- Open Access
Natural relapses in vivax malaria induced by Anopheles mosquitoes
Malaria Journal volume 7, Article number: 64 (2008)
Monthly malaria cases in Finland during 1750–1850 revealed regionally different peaks. The main peak was in late spring in the whole country, but additional peaks occurred in August and December in some regions of Finland. Both primary infections and relapses caused deaths from malaria. The cause and timing of relapses are analysed.
Monthly data of deaths from malaria in 1750–1850 were successively correlated with mean temperatures of June and July of five years in succession forwards from the current year and through 10 years in succession backwards to identify timing of relapses in Plasmodium vivax.
Malaria cases show an increasing correlation with June-July temperatures, with peaks in late summer, midwinter and late spring and then dropped gradually during 2–9 years from the first summer depending on the region. The longest incubation time identified was 8 years and 7 months.
High correlations of June-July temperatures with deaths from malaria in August to September in the same year indicate a close connection to the new generation of hatching Anopheles mosquitoes. Because rapid sporogony before October is impossible in Finland, the most plausible explanation is an early induction of relapses of vivax malaria by uninfected anophelines. Malaria cases during the winter and the following spring are caused by both primary infections and induced relapses. All subsequent cases represent relapses. It is proposed that the basic relapse patterns in vivax malaria are regulated by anophelines. It is also proposed that the Plasmodium is enhancing blood sucking of Anopheles messeae, which so far has been considered a bad vector.
It has long been known that vivax malaria causes relapses in a variable degree. The malarial relapse including a pre-erythrocytic stage in Plasmodium vivax was first outlined in 1948 [1, 2], but the true relapse stage, the hypnozoite, was only identified in 1982 . The exact cause of activation of hypnozoites has so far remained unexplained . Regionally different incubation times have been recognized [5–7], suggesting a polymorphic genetic basis for the incubation time [8, 9]. In general it seems that P. vivax of the temperate zone has a longer incubation time than its tropical counterpart although a long incubation time of tropical malaria is also known . No convincing explanation for the regulation of the incubation time has been presented . In 2004, however, Paul, Diallo and Brey discussed the role of the bites of uninfected mosquitoes in the seasonal transmission of Plasmodium falciparum .
The northern P. vivax disappeared in the 20th century and can only be studied through data in historical sources and archives. The Finnish malaria can be studied according to statistics of deaths from malaria in the parish registers since 1749. These high resolution data are very representative and homogeneous during the time span of 100 years and permits statistical analysis with different parameters. The data also give a detailed insight in the historical distribution of P. vivax malaria in northern regions. The mortality in malaria under this period is not biased by the use of cinchona bark or quinine because the ordinary people could not afford them.
June and July temperatures were relevant in influencing the size of the adult Anopheles population which hatched in the end of July and August. This had an impact on the malaria situation during the following 12 months .
This study aims to explain the underlying cause of relapses and to determine the length of the incubation time of P. vivax malaria in Finland.
Statistics on malaria deaths in 1750–1850 were collected from the parish registers as described in Huldén et al . The closest complete temperature series that cover the time span of the malaria data was taken from Uppsala, Sweden . It has been demonstrated that the use of Swedish temperature records at this level gives a reliable picture of the principal temperature trends in Finland .
Data for monthly deaths from malaria in the period 1750 to 1850 were compared with June/July temperatures for the corresponding period and stepwise 10 years backwards in time, 132 months in all (1750–1850, 1749–1849, 1748–1848 etc.). In order to demonstrate the difference between trends and noise the data for monthly deaths from malaria were also compared with June/July temperatures stepwise 5 years forwards in time, 60 months in all (1751–1851 to 1755–1855).
The study area was divided into four regions: Åland islands, SW-coast with archipelago, western mainland and eastern mainland (Figure 1). The regions were chosen according to the known distribution patterns of the Anopheles species. In the first two regions Anopheles messeae is very common with rare finds of Anopheles claviger. Åland islands are separated because of a strongly biased gender-related ratio of malaria cases (men/women ca. 40/60%). Men were less exposed to Anopheles mosquitoes in the main transmission season in winter/spring because they spent long time in mosquito free conditions when they were out fishing and seal hunting remotely on the sea ice. On the western mainland only A. messeae is known, and on the eastern mainland both A. messeae and Anopheles beklemishevi are common.
The highest correlation of deaths from malaria with the June-July temperature occurs in April – May during the spring peak of malaria in the following year. The correlation coefficient is then gradually declining during the subsequent years. The regional correlation trends are given for SW-coast and Eastern Finland in Figures 2 and 3.
