- Open Access
Malaria resurgence risk in southern Europe: climate assessment in an historically endemic area of rice fields at the Mediterranean shore of Spain
Malaria Journal volume 9, Article number: 221 (2010)
International travel and immigration have been related with an increase of imported malaria cases. This fact and climate change, prolonging the period favouring vector development, require an analysis of the malaria transmission resurgence risk in areas of southern Europe. Such a study is made for the first time in Spain. The Ebro Delta historically endemic area was selected due to its rice field landscape, the presence of only one vector, Anopheles atroparvus, with densities similar to those it presented when malaria was present, in a situation which pronouncedly differs from already assessed potential resurgence areas in other Mediterranean countries, such as France and Italy, where many different Anopheles species coexist and a different vector species dominates.
The transmission risk was assessed analysing: 1) climate diagrams including the minimum temperature for Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax development; 2) monthly evolution of the Gradient Model Risk (GMR) index, specifying transmission risk period and number of potential Plasmodium generations; 3) ecological characteristics using remote sensing images with the Eurasia Land Cover characteristics database and the monthly evolution of the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI); 4) evaluation of A. atroparvus population dynamics.
Climatological analyses and GMR index show that a transmission risk presently exists, lasting from May until September for P. falciparum, and from May until October for P. vivax. The GMR index shows that the temperature increase does not actually mean a transmission risk increase if accompanied by a precipitation decrease reducing the number of parasite generations and transmission period. Nevertheless, this limitation is offset by the artificial flooding of the rice fields. Maximum NDVI values and A. atroparvus maximum abundance correspond to months with maximum growth of the rice fields.
The Ebro Delta presents the ecological characteristics that favour transmission. The temperature increase has favoured a widening of the monthly potential transmission window with respect to when malaria was endemic. The combined application of modified climate diagrams and GMR index, together with spatial characterization conforms a useful tool for assessing potential areas at risk of malaria resurgence. NDVI is a good marker when dealing with a rice field area.
Change of climate factors and other variables related to environmental modifications included within the broad term of global change have a proven impact on the transmission of infectious diseases [1, 2], caused by different types of infectious organisms including microparasites (viruses, bacteria, rickettsia and protozoans) and also, as very recently proved, metazoan macroparasites (helminths) [3–5], among which mainly vector-borne diseases [6–9], such as malaria [10–13]. Prediction studies indicate that the incidence of infectious diseases is likely to increase as a consequence of climate change and, in the case of malaria, it has been calculated that 50 million new cases will occur by 2100 . Global warming has been considered as a potential risk for malaria resurgence in northern hemisphere areas [12, 15].
Southern Europe is among the most risky regions for malaria resurgence due to (i) the appropriate latitudes with benign climate such as mainly those under mildering influences of the Mediterranean sea, (ii) the closeness to Africa enabling an uncontrolled entry of immigrants from sub-Saharan Africa by means of boats, whether directly through the Mediterranean or indirectly through the Pacific into first the Canary Islands and afterwards the Iberian Peninsula, (iii) the wide presence of anopheline vectors which played an important transmission role during the first half of last century, (iv) the pronounced antropogenic modifications of the environment related to modern development, industry and construction growing giving rise to settlement concentrations consequence of increasing population and tourism which attract a high number of poor immigrants coming from endemic countries and looking for jobs created within the construction and services sectors, and (v) the high immigration rates occurred in recent years mainly from poor endemic areas of developing countries of other continents. All this applies to Spain, where the increase of international travel and immigration from presently malaria-endemic countries has been an exponential phenomenon and global warming has become very evident in the last two decades. In this country, as well as in the neighbouring Portugal, Anopheles atroparvus was the most efficient vector [16, 17]. At present, this anopheline species shows high population densities similar to those observed in old times when there still were authochthonous transmission areas [18, 19]. These facts call for the need to carry out studies on the present potential transmission risk of malaria in areas of Spain, which were historically endemic to assess resurgence probabilities.
