- Open Access
Treatment-seeking for febrile illness in north-east India: an epidemiological study in the malaria endemic zone
Malaria Journalvolume 8, Article number: 301 (2009)
This paper studies the determinants of utilization of health care services, especially for treatment of febrile illness in the malaria endemic area of north-east India.
An area served by two districts of Upper Assam representing people living in malaria endemic area was selected for household survey. A sample of 1,989 households, in which at least one member of household suffered from febrile illness during last three months and received treatment from health service providers, were selected randomly and interviewed by using the structured questionnaire. The individual characteristics of patients including social indicators, area of residence and distance of health service centers has been used to discriminate or group the patients with respect to their initial and final choice of service providers.
Of 1,989 surveyed households, initial choice of treatment-seeking for febrile illness was self-medication (17.8%), traditional healer (Vaidya)(39.2%), government (29.3%) and private (13.7%) health services. Multinomial logistic regression (MLR) analysis exhibits the influence of occupation, area of residence and ethnicity on choice of health service providers. The traditional system of medicine was commonly used by the people living in remote areas compared with towns. As all the febrile cases finally received treatment either from government or private health service providers, the odds (Multivariate Rate Ratio) was almost three-times higher in favour of government services for lower households income people compared to private.
The study indicates the popular use of self-medication and traditional system especially in remote areas, which may be the main cause of delay in diagnosis of malaria. The malaria training given to the paramedical staff to assist the health care delivery needs to be intensified and expanded in north-east India. The people who are economically poor and living in remote areas mainly visit the government health service providers for seeking treatment. So, the improvement of quality health services in government health sector and provision of health education to people would increase the utilization of government health services and thereby improve the health quality of the people.
Malaria is one of the major public health problems of many countries of world [1–3]. According to WHO report, almost 300 million cases of malaria occur worldwide and more than one million people die due to malaria every year . In India, malaria is reported from many states, but several deaths of epidemic proportion reported every year from different parts of north-east India [5–7]. Assam, being the most populated (27.85 million) and geographically second largest State (78,523 km2) of north-east India, is contributing more than 5% of the total number of cases of malaria reported in India. Most districts of the State are malaria-endemic and many pockets in forest, forest fringes, and foothill villages along the inter-country/inter-state border are vulnerable to malaria outbreak as reported . Chloroquine-resistant malaria is widespread in the State, and decreased sensitivity to other anti-malarial drugs has been documented . The malaria cases are detected throughout the year , but higher incidence is reported during May to October . There is often delay in reporting illness to health care providers and during these periods certain unorthodox practices are adopted as cost-saving measures.
Although investment in health sectors has been gradually increasing and many health programmes to control malaria, such as spraying DDT in high-risk areas, use of impregnated-bed nets and mass collection of blood slides form the community, have been launched by the government, but there is no appreciable change in malaria incidence. A clear understanding about the health-seeking behaviour of households is crucial for an effective control programme of malaria. For instance, the implementation of current strategy for the control of malaria is mostly based on early diagnosis. It is important to know the factors that determine the utilization of the services of a health care provider for suspected cases of malaria so that an effective strategy can be developed.
Utilization patterns of health service mainly depend on quality of service offered by health care providers and whether it is affordable by the individual user. Moreover, impact of quality differences on the use of health care facilities is to be assessed simultaneously with household and individual characteristics affecting the utilization. The preference of one health care provider over another will be affected not only by facility characteristics (quality of service and cost of service), but also by the individual characteristics such as preferences, affordability, convenient, education level, and household income.
The present study is an attempt to assess the various options of health care patients normally follow for seeking treatment of febrile illness or malaria and also estimate the factors associated with the choice of health services. In the endemic areas, fever is the most common symptom for suspected cases of malaria and is, therefore, being used interchangeably .