Most remarkably, there is a sudden increasing correlation between mean temperatures of June – July and deaths from malaria already in August or September during the current year. Because Anopheles mosquitoes in Finland are in larval stage in June and July, this high correlation indicates that the new emerging generation of uninfected mosquitoes is somehow involved in the malaria deaths in August and September.
Induction of relapses
The temperatures in outdoor conditions in Finland are too low for a rapid sporogonic cycle of P. vivax to be completed for a new transmission of sporozoites. Nearly all of the primary infections take place indoors during winter and spring . The conclusion is that uninfected anophelines in August and September are inducing an activation of P. vivax hypnozoites in humans. As a consequence, relapses in vivax malaria are induced by anophelines. The time limits for relapses or infections in relation to timing of deaths from malaria are schematically presented in Figure 4.
It seems probable that only the bites by anophelines can induce a relapse. In Finland the nuisances of mosquitoes outdoors culminates in June and July . An investigation of the man-biting species in early July all over Finland encountered eleven Culicinae species belonging to the genera Aedes and Culiseta, but no Anopheles species . If any of these species could have induced relapses it would have made the monthly correlation pattern of malaria different.
The maximum length of dormancy until the manifested relapse varies between the regions. On the SW-coast and in the western mainland the length of dormancy is less than two years (estimated from the peak of primary infections in April-May). In Åland islands the maximum length is tentatively 3–5 years and in eastern Finland nearly 9 years. The monthly correlation trends of malaria during 10 years after primary infection for eastern mainland are for additional clarity extracted in Figures 5, 6 and 7. The malaria year is presented as the time from August to July in the subsequent year. During the first year high correlation to June-July temperatures in August and September must exclusively represent relapses. Correlation peaks during midwinter are probably mostly caused by relapses with occasional primary infections. This is concluded from the fact that few mosquitoes in the heated cottages had the chance to become infected during the first wave of malaria relapses in August-September because most of the household members then slept separated in unheated buildings. Usually in October people were forced to move together in a heated building because of the decreasing temperatures. Infected mosquitoes in the unheated buildings could not then transmit the parasite further. The proportion of infected mosquitoes in the heated building must have been very low in the beginning of October. Only 15% of Anopheles messeae take blood before entering overwintering sites in the beginning of September. Only a small number of these may have got gametocytes from relapses caused by other mosquitoes of the same generation, and finally, only very few of these infected individuals could have by chance entered those buildings where humans in October moved for the winter season. The number of primary infections started to increase at an accelerating rate after midwinter culminating in the high correlation peak in April-May. All subsequent peaks in the correlation (although not necessarily all malaria cases) represent exclusively relapses because the overwintering Anopheles dies soon after egg-laying in May. In the case of the eastern mainland the correlation trends reveals that the midwinter peak is preserved for the longest time.
In order to separate trends from noise, the corresponding trends for malaria death cases in eastern mainland are also correlated against June-July temperatures five years in future, which cannot have any real connections to the deaths from malaria (Figure 8). These five years represent random noise and differ distinctly in structure from the trends 6 to 9 years back in time (Figure 5, 6 and 7), which still cluster in midwinter.
In order to check the stability of the regional correlation patterns each regional data series were divided into two periods, 1750–1799 and 1800–1850. These time series can be regarded as two completely independent data sets. The results for two years are presented for eastern mainland in Figure 9. The two correlation series are strikingly similar although the number of malaria death cases may vary between the time series, August in particular. The two time series of Åland islands (not illustrated) deviate slightly from the others, but this is probably due to the exceptional demographic conditions where the male population has changed seasonal means of livelihood. Otherwise the data suggest a robust basis for regionally determined patterns.
It is known that the saliva of Anophelines and Culicines has different vasodilators and anticoagulants suggesting independent evolutionary events . When the released sporozoites migrate from the oocysts in the outer wall of the midgut of the mosquito female to the salivary glands, they are detecting and attracted by certain molecules in the structures of the glands. These molecules, however, are not a component of the saliva itself. An ability to detect some component in the saliva must have passed through the sporozoite to the hypnozoite. This information could be imprinted in the sporozoite genome itself or resulting from an interaction between the sporozoite and saliva.