In Spain, benign tertian fever caused by Plasmodium vivax and, to a lesser degree, malign tertian fever caused by Plasmodium falciparum and that of quartan periodicity caused by Plasmodium malariae, were endemic until mid last century. In 1943, around 400,000 cases were diagnosed and 1,307 deaths due to malaria were registered. The last autochthonous case was registered in May 1961, and Spain was declared a malaria-free country since it received the official certificate of eradication in 1964 . However, imported cases, mainly stemming from immigrants and tourists, are yearly reported. The surge in travel to exotic countries where malaria is present as well as the increased rate of immigration from endemic countries have led to a steady increase in imported malaria cases from 21 in 1967 to 263 in 1995 and 351 in 2004 [21, 22]. Thus, the possibility that Spanish Anopheles could facilitate the re-introduction of Plasmodium into the country carried by immigrants or travellers who did not follow the appropriate prophylactic measures, has to be taken into account, depending on the receptivity towards its various strains. Currently, new studies are being carried out on the receptivity of the European vector A. atroparvus towards African Plasmodium strains. Previous studies already revealed that it is not susceptible to the afro-tropical P. falciparum strains [6, 18, 23–26], but susceptible to the European strains [6, 27, 28], although probably fully susceptible to infection by P. vivax strains imported from Africa . In addition, Asian or American P. falciparum strains may also be imported . Hence, a transmission resurgence risk, as reflected by the detection of possible autochthonous cases in south European countries as Spain , Greece [30, 31], Italy [32–34] and France [35, 36], and even more northward as in Germany , should be taken into account. These facts make it necessary to carry out studies to analyse the present situation and to assess whether the ecological, entomological and social characteristics of the historically endemic areas in Spain allow for the transmission of the disease nowadays. Studies with similar objectives have very recently been carried out in other European countries such as Italy [33, 38], France [39–43], Portugal  and Germany .
A field analysis of potential risk factors of malaria transmission resurgence has so far never been made in Spain. A historically endemic area as the Ebro Delta, at the Mediterranean shore (Figure 1), appears to be the best way for such a study. Malaria in the Ebro Delta was first reported in Tortosa in 1738 and between 1800 and 1900 the disease was included among the priority treatment campaigns prescribed by local physicians . The problem of malaria in the area began to worsen from 1860 onwards after the introduction of rice cultivation . The rapid expansion of this crop together with the bad planning of drainage systems, the precarious conditions of day labourers and deficient hygienic conditions caused an increase of the disease and turned it into a serious health and socioeconomic problem, as a consequence of the decrease of day labourers and the costs incurred by treatments and anti-malaria campaigns. Old data showed that 26,557 out of 70,540 inhabitants of the Ebro Delta were exposed to a paludic environment and that the number of infected people rose from 6,207 in 1912 to 12,545 in 1915, reaching an outstanding 95% in some municipalities of the area . Plasmodium falciparum and P. vivax were the causes of two thirds of all cases . There has been no indication of malaria transmission since its eradication. Thus, the Ebro Delta presents nowadays a situation of anophelism without malaria, with A. atroparvus as the only anopheline species present . This feature shall be highlighted when compared to old malaria endemic areas and presently potential resurgence areas in other Mediterranean countries as France and Italy, where many different Anopheles species coexist in the same area and a different vector species dominate, as Anopheles hyrcanus in France [39, 40] and Anopheles labranchiae in Italy [33, 34, 38]. Anopheles atroparvus is an halophilous species following seasonal population dynamics nearly throughout Europe. Changes in climatic conditions, including temperature, evapotranspiration and surface runoff, all key factors to determining mosquito abundance and survivorship , may increase the favourable period for the development of the vector and the transmission of the disease.
With the aim to assess whether the present ecological characteristics of the Ebro Delta permit malaria transmission nowadays, the A. atroparvus population has been monitored and climatic as well as terrain conditions have been characterized to determine if this parasite/vector association could satisfactorily complete its biological cycle. This assessment has been carried out by means of a climatic analysis and applying the Gradient Model Risk Index based on climatic conditions favouring the development of the parasite and vector [49, 50]. For terrain analysis, satellite imagery, known to furnish valuable data for the forecast of malaria , has been used by means of remote sensing information selected to characterize the overall land cover of rice fields of the Ebro Delta as data from the Eurasian Land Cover database , and the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) which has been proved to be highly efficient for prediction studies in water-related parasitic diseases .