Observing high incidence of malaria, two districts of upper Assam, namely Tinsukia and Golaghat, were selected as study area for conducting the survey. A sample of 2,000 households was worked out to capture the variability in health care services and its utilization for both the districts. In the first stage, 50 PSUs (census villages/wards) were selected randomly from each district by using the method of probability proportional to size (PPS) sampling and 20 households from each PSU were selected in a second stage by systematic sampling. The household listing of selected PSUs was prepared during the survey by visiting house-to-house and enquiring whether anybody had malaria or fever in last three months. Those households who reported a fever case and also described the symptom of disease before seeking treatment were recorded in the household listing. A sample of 20 such households, who had received treatment of fever, was selected from the household listing by using systematic sampling. The limitation of such a technique without parasitological analysis is obvious, but in the rural community without laboratory facilities, malaria is diagnosed by the symptoms and clinical manifestations of the disease.
The heads of the selected households, or the most senior person, were interviewed by the trained field workers to collect the general information, whereas specific information about the treatment of fever was collected from the individual patient or mother of sick child in a pre-tested questionnaire. The questionnaire included information about the household, such as household income, education, ethnicity and the use of various options of health care providers for seeking treatment of fever, awareness about malaria, traditional belief and practices, distance of nearest health center (government/private) from residence.
Health care delivery in north-east India is mainly provided through the government, private practitioners and private industries. A structural approach to provide health services by population unit is adopted by the government, which is similar to the all-India model (World Bank 1997). The government health care system is mainly categorized in four levels, based upon amenities and service facilities. According to the facility levels, they are district hospitals, community health centers (CHC), primary health centers (PHC) and sub-centers (SHC). The second largest health care service providers are private hospitals of tea gardens, oil and coal industries, including the health clinics of private practitioners.
The traditional system on the other hand comprises the Vaidya (herbalists) and priests. The traditional Vaidya mainly use herbs for the preparation indigenous medicine and to provide treatment of diseases. The priests (ojha) are believed to 'invoke the spiritual powers' of a deity in diagnosis and treatment of disease. They perform spiritual prayer and also sacrifice of birds or animals during prayer to cure the disease. This system is still being practiced in remote areas and is popular among some tribal communities.
Self-medication is rapidly increasing among all sections of the society, because it saves consultation fees and traveling cost to the health center. In remote areas, the medicines for fever are available and sold freely in the general shop. In towns, the scenario is different, the people describe the symptoms to the drug store operator, who may not necessarily be a pharmacist, and obtain suggestions for drugs to purchase.
Data collected from the 1989 households in the survey were analysed to identify the possible associated factors with utilization of health services. Statistical tests were applied to examine the association and differences, wherever applicable [13, 14]. The geographical area of selected PSUs (villages/wards) was categorized as town, flood, forest, tea garden, and others (Plain area) on the basis of information collected in the survey. Those villages affected by flood every year were categorized as flood area, whereas villages located inside or close to forest were categorized as forest area. Occupation was mainly classified as service (permanent job with regular income and pensioners), self-employed (businessman and professionals), farmer (agriculture), housewives, and others (unemployed, labourers, students). The majority of the households were Hindu (93.6%). Ethnicity of the household respondents was grouped as Assamese (non-tribal), Assam tribes (including Missing, Sonowal, Kachari), Tea tribes of Assam (mainly confined to tea gardens), Bengali (Hindu family), Nepali (originally from Nepal) and others (mostly people who came from other States of India such as Rajasthan, Bihar, Nagaland).
Multinomial logistic regression analysis was used to estimate the rate ratios with respect to indicator/reference category for comparison and identification of actual associates . While seeking treatment of fever, the individual has used more than one option of available treatment. In the model, initial choice of health care service providers, such as traditional system, self-medication, government and private health service, were taken as dependent (or outcome) variable and all other variables viz. residence area, gender, ethnicity, education, occupation, age and income of household, were included as independent variable. However, the analysis was repeated again with the final choice of treatment option (i.e. government or private) used by the individual to know the differences. The Statistical software, SPSS 12.0 was used for statistical analysis.