A polymorphic basis of P. vivax relapse patterns has been proposed (described as strains or subspecies of P. vivax) [8, 9]. The current results give some insight into the evolutionary patterns of P. vivax biology. It would be a considerable advantage for the Plasmodium to be able to alter the timing of gametocyte production in relation to the phenology of the mosquitoes. It is obvious that if the hypnozoite has the capacity to detect blood feeding by the new generation of mosquitoes from humans, the Plasmodium can optimize the production of gametocytes when the mosquitoes are abundant. An ability to detect the presence of suitable vectors would also maximize the probabilities of P. vivax to adapt to new distant areas with different local vector behaviour. The Plasmodium is mainly spreading to the new areas by means of infected humans. In the northern taiga region, the principal time of travel was winter, when adult Anopheles mosquitoes were hibernating indoors. As a result the combined behaviour of the vector and human host enhanced cold season transmission and spreading of malaria in northern regions.
The regionally different relapse patterns of malaria, from a maximum of one to two years to a maximum of more than five years, suggest both a western and eastern origin of P. vivax in Finland. The prolonged relapse time in eastern Finland may refer to the P. vivax strain hibernans described from Russia, which gradually dominates towards the taiga region. The western form with a shorter maximum relapse time (one to two years) may refer to the north-west European strain known from Germany, the Netherlands and the British Isles.
If the variation in the relapse time of hypnozoites is a polymorphic character in P. vivax, the variation in the relapse time can be explained as a result of regional and seasonal variation in the mosquito vector. Unpredictable seasonality or unpredictable mosquito populations will select for a character that produces hypnozoites with a long relapse time to ensure the survival of Plasmodium population. Unpredictability in these conditions increases towards the north and colder regions in the temperate zone and correlates with the increase of long relapse time of vivax malaria. The long relapse time in the tropics is less pronounced because the relapse is easily hidden by continuous presence of mosquitoes. Long relapse time up to four years is, however, also known from the tropics .
It is assumed that the polymorphic character in vivax malaria is defined by the time during which the hypnozoites are resistant to activation. After the resistance time the hypnozoites become sensitive to activation. In natural conditions the sensitive hypnozoites are expected to remain inactive until the new anopheline generation starts to take blood. The anophelines trigger the sensitive hypnozoites to transform into schizonts and to produce merozoites in the human blood. Within a week or two the increasing new generation of anophelines will become infected by gametocytes from human blood. Hypnozoites with longer resistance time would still remain in the human liver until they also become sensitive to activation. Continuous unpredictable conditions (because of climate or other causes) will gradually select for a higher proportion of long incubation time, and may finally lead to regional strains ("forms" or "subspecies") like hibernans in which all sporozoites may be transformed into hypnozoites. This simple model explains most observations made on relapses of vivax malaria and is fitted for the needs of the Plasmodium to survive in variable environmental conditions.
Anopheles messeae as a vector
Anopheles messeae was the only vector covering most of the area where endemic malaria prevailed in Finland. The species has been questioned as a vector in the Netherlands and Sweden. In the Netherlands A. messeae increased and Anopheles atroparvus declined at the same time as malaria disappeared and it has been assumed that it does not enter heated buildings as often as A. atroparvus . In Sweden, it was found that A. messeae only marginally take blood before hibernation and that this is not obligatory for the hibernation success . In recent years, however,A. messeae has repeatedly been recorded in summer cottages in Finland during the cold season and it has also been observed biting man in the winter season [Kauri Mikkola personal communication 2006]. The Russian research also considers A. messeae an important vector in parts of the former Soviet Union . Lewis Hackett observed hibernating A. messeae in the beginning of the 1930's. When a mosquito was placed in a warm environment it sucked blood and Hackett concluded that the need for nourishment depended on the conditions in the hibernating place . In 1996, A. messeae was identified as the principal vector of resurgent malaria in Russia . The Finnish anophelines entered shelter for hibernation during September and at that time most people still slept in unheated sheds. As a consequence the anophelines entered suitable sheds and buildings at random only some of which later were to be heated. The heating of the crowded traditional log houses in the 18th and 19th century during winter produced very warm and humid conditions which were favourable for semiactive overwintering mosquitoes but which forced the mosquitoes to take extra blood meals to survive. A representative case of late 18th century and early 19th century building is shown in Figure 10.
It is known that the actual number of sporozoites entering humans during blood feeding of an infected mosquito is low although the total production of sporozoites is high . There are indications of enhanced blood feeding with increased number of sporozoites in the salivary glands of Anopheles punctulatus and Anopheles gambiae . The Plasmodium needs to reach as many hosts as possible during the transmission season, which in Finland principally took place during the cold season from midwinter to spring. It is suggested that P. vivax similarly enhanced the Finnish vectors (A. messeae, A. beklemishevi) to take several blood meals in indoor conditions when the maximum number of sporozoites is available in the salivary glands. If P. vivax has the ability to alter the behaviour of the vector, it improves the parasite's capacity to adapt to new regions. Thus the results by Jaenson and Ameneshewa  are not in contradiction with the possibility that A. messeae can be an effective vector of malaria.
