- Open Access
Distinction of Plasmodium falciparum recrudescence and re-infection by MSP2 genotyping: A caution about unstandardized classification criteria
© Rouse et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2008
- Received: 23 April 2008
- Accepted: 23 September 2008
- Published: 23 September 2008
Plasmodium falciparum genotyping with molecular polymorphic markers is widely employed to distinguish recrudescence from re-infection in antimalarial drug efficacy monitoring programmes. However, limitations occur on agarose gel DNA measurements used to resolve the polymorphisms. Without empirical data, the current distinction of pre- and post-treatment bands, as persistent or new infection, is subjective and often varying by author. This study measures empirical tolerance limits for classifying different-sized bands as same or different alleles during MSP2 genotyping.
P. falciparum field samples from 161 volunteers were genotyped by nested PCR using polymorphic MSP2 family-specific primers. Data were analysed to determine variability of band size measurements between identical MSP2 alleles randomized into different agarose lanes.
The mean (95% CI) paired difference in band size between identical alleles was 9.8 bp (1.48 – 18.16 bp, p = 0.022) for 3D7/IC and 2.54 (-3.04 – 8.05 bp, p = 0.362) for FC27. Based on these findings, pre- and post-treatment samples with 3D7/IC alleles showing less than 18 bp difference corresponded to recrudescence, with 95% confidence, while greater difference indicated new infection. FC27 allele differences were much narrower. For both 3D7/IC and FC27 amplicon, allele detection sensitivity was significantly higher with 13 μl compared to 20 μl or 30 μl lane loading volumes.
During MSP genotyping, it is useful to standardize classifications against measurement of background variability on identical alleles, in order to obtain reliable findings. It is critical to use a fixed optimal lane loading volume for constant allele patency, to avoid the disappearance or false appearance of new infection.
- Nest Polymerase Chain Reaction
- Band Size
- Identical Allele
- MSP2 Allele
- Allele Intensity
Increasing resistance to antimalarial therapy is one of the major obstacles for malaria control worldwide [1–3]. Consequently, surveillance of therapeutic efficacy of these drugs over time is an essential component of malaria control.
In endemic areas, the reappearance of asexual erythrocytic stages of P. falciparum after a correct therapeutic course may be attributed to either recrudescence of drug-resistant parasites or a new infection. Molecular genotyping with MSP1, MSP2 and GLURP polymorphic markers is now widely used to distinguish recrudescence from re-infection during in vivo drug efficacy monitoring programmes[4, 5].
Infections can be distinguished by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) fingerprinting. PCR has important potential advantages for being highly sensitive and specific in detecting malaria parasitaemia. Comparing pre- and post-therapy isolates provides information about the clonality of any persistent infection. However, although straightforward in principle, the current methods used to interpret results vary widely. Band size variability between same alleles can occur on agarose gels. Current classifications of alleles as same or different are often subjective and varying between authors, with no empirical data. A recent MMV/WHO consensus report on P. falciparum genotyping recommends possible use of polyacrylamide gels, capillary electrophoresis, or use of dedicated fragment sizing software, to increase discriminatory power. However, band size variability between same alleles can still occur, leading to false categorization as different alleles. The present study examines band size variance within and between MSP2 alleles and measures empirical thresholds for classing infections as same or different.
Study area and data collection
The study was conducted in a 2000 km2 area from the vicinity of the Malaria Institute at Macha, in Southern Province of Zambia. The area encompasses four chiefdoms (Mapanza, Chikanta, Macha and Muchila), with an estimated population of 180,000 and experiences hyperendemic malaria transmission. The study was based on a simple random sample of 161 thick film-positive residents of all ages and either sex. Volunteers who gathered at designated central areas were screened for malaria by microscopy. P. falciparum DNA samples were collected by blotting fingerprick blood from thick film-positives onto Whatman No 3 MM filter paper as previously described .
Informed consent was sought from each participant and in the case of children, from their guardians. Ethical clearance was obtained from both the national and John Hopkins University IRB's.
DNA extraction and PCR
P. falciparum DNA was extracted from air-dried filter paper blood samples using the chelex method[10, 11]. The extracted DNA was amplified using nested PCR and MSP2 family specific primers as previously described. First-round PCR primers corresponded to conserved sequences flanking these regions. Second-round PCR primers were used to amplify the 3D7/IC and FC27 allelic families of MSP2. For both primary and secondary reactions a 100 μl total volume was used comprising: 8 μl template, 0.25 μM MSP2 primers, 1.5 mM magnesium chloride, 200 μM dNTP's, 1× PCR Buffer and 4 U of Taq DNA polymerase. PCR annealing cycles for both primary and secondary MSP2 reactions consisted of an initial two minute denaturation step at 94°C, followed by 25 cycles of denaturation at 94°C for 45 seconds, annealing at 61.1°C for 45 seconds and extension at 65°C for one minute. Final extension was at 65°C for two minutes. The PCR amplifications were performed in a Thermo Electron® PX2 (HBPX2) thermal cycler.