The study was conducted after obtaining approval of the Scientific Advisory Committee (SAC) of the Indian Council of Medical Research. Ethical advice was followed for conducting the survey. The district health administrations and tea garden authorities were also informed to provide local support during the study. At village level, a verbal consent of the village headman was obtained and he was consulted before conducting the survey. Before questioning, the households were apprised in the understandable local language regarding the purpose of visit by the field investigator. The interview was conducted after obtaining consent of the household respondent.
The general characteristics of household respondents such as age, household income, education, occupation, area of residence, health care services used, distance of nearest health center (government/private) from residence, are presented district-wise for comparison (Table 1). The mean household income was Rs. 2,534 ± 1,816 (INR) per month, but it was significantly lower in Tinsukia district. Variability in monthly household income was high as is reflected by the standard deviation. About 47% of respondents were illiterate and 10% educated up to secondary and above. A majority of the respondents were farmers (38.6%), followed by service class (22%) and self-employed (12.6%) people. Most of the respondents were Hindu (93.6%) and ethically belong to different tribal and non-tribal communities of Assam. The residential area of households was categorized as town (12%), forest (23.0%), flood (22.0%), tea garden (26.3%) and other (16.7%) plain area. The health care services attended initially for seeking treatment of febrile illness were traditional system (39.2%), government health services (29.3%), private health services (13.7%) and self-medication (17.8%) (Figure 1). Except self-medication, the use of health services differs significantly between the tow districts. The average distance to the nearest health center (Government/Private) was 4.2 ± 5.6 km, which was slightly lower for Golaghat district.
Health care services used by the households and its differences across socio-demographic characteristics of households, residential area and patient's characteristics are presented with statistical analysis (Table 2). The association of health care services was significant with all the variables, except gender of patients. The traditional system was the first choice of treatment among majority of people residence in tea garden (60%), flood (43.7%) and forest (33.8%) areas. However, self-medication was popular in forest (25.8%) and town (25.5%) areas. A decreasing pattern in the use of the traditional system was observed with increasing level of education of household heads. It was also recorded to be high among farmers (42.5%), tea tribes (57.1%) and Nepali (50.5%) communities. As an initial choice, self-medication was high among higher educational groups, i.e. secondary+ (20.7%); farmers (24.3%); Nepali (26.9%) and Assamese (20.2%) communities. It was also recorded high among higher household income groups (21.4%). The increasing pattern of self-medication was observed with increase age group of patients.
Government health service, as initial choice of seeking treatment, was high in all the residential areas (32% to 42%), except in tea garden areas (14.2%). It was also shown to be low among tea tribes of Assam (14.8%). Similarly, the private health services were commonly used in town (29.3%) and tea gardens (17.8%). Utilization of private health services was also high among tea tribes (20.3%) and higher household income group (17.7%).
Analysis of final choice of seeking treatment indicated the significant association with location, area of residence, occupation, ethnicity, household income and distance of nearest health center. However, the association of education and gender of patients was not significant. The utilization of government health services was significantly higher in Golaghat district (78.5%) compared to Tinsukia (52.5%). It was also recorded high in forest (80.6%) and flood area (78.9%). The private health services were used commonly in tea garden areas, especially by the tea tribes (Table 2).