New interpretation of Plasmodium falciparum recrudescence
Hypnozoites are not known in P. falciparum and thus falciparum malaria does not have a true relapse. Falciparum malaria, however, may persist through non transmission seasons by means of latent trophozoites or schizonts in sequestered red blood cells in the microvascular system, or a process of antigenic variation [25–27]. It is known that in the beginning of the transmission season children under one year get malaria several weeks later than their mothers . It has been suggested that Anopheles and/or other genera of mosquitoes cause a sudden increase in infectivity in mothers who have latent schizonts from malaria in the previous transmission season. This "kick start" of malaria was discussed by Paul et al . In other words, a mother gets at first a recrudescence while the primary infection in the baby occurs only several weeks later. A new interpretation for this process is proposed. It is assumed that the Anopheles mosquitoes actually trigger the schizonts to produce merozoites in the same way as they trigger activation of hypnozoites in vivax malaria. In the case of vivax malaria in Finland, the Plasmodium could not afford to respond to any other mosquitoes than Anopheles species because of deviating seasonality. Similarly, it would be highly advantageous for P. falciparum to produce gametocytes as soon as the vector is becoming abundant. This is the most parsimonous model that explains the observations made on falciparum malaria.
The relapse mechanism in vivax malaria has long been an enigma to the scientific community. In modern times much of the research on the relapse concerns situations where medication has been in use. It is very probable that medication actually interfere with natural relapses. The Finnish statistical material is quite unique in this respect because practically no effective medication was practiced during 1750–1850. As a consequence natural relapses induced by mosquitoes in the historical statistics can be assessed in Finland.
It is proposed that P. vivax has the capacity to detect and alter blood feeding of the Anopheles vectors. Increased selection for hypnozoites, the dormant stage, is a response to unpredictable seasonal conditions. By these means vivax malaria could spread over a large part of the temperate region and is not limited by climatic conditions.
Ultimately demonstrating a molecule that triggers relapses or recrudescence could create new possibilities for medication of malaria. When hypnozoites can be artificially activated during the nontransmission season the medication will be more effective and further relapses prevented.
Shortt HEL, Garnham PCC: Pre-erythrocytic stage in mammalian malaria parasites. Nature (London). 1948, 161: 126-10.1038/161126a0.
Shortt HEL, Garnham PCC, Covell G, Shute PG: The pre-erythrocytic stage of human malaria, Plasmodium vivax. Br Med J. 1948, i: 547-
Krotoski WA, Collins WE, Bray RS, Garnham PCC, Cogswell FB, Gwads RW, Killick-Kendrick T, Wolf R, Sinden R, Konntz LC, Syanfill PS: Demonstration of hypnozoites in sporozoite-transmitted Plasmodium vivax infection. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1982, 31: 1291-1293.
Prudêncio M, Rodriguez A, Mota MM: The silent path to thousands of merozoites: the Plasmodium liver stage. Nat Rev Microbiol. 2006, 4 (11): 849-856. 10.1038/nrmicro1529.
Contacos PG, Collins WE, Jeffery GM, Krotoski WA, Howard WA: Studies on the characterization of Plasmodium vivax strains from Central America. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1972, 21: 707-712.
Garnham PCC, Bray RS, Bruce-Chwatt LJ, Draper CC, Killick-Kendrick R, Sergiev PG, Tiburskaja NA, Shute PG, Maryon M: A strain of Plasmodium vivax characterized by prolonged incubation: morphological and biological characteristics. Bull World Health Organ. 1975, 52: 21-32.
Adak T, Sharma VP, Orlov VS: Studies on the Plasmodium vivax relapse pattern in India. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1998, 59: 175-179.
Adak T, Valecha N, Sharma VP: Plasmodium vivax polymorphism in a clinical drug trial. Clin Diagn Lab Immunol. 2001, 8: 891-894. 10.1128/CDLI.8.5.891-894.2001.
Cui L, Escalante AE, Imwong M, Snounou G: The genetic diversity of Plasmodium vivax populations. Trends Parasitol. 2003, 19: 220-226. 10.1016/S1471-4922(03)00085-0.