Agarose gel electrophoresis
PCR product was resolved by electrophoresis on ethidium bromide-stained 1.5% agarose gels, on a standard 11 cm × 9 cm casting tray. Gel thickness was 1.5 cm with well sizes of 1.2 cm depth × 0.7 cm length × 0.1 cm width. Duplicate amplicon for each sample was individually randomized and loaded separately in 13 ul volumes per lane (denoted lane A and lane B). Subsequently, each sample amplicon was also loaded into randomized single lanes in 20 ul and then 30 ul volumes. Therefore, because of randomization, some duplicate samples were run in adjacent or non-adjacent lanes. PCR products for 3D7/IC and FC27 family specific primers were run in separate lanes and bands were visualized by UV transillumination. Molecular weight, band mass and intensity were measured using the Kodak 1D Imaging system.
Data were analysed to determine the mean and 95% confidence limits of paired differences in band size between identical MSP2 alleles randomized into different agarose lanes. Linear regression was used to study the relationship between paired band size mean difference and allele size after controlling for confounders. Potential confounders included locus used, participants' age and sex, allele intensity, allele mass and streak pattern. Paired-sample t test was used to determine if means statistically differed by volume and locus. McNemar's test was used to calculate MSP2 allele patency by lane loading volume and Wilcoxon Z test used to compare number of alleles detected.
One hundred and sixty one samples were used to assess the tolerance limits for band size classifications. All genotyping was done using MSP2 with varied volumes of 13 ul, 20 ul and 30 ul. Participants were aged between 2 – 61 years (median 10 years) with an even distribution between the sexes. Asexual parasite density ranged from 0 – 16560 parasites/μl, with a geometric mean (95% CI) of 364 (119 – 610) asexual parasites/μl.
Inter-lane variability in 3D7/IC and FC27 allele size measurements
Inter-lane variability in FC27 allele size measurements
MSP2 allele detection in relation to gel loading volume
There were no significant differences in detected allele size distribution by sample loading volume. Using 13 ul, the mean (95% CI) 3D7/IC allele sizes were 502.6 bp (95% CI: 482.4 – 522.7 bp) in lane A; 516.5 bp (95% CI: 497.7 – 535.3 bp) in lane B; 487.3 bp (95% CI: 457.6 – 516.9 bp) in 20 ul lane; and 479.3 bp (95% CI: 448.7 – 509.9 bp) in 30 ul lane (p = 0.182).
Corresponding mean (95% CI) readings for FC27 were 341.0 bp (95%CI: 322.9 – 359.1 bp) in 13 ul lane A; 346.4 bp (95% CI: 328.5 – 364.3 bp) in 13 ul lane B; 345.4 bp (95% CI: 325.4 – 365.4 bp) in 20 ul lane and 350.1 bp (333.1 – 367.2 bp) in 30 ul lane (p = 0.921).
Allele detection per sample by loading volume and MSP2 locus.
Lane loading volume
Mean number of alleles per sample [range]
ψ Wilcoxon Z (P value)
ψ Wilcoxon Z (P value)
13 μl (A)
13 μl (B)
-3.788 (< 0.001)
MSP2 allele patency by lane loading volume.
Lane loading volume
13 ul (B)
13 μl (A)
13 μl (A)
The variability seen in paired band size mean difference was not accounted for by sex, age, allele intensity, allele mass or locus used.
In antimalarial drug efficacy monitoring programmes, molecular genotyping with MSP1, MSP2 and GLURP polymorphic markers is widely used to distinguish recrudescence from re-infection. However, one of the current limitations for this invaluable "PCR correction" is that similar-sized alleles are often classed as same or different infections, using subjective visual inspection on agarose gels. Other workers have adopted a 10 bp cut off point  illustrating arbitrary variability between authors, with no standardizing experimental data.
The present study ascertained tolerance limits for empirically classing different-sized bands as recrudescence or re-infection, during MSP2 genotyping. This classification is the key basis for identifying drug therapeutic failure from new infections during in vivo drug efficacy assessments. The results show that band size measurements for the same allele can vary appreciably on agarose gels, presumably for varied reasons, ranging from gel running conditions, human error and complexity of infection. Identical MSP2 alleles could differ in band size, by up to 18 bp for 3D7/IC and 11 bp, for FC27 families. Therefore, visual distinction of infections is not reliable. For the reported data, post-treatment alleles exhibiting differences below these upper limits could thus be classed as recrudescence, with 95% confidence, while those above these thresholds could be considered as re-infection.