The results of multinomial logistics regression (MLR) analysis with initial and final treatment-seeking choice are presented in Table 3. The estimated coefficients (β) of the variables in the model indicate how changes in each of the variable affect the household choice of health service providers for seeking treatment of febrile illness. Except for gender of patients, a significant effect of location, residential area, education, occupation, ethnicity, age of patients and household income was recorded with the dependent variables, i.e. health care services. Multivariate rate ratios (MRR) for traditional system as initial choice was significantly higher for residential area: tea garden (5.6), flood (3.2), forest (1.5); level of education: literate (1.7); ethnic group: Assamese (1.5) and tea tribes (3.4); and distance of health center: ≥ 5 km (1.4) compare with respective reference. It clearly indicates that the use of traditional system of medicine was much higher in tea garden, forest and flood affected area with compare to town and others. The MRR of government service as initial choice was significantly higher for education: literate (1.4); occupation: service and self-employed (2.4); others (1.9); and low household income (1.8). The household income was one of the important determinants for utilization of government services. However, there was no significant effect of residential area and ethnic background of people. The private services as initial choice shows the significantly higher value of MRR (odd) with location: Golaghat (1.5); education: literate (1.4); occupation: service and self-employed (4.1) and others (3.4); ethnic group: tea tribes (2.6); and age of patients: lower age group (1.9) compare to respective reference. However, there was no significant effect of residential area, household income and gender of patients on utilization of private health services.
As a final choice of seeking treatment, the MLR analysis shows the significant effect of location, education, occupation, ethnicity, household income and distance of nearest health center with government health services utilization with reference to private services. The estimated values of β and MRR shows the significant negative or decreasing effect with location: Tinsukia (-1.16; 0.3); education: literate (-0.47 & 0.6); occupation: service & self-employed (-1.15 & 0.32) and others (-0.93 & 0.2); and ethnic group: tea tribes (-1.59 & 0.2) with their respective reference. However, it was almost three times higher in favour of government health services for lower income (≤ 2000 INR) group (2.9). If the distance of health center increases (≥ 5 km), the MRR was significantly higher (1.6) in favour of government health services. The area of residence was not showing any effect with the final choice of two health services i.e. government or private.
A better understanding of health-seeking behaviour of people, especially when suffering from fever, a common symptom of malaria, is important for effective management and control of malaria. This is related with early treatment, accessibility and proper use of drugs. The most common treatment options reported by the households for seeking treatment of fever was use of traditional drugs, self-medication, government and private health services, which was also reported by others in many studies [16–19].
The use of traditional medicines was prevalent in remote areas especially in tea gardens, forest and flood affected areas. It seems that internal factors of the specific geographical region like availability and accessibility of health services; traditional belief and practices was motivating the people for seeking medical assistance from traditional system (Vaidya). Although most of the people received treatment finally from government or private health services, but majority of them initially visited to traditional Vaidya for seeking treatment of febrile illness. The strong belief in traditional system was reflected even among literate people. A study in Tanzania also reported that traditional healers are an important factor of delay for malaria treatment .
Self-medication and consultations at medical stores was a common practice in town and forest areas. Such practices created a situation where people wait till the patient become serious enough before reporting to health centers. Obviously, some of these patients develop complications and even die by the time they reach a hospital. No doubt, the 'wait-and-watch' attitude is not only harmful to the patients, but also contributing to increased malaria. These practices are very common not only among un-educated and poor people, but across most of the variables included in the analysis. This was also reported and discussed by others [20–22].
Over all, response of availing government health services was high by the people residing in forest and flood affected area. Moreover, the people from town and tea garden areas were seeking treatment mainly from private health services, because private health services were mainly confined in the town and private tea gardens located outside the town nearby the tea gardens. Despite longer distances and poor connectivity to motorable roads, the accessibility to government health services was recorded high among the people living in forest and flood areas. The increasing level of education of household head has decreasing effect with accessibility of government services. The MRR was also significantly low for literates with reference to illiterates. Household income is one of the important determinants for health service utilization. Similarly, increasing level of household income has decreasing effect with accessibility of government services. It was possibly due to the expensive treatment in private health centers. The socio-economic impact on choice of health services was also discussed by others [23–26].
Early diagnosis of febrile illness or malaria can yield rich dividends for effective management and control of malaria [18, 27–29]. Though the distance to a health center is one of the important factors of delay, its effect may be confounded with the place of residence. Residential areas such as forest, flood and tea garden, show the highest preference for traditional system and self-medication, which could be the reason of delay in proper diagnosis. Interestingly, there is no gender bias in the choice of seeking treatment, which is often reported as an important indicator to address this issue [29, 30]. However, the decision-making power on treatment-seeking behaviour mainly depends on male family elders .
