thus sensitive to CQ. In the case of pfmdr1, all 51 samples presented the genotype NFCDD. Positions N86 and D1246 showed the wild type, while positions 184F, 1034C and 1042D showed a mutant phenotype in all samples (Fig. 3). Gene sequences were deposited in the NCBI database under the accession numbers MZ400792-MZ400875 (pfcrt) and MZ670132-MZ670296 (pfmdr1).

Discussion
Chloroquine, one of the oldest synthetic drugs used in the treatment of malaria was developed in the 1930s, and became the most widely used synthetic antimalarial during the 1960s and 1970s [21]. However, the first chloroquine resistant (CQR) strains of P. falciparum began to be reported in Southeast Asia as early as 1957 [4]. CQR rapidly spread to sub-Saharan Africa and new resistant variants appeared in South America and Asia during the following decades [7,22]. Surprisingly, northern Central America and the island of Hispaniola in the Caribbean are the only region in the world where P. falciparum strains are still susceptible to chloroquine (CQS) [12,23]. Therefore, there are six countries in the Americas  [24,25], it is important to periodically monitor parasite populations for evidence of CQR [26]. This study is an effort to contribute to the routine surveillance of CQR in P. falciparum that has been carried out in Central America since 2010. The pfcrt gene region spanning codons 72-76 in 205 P. falciparum isolates collected between 2018 and 2021 from Honduras and Nicaragua were sequenced. All samples showed a wild-type haplotype CVMNK associated with susceptibility to CQ. This result is consistent with previously published studies. The first study carried out with 30 samples collected in five departments of Honduras between 2004 and 2009 showed 100% of isolates with wild genotype, except for two individuals whose infection had been contracted in Asia and Africa [14]. A study of the therapeutic efficacy of CQ included 68 samples collected in Puerto Lempira, in the Honduran Mosquitia, revealing only wild genotypes in the pfcrt gene [13]. Likewise, an efficacy trial conducted in the North Atlantic Region (RAAN) of Nicaragua during 2005 and with samples from a surveillance study from 2011 showed that 96 of 98 samples had the CVMNK phenotype, while two samples had the CVIET CQR phenotype. Unfortunately, the authors were unable to confirm whether these cases were imported or not [27]. In a 2014 publication, the authors evaluated 160 samples collected from several municipalities in Honduras between 2010 and 2013 and showing 100% wild genotypes of pfcrt [12]. Unpublished data revealed that 16 samples collected in 2015 from Guatemala also showed the wild genotype. In a more recent study including 16 specimens that underwent next generation sequencing, 3 specimens were found with a CQR haplotype SVMNT. The authors indicate that two of these samples were imported cases from Africa and that the third was a local case collected in 2013 in the Choluteca region [11]. However, no epidemiological information is offered on the case that can ensure that it was In the case of Central America and Hispaniola, where circulating parasites still show a wild CQS genotype the presence of imported cases from countries with CQR strains [11,[27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34] puts at risk the efforts made in recent decades to achieve malaria elimination [2]. The continued finding of CQ susceptibility in recent years, indicates that the notable increase in malaria cases in Nicaragua from 2014 to the present (Fig. 1) is not caused by the appearance of CQR strains but to other phenomena that exceed the purposes of this study and must be promptly analysed in an integrated way.
The second gene analysed in this study was pfmdr1, a transporter on the membrane of the digestive vacuole that mediates the transfer of antimalarial drugs from the cytosol to the vacuole [35]. At least 5 SNPs have been described in pfmdr1 presumably associated with resistance to different antimalarial drugs [36][37][38]. Unlike pfcrt, the influence of the pfmdr1 gene on P. falciparum CQR is still not entirely clear, and the response to antimalarials is likely to be a multigenic phenomenon that is affected by the sum of mutations in different transporter genes [39]. To shed some light on this topic, three fragments of the pfmdr1 gene encompassing codons 86, 184, 1034, 1042, and 1246 in 51 samples that had shown a wild type pfcrt genotype were sequenced. All samples showed an NFCDD haplotype, with wild type alleles at positions 86 and 1246, and mutant alleles at 184, 1034, and 1042. There are two published studies on this gene in samples from Honduras that coincide with the results of this study. A first study in 2011 showed that all 30 samples tested had the wild N86 genotype [14]. Similarly, a second study revealed the genotype N86, 184F, D1246 in all 16 samples [11]. This is the first study to analyse the five codons of interest in the pfmdr1 gene in samples from Honduras and Nicaragua.
A study carried out in Haiti found the haplotype N86/184F in 108 samples analysed after the 2010 earthquake [30]. A second study carried out in Haiti amplified 54 samples and analysed all five codons, finding mutations only in codon 184 (NFSND) [34]. Likewise, six patients infected by P. falciparum in Punta Cana in the Dominican Republic were described as carriers of the 184F mutation [33]. On the other hand, there are several studies that reported different haplotypes of pfmdr1 in South America. As in the present study, all reported exclusively the wild-type N86 [40][41][42][43][44][45] that seems to be a common characteristic in the strains of the continent. Some authors propose that CQR mediated by pfcrt mutations is modulated somehow by mutations in pfmdr1, and that the mutant alleles 86Y and 184F are the most relevant [46,47]. According to the literature all the P. falciparum isolates show the 184F mutant allele in Central America [11], Haiti [30,34] and South America [41][42][43][44][45][48][49][50]. Mutation 184F is believed to have a limited effect in the absence of a mutation at codon 86 [51,52]. Consequently, a pfcrt haplotype CVMNK together with a wild type N86 allele in most parasite strains in Central America and Haiti (despite the presence of 184F mutants), would allow predicting that it is unlikely that short-term CQR will appear in the region due to an accumulation of mutations in both genes.
Codon 1034 is more heterogeneous on the American continent. Both the wild genotype S1034, and the mutant 1034C, have been described in Colombia, Venezuela, Peru, and Suriname. The wild genotypes 1042D and 1246Y are the most frequent in the region [41,42,44,45,50,[53][54][55][56]. The NFCDD signature found in this study in all samples analysed has also been described in Peru (94.5-100%) [42,45], French Guiana (0.2%) [56], Ghana (43.5%) [57], and Yemen (57%) [58]. It is complex to interpret the role that mutations in pfmdr1 play on the modulation of resistance to the different antimalarial drugs available. However, in the absence of mutations in pfcrt in parasites from Honduras and Nicaragua, where CQ remains the first-line of treatment for uncomplicated malaria, mutant haplotypes in pfmdr1 do not appear to be an important variable to consider at present. Some limitations of the study are a relatively low number of samples analysed, the exclusion of P. vivax, which continues to be the predominant species of the parasite in the region, and the lack of clinical data on the susceptibility of the parasite to chloroquine, that could only be obtained from an in vivo efficacy study.

Conclusions
This study established that there are still no mutations linked to antimalarial resistance in the pfcrt gene in P. falciparum isolates from Honduras and Nicaragua. Furthermore, the predominant haplotype for five codons of interest of pfmdr1 gene is reported for the first time, revealing three positions with fixed mutations. The increasing number of malaria cases reported in Nicaragua since 2014 cannot be attributed to the emergence of resistance to CQ in P. falciparum. The evidence obtained in this study supports the hypothesis that CQ remains an effective drug for the treatment of uncomplicated P. falciparum malaria in the Mosquitia, although an in vivo efficacy study with chloroquine is necessary as definitive evidence.