Skip to main content

Table 3 Sporozoite rate (SR) of An. gambiae s.l. in treated and control communes in Alibori and Donga departments in 2019, 2020 and 2021

From: Did the prolonged residual efficacy of clothianidin products lead to a greater reduction in vector populations and subsequent malaria transmission compared to the shorter residual efficacy of pirimiphos-methyl?

Location

Insecticide (Years)

Period

Department of Alibori

Department of Donga

Control Commune (Bembèrèkè)

Communes under IRS (Kandi + Gogounou)

P

Control Commune (Bassila)

Communes under IRS (Djougou + Copargo)

P

SR % (A/B)

SR % (A/B)

SR % (A/B)

SR % (A/B)

Indoors

PM 300 CS (2019)

Before IRS

5.9 (3/51)

0.0 (0/120)

0.041

14.3 (5/35)

2.2 (1/45)

0.109

After IRS

1.7 (17/1002)

0.0 (0/330)

0.036

7.0 (24/342)

0.6 (2/349)

 < 0.0001

Clo + Del (2020)

Before IRS

0.0 (0/16)

0.0 (0/97)

NA

0.0 (0/13)

2.3 (1/44)

1

After IRS

1.2 (6/521)

0.4 (2/573)

0.230

3.0 (15/493)

1.0 (8/831)

0.010

Clo 50 WG (2021)

Before IRS

0.0 (0/39)

0.6 (2/318)

1

2.1 (1/47)

1.0 (1/100)

1

After IRS

1.7 (17/989)

1.5 (18/1177)

0.860

5.0 (27/542)

4.5 (61/1365)

0.7186

Outdoors

PM 300 CS (2019)

Before IRS

7.4 (2/27)

0.7 (1/136)

0.116

5.3 (1/19)

5.9 (2/34)

1

After IRS

0.9 (7/821)

0.9 (5/538)

1

6.4 (16/249)

0.4 (2/474)

 < 0.0001

Clo + Del (2020)

Before IRS

0.0 (0/13)

0.0 (0/101)

NA

0.0 (0/24)

2.7 (1/37)

1

After IRS

1.5 (5/332)

0.6 (3/487)

0.363

0.8 (6/748)

0.6 (6/1042)

0.776

Clo 50 WG (2021)

Before IRS

0.0 (0/30)

0.5 (1/215)

1

4.8 (2/42)

3.9 (2/52)

1

After IRS

1.1 (11/1038)

1.0 (13/1280)

1

5.0 (29/586)

4.4 (68/1544)

0.673

  1. SR: sporozoite rate; %: percentage; A: number of positive head-thoraxes tests; B: total number of heads-thoraxes tested; PM: pirimiphos-methyl; CS: capsule suspensions; WG: Water dispersible granules; Clot + Del: mixture clothianidin 500 g/kg + deltamethrin 62.5 g/kg; Clo 50 WG: clothianidin 50 WG alone
  2. P: p-value of comparisons between control commune and commune under IRS in each department