Although treatment expenditure is one of the important components, which influence the household choice of health service providers , information could not be collected in this study due to recall bias and lack of records during survey. Moreover, household income is recorded as one of the important determinants influencing the utilization of health services. The identification of various other indicators in this study provides useful information to understand the interlinked behavioural practices related to malaria. As early diagnosis is the main theme of prevention and control of malaria, the effective strategies to provide health services at nearest periphery of village/community and parallel health awareness programme with people participation are needed to circumvent the situation.
Dev V, Hira CR, Rajkhowa MK: Malaria-attributable morbidity in Assam, north-eastern India. Ann Trop Med Parasitol. 2001, 95: 789-796. 10.1080/00034980120111136.
Alles HK, Mendis KN, Carter R: Malaria mortality rates in south Asia and in Africa: imlication of malaria control. Parasitol Today. 1998, 14: 369-375. 10.1016/S0169-4758(98)01296-4.
Carter R, Mendis KN: Evolutionary and historical aspects of the burden of malaria. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2002, 15: 564-594. 10.1128/CMR.15.4.564-594.2002.
WHO: Malaria control today: Current WHO recommendations. 2005, RBM Department; WHO, Geneva
Mohapatra PK, Prakash A, Das HK, Mahanta J, Srivastava VK: Malaria outbreak in lower Assam: An epidemiological appraisal. J Parasitic Dis. 1995, 19: 175-178.
Mohapatra PK, Prakash A, Bhattacharyya DR, Mahanta J: Malaria situation in north-eastern region of India. ICMR Bull. 1998, 28: 21-30.
Prakash A, Mohapatra PK, Bhattacharya DR, Sharma CK, Goswami BK, Hazarika NC, Mahanta J: Epidemiology of malaria outbreak in Titabbor Primary Health Centre, district Jorhat, Assam. Indian J Med Res. 2000, 111: 121-126.
Mohapatra PK, Narain K, Prakash A, Bhattacharya DR, Mahanta J: Risk factors of malaria in the fringes of an evergreen monsoon forest of Arunachal Pradesh. Natl Med J India. 2001, 14: 139-142.
Dua VK, Dev V, Phookan S, Gupta NC, Sharma VP, Subbarao SK: Multi-Drug Resistant P. falciparum malaria in Assam, India: timing of recurrence and anti-malarial drug concentrations in whole blood. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2003, 69: 555-557.
Dev V, Phookan S, Sharma VP, Anand SP: Physiographic and entomologic risk factos of malaria in Assam, India. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2004, 71: 451-456.
Kamal S, Das SC: Epidemiological observations on malaria in some parts of Darrang District, Assam. Indian J Malariol. 2001, 38: 25-31.
Asenso-Okyere W: 'Disease and health in four selected areas of Ghana with special reference to malaria and schistosomiasis'. Health Social Sciences Research Unit Monograph Series No. 1. 1992, (Institute of Statistical, Social and Economic Research, University of Ghana, Legon)
Snedcor WG, Cochron WG: Statistical methods. 1980, IOWA State University Press, Ames, Seventh
Siegel S, Castellan J: Nonparametric statistics for the behavioral sciences. 1988, McGraw-Hill, New York
Hosmer DW, Lemeshow S: Applied logistic regression. 2000, John Wiley & Sons, New York, full_text.
Montgomery CM, Mwengee W, Kong'ong'o M, Pool R: 'To help them is to educate them': power and pedagogy in the prevention and treatment of malaria in Tanzania. Trop Med Int Health. 2006, 11: 1661-1669. 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2006.01719.x.