Neither band size nor lane streaking was significantly different by loading volume. Mean allele size was significantly larger for 3D7/IC than FC27 and not dependent on participants' age or sex, allele intensity or mass. Readings from a 13 ul loading volume detected significantly more 3D7/IC and FC27 alleles than higher 20 ul and 30 ul volumes.
The current study estimated absolute band size variability for identical alleles randomized on agarose gel lanes. During routine genotyping for drug efficacy monitoring trials, pre and post samples are generally placed in adjacent wells when viewing. This may lead to narrower allele differences than reported. Furthermore, the measurements cannot be generalized for different laboratories and separation systems. Individual laboratories would need to measure within allele variability for their own electrophoresis apparatus to standardize their genotyping classifications.
This study shows that it is useful to standardize MSP2 genotyping classifications against measurement of background band size variability on identical alleles, in order to obtain reliable findings. Furthermore, a fixed optimal lane loading volume is critical for constant allele patency, to avoid the disappearance or false appearance of new infection.
This work was funded by the John Hopkins Malaria Research Institute (JHMRI), and the Johns Hopkins School of Public Health (JHSPH). Our gratitude to all the staff and fieldworkers of the Malaria Institute at Macha (MIAM) who contributed to this study, and most importantly, to the volunteers from the chiefdoms of Macha, Mapanza, Muchila and Chikanta, for their participation. Special thanks to both Gift Moono and Christopher Simoloka for conducting all P. falciparum DNA extractions.
- David KP, Alifrangis M, Salanti A, Vestergaard LS, Ronn A, Bygbjerg IB: Atovaquone/proguanil resistance in Africa: a case report. Scand J Infect Dis. 2003, 35: 897-898. 10.1080/00365540310016862.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Farnert A, Lindberg J, Gil P, Swedberg G, Berqvist Y, Thapar MM, Lindegardh N, Berezcky S, Bjorkman A: Evidence of Plasmodium falciparum malaria resistant to atovaquone and proguanil hydrochloride: case reports. Bmj. 2003, 326: 628-629. 10.1136/bmj.326.7390.628.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fivelman QL, Butcher GA, Adagu IS, Warhurst DC, Pasvol G: Malarone treatment failure and in vitro confirmation of resistance of Plasmodium falciparum isolate from Lagos, Nigeria. Malar J. 2002, 1: 1-10.1186/1475-2875-1-1.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ayala E, Lescano AG, Gilman RH, Calderon M, Pinedo VV, Terry H, Cabrera L, Vinetz JM: Polymerase chain reaction and molecular genotyping to monitor parasitological response to anti-malarial chemotherapy in the Peruvian Amazon. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2006, 74: 546-553.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cattamanchi A, Kyabayinze D, Hubbard A, Rosenthal PJ, Dorsey G: Distinguishing recrudescence from reinfection in a longitudinal antimalarial drug efficacy study: comparison of results based on genotyping of msp-1, msp-2, and glurp. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2003, 68: 133-139.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- WHO: Assessment and Monitoring of Antimalarial Drug Efficacy for the Treatment of Uncomplicated Falciparum Malaria. 2003, Geneva: World Health OrganizationGoogle Scholar
- Snounou G, Beck HP: The use of PCR genotyping in the assessment of recrudescence or reinfection after antimalarial drug treatment. Parasitology Today. 1998, 14: 11-10.1016/S0169-4758(98)01340-4.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Anon: Methods and techniques for clinical trials on antimalarial drug efficacy: genotyping to identify parasite populations. Informal consultation organized by the Medicines for Malaria Venture and cosponsored by the World Health Organization, 29–31 May Amsterdam, The Netherlands. 2008, Medicines for Malaria Venture and World Health OrganizationGoogle Scholar
- Mharakurwa S, Simoloka C, Thuma PE, Shiff CJ, Sullivan DJ: PCR detection of Plasmodium falciparum in human urine and saliva samples. Malar J. 2006, 5: 103-10.1186/1475-2875-5-103.PubMed CentralView ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Plowe CV, Djimde A, Bouare M, Doumbo O, Wellems TE: Pyrimethamine and proguanil resistance-conferring mutations in Plasmodium falciparum dihydrofolate reductase: polymerase chain reaction methods for surveillance in Africa. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1995, 52: 565-568.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Plowe CV, Wellems TE: Molecular approaches to the spreading problem of drug resistant malaria. Adv Exp Med Biol. 1995, 390: 197-209.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Snounou G, Zhu X, Siripoon N, Jarra W, Thaithong S, Brown KN, Viriyakosol S: Biased distribution of msp1 and msp2 allelic variants in Plasmodium falciparum populations in Thailand. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1999, 93: 369-374. 10.1016/S0035-9203(99)90120-7.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.