Mangoni ED, Severini C, Menegon M, Romi R, Ruggiero G, Majori G: Case report: an unusual late relapse of Plasmodium vivax malaria. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2003, 68: 159-160.
Cogswell FB: The hypnozoite and relapse in primate malaria. Clin Microbiol Rev. 1992, 5 (1): 26-35.
Paul REL, Diallo M, Brey PT: Mosquitoes and transmission of malaria parasites – not just vectors. Malar J. 2004, 3: 39-10.1186/1475-2875-3-39.
Huldén Le, Huldén La, Heliövaara K: Endemic malaria: an 'indoor' disease in northern Europe. Historical data analysed. Malar J. 2005, 4: 19-10.1186/1475-2875-4-19.
Moberg A, Bergström H: Homogenization of Swedish Temperature Data. Part III: The Long Temperature Records from Uppsala and Stockholm. Int J Clim. 1997, 17: 667-700. 10.1002/(SICI)1097-0088(19970615)17:7<667::AID-JOC115>3.0.CO;2-J.
Natvig LR: Contributions to the knowledge of the Danish and Fennoscandian mosquitoes Culicini. Norsk Entomol Tidskr. 1948, 1-567. Suppl 1
Utrio P: Distribution of mosquitoes (Diptera, Culicidae) attracted by man in Finland in early July. Notulae Entomol. 1978, 58: 107-114.
Champagne DE: Antihemostatic molecules from saliva of blood-feeding arthropods. Pathophysiol Haemost Thromb. 2005, 34: 221-227. 10.1159/000092428.
Takken W, Geene R, Adam W, Jetten TH, Velden van der JA: Distribution and dynamics of larval populations of Anopheles messeae and A. atroparvus in the delta of the rivers Rhine and Meuse, the Netherlands. Ambio. 2001, 31 (3): 212-218. 10.1639/0044-7447(2002)031[0212:DADOLP]2.0.CO;2.
Jaenson TGT, Ameneshewa B: Prehibernation diet and reproductive condition of female Anopheles messeae in Sweden. Med Vet Entomol. 1991, 5: 243-252. 10.1111/j.1365-2915.1991.tb00547.x.
Sokolova MI, Snow KR: Malaria vectors in European Russia. European Mosquito Bulletin 2002 (12 May). 2002, [http://www.uel.ac.uk/mosquito/emb.htm] (12 May)
Hackett L: Maculipennis races: Their morphological and biological characters. League of Nations, Health Organisation, Malaria Commission. Geneva, March 28th. 1933, [http://www.who.int/library/collections/historical/en/index4.html] , CH/Malaria/203
Nikolaeva N: Resurgence of malaria in the former Soviet Union (FSU). Soc Vector Ecol Newsl. 1996, 27: 10-11.
Copeland RS: Mosquitoes: Parasite-Vector Interactions, Host-Vector Interactions and Population Management. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Tropical Entomology. 30th October – 4th November 1994. Edited by: Saini RK. 1994, Nairobi, Kenya, 105-126.
Paul REL, Ariey F, Robert V: The evolutionary ecology of Plasmodium. Ecol Lett. 2003, 6: 866-880. 10.1046/j.1461-0248.2003.00509.x.
Warrell DA, Cox TM, Firth JD, Benz EJ, eds: Oxford Textbook of Medicine. 2003, Oxford Univ Press, Oxford, 4
Nakazawa S, Kanbara H, Aikawa M: Recrudescence of Plasmodium falciparum in culture: unaffectedness and frequency of dormant parasites. Tokai J Exp Clin Med. 1998, 23: 99-100.
Pettersson F, Vogt AM, Jonsson C, Mok BW, Shamei Tousi A, Bergström S, Chen Q, Wahlgren M: Whole-body imaging of sequestration of Plasmodium falciparum in the rat. Infect Immun. 2005, 73: 7736-7746. 10.1128/IAI.73.11.7736-7746.2005.
The opinion article in 2004 by Paul, Diallo & Brey  inspired us to investigate the role of the vector of malaria. We also thank professor Kauri Mikkola for observing the A. messeae population in his summer cottage through hibernation. This study was supported by grants from Svenska Litteratursällskapet i Finland.
LeH drafted the manuscript and collected the historical data. LaH added and/or removed various sections and participated in the design of the study. KH conceived the study and participated in its design. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Huldén, L., Huldén, L. & Heliövaara, K. Natural relapses in vivax malaria induced by Anopheles mosquitoes. Malar J 7, 64 (2008) doi:10.1186/1475-2875-7-64
- Malaria Case
- Relapse Time
- Vivax Malaria