Malik EM, Hanafi K, Ali SH, Ahmed ES, Mohamed KA: Treatment seeking behaviour for malaria in children under five years of age: implication for home management in rural areas with high seasonal transmission in Sudan. Malar J. 2006, 5: 60-10.1186/1475-2875-5-60.
Makundi EA, Malebo HM, Mhame P, Kitua AY, Warsame M: Role of traditional healers in the management of severe malaria among children below five years of age: the case of Kilosa and Handeni districts, Tanzania. Malar J. 2006, 5: 58-10.1186/1475-2875-5-58.
Prakash A, Bhattacharyya DR, Mohapatra PK, Barua U, Phukan A, Mahanta J: Malaria control in forest camp in an oil exploration area of upper Assam. Natl Med J India. 2003, 16: 135-138.
Ndyomugyenyi R, Magnussen P, Clarke S: Malaria treatment seeking behaviour and drug prescription practices in an area of low transmission in Ugnda: implication for prevention and control. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2007, 101: 209-215. 10.1016/j.trstmh.2006.06.004.
Uzochukwu BSC, Onwujekwe OE: Socio-economic differences and health seeking behaviour for the diagnosis and treatment of malaria: a case study of four local government areas operating the Bamako initiative programme in south-east Nigeria. International Journal for Equity in Health. 2004, 3: 6-10.1186/1475-9276-3-6.
McCombie S: Treatment seeking for malaria: A review of recent research. Soc Sci Med. 1996, 43: 933-945. 10.1016/0277-9536(95)00446-7.
Ahorlu CK, Koram KA, Ahorlu C, de Savigny D, Weiss MG: Socio-cultural determinants of treatment delay for childhood malaria in southern Ghana. Trop Med Int Health. 2006, 11: 1022-1031. 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2006.01660.x.
Wallman S, Baker M: Which resources pay for treatment? A model for estimating the informal economy of health. Soc Sci Med. 1996, 42: 671-679. 10.1016/0277-9536(95)00412-2.
Morey ER, Sharma VR, Mills A: Willingness to pay and determinants of choice for improved malaria treatment in rural Nepal. Soc Sci Med. 2003, 57: 155-165. 10.1016/S0277-9536(02)00338-6.
de Bartolome CAM, Vosti SA: Choosing between public and private health care: A case study of malaria treatment in Brazil. J Health Econ. 1995, 15: 191-205. 10.1016/0167-6296(94)00045-6.
Miguel CA, Manderson L, Lansang MA: Pattern of treatment for malaria in Tayabas, The Philippines: implication of control. Trop Med Int Health. 1998, 3 (5): 431-421. 10.1046/j.1365-3156.1998.00249.x.
Diallo D, Graz B, Falquet J, Traore AK, Giani S, Mounkoro PP, Berthe A, Sacko M, Diakite C: Malaria treatment in remote areas of Mali: use of traditional medicines, patient outcome. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2006, 100: 515-520. 10.1016/j.trstmh.2005.08.003.
Tanner M, Vlassoff C: Treatment seeking behaviour for malaria: a typology based on endemicity and gender. Soc Sci Med. 1998, 46: 523-532. 10.1016/S0277-9536(97)00195-0.
Tolhurst R, Nyonator FK: Looking within the household: gender roles and responses to malaria in Ghana. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2005, 100: 321-326. 10.1016/j.trstmh.2005.05.004.
The Indian Council of Medical Research, New Delhi provided financial support for conducting the study. We are grateful to all the members of scientific advisory committee including the Chairman for their valuable suggestions and advice. Authors are also thankful to the Joint Directors, District Health Department of Golaghat and Tinsukia for providing necessary help during the survey.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
HKC contributed to the conception, preparation of project proposal and design of the study, developed the questionnaire and collected data, and contributed to the analysis, interpretation of the data and to the writing of the paper. JM contributed to the conception and preparation plan of study, developed the questionnaire and the data collection. AP contributed to the interpretation of data and to write the paper. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.