The Ebro Delta is a Mediterranean ecosystem, situated in the province of Tarragona, Spain, covering 24,000 ha (Figure 1), of which 8,000 ha form a Natural Park. The delta plain, at sea level, is divided by the Ebro river into two hemideltas. The left part includes the municipality of Deltebre, Baix Ebre zone, and the right hemidelta includes the municipalities of Amposta, Sant Jaume d'Enveja and Sant Carles de la Rapita, Montsia zone.
Since the construction of the irrigation canals, on the right hemidelta in 1860 and on the left in 1912, rice cultivation has taken up a great part of the delta plain, currently around 65%. The dominance of this crop, characterized by extensive water networks throughout the entire delta, constitutes a favourable environment for various culicid species, including A. atroparvus.
The climatic features of the Ebro Delta have been analysed to determine whether they permit the transmission of Plasmodium. This characterization was carried out based on climate data corresponding to a 26-year-period (1961-1986), obtained from the weather station situated in Tortosa, belonging to FAO. The following climate data were analysed (Table 1): mean maximum temperature (MMT), mean minimum temperature (MmT), mean environmental temperature (MET), all in °C, precipitation in mm (Pt), relative humidity in % (RH), potential evapotranspiration in mm (PET), wind speed in m/s (WM), vapor pressure in hPa (VP), and global radiation in W/m2 (GR).
A climate diagram for the area has been created, based on proposed models  and according to methods used previously , with emphasis on the duration and periodicity of humid and dry intervals along the study period. Also, climate diagrams for the two study years of 2005 and 2006 have been created to determine possible variations in duration and periodicity of humid and dry periods caused by the increasing temperatures of recent years. Precipitation data (mm) and mean environmental temperature (°C), used when creating the aforementioned climate diagrams, were obtained from the weather station of the Servei Meteorologic de Catalunya, located in Amposta.
Terrain characterization by remote sensing data
The unchangeable patterns of rice sowing and harvesting along the last decades and the crop's predominance in the Ebro Delta justify the use of satellite images (although not exactly corresponding to the two-year field study period) for an appropriate characterization of this area, thus determining whether its features allow for the completion of the vector cycle.
To study related remote sensing data, a total of 72 10-day (dekad) composite images from the Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) sensor on board the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) environmental satellite, have been analysed. This dataset archive comprises the period April 1992 to March 1993 and February 1995 to January 1996 and was downloaded from the Global Land 1-km project Internet site. Particularly, the monthly evolution of corresponding NDVI values has been obtained to show the general response of vegetation to water availability (rainfall) and in this case of rice growing to man-made irrigation. This index produces values in the range of -1.0 to 1.0, where increasing positive values indicate increasing green vegetation and lower values indicate non-vegetated surface features such as water, barren areas, ice and snow or clouds .
Also, the Eurasia Land Cover characteristics database using 1-km AVHRR data covering the period from April 1992 to March 1993  has been analysed to determine the majority classes of each of the classifications included in this database.
All images were geo-referenced and processed using Erdas Imagine 8.3.1 software. ArcView GIS 3.2a software and its Spatial Analyst application were used to obtain values corresponding to surfaces occupied by each class of NDVI and Land Cover for each of the three polygons created, namely the entire Ebro Delta, the left hemidelta (Baix Ebre zone) and the right hemidelta (Montsia zone). Of the obtained values, those related to the majority value in the case of Land Cover and to the average in the case of NDVI have been considered.
The entomological study has been performed from May to October 2005 by means of bimonthly surveys. Adult and larval stages of the various mosquito species were captured using CDC-light traps, following the methodology detailed in other recent studies [34, 40] and installed at four sites on either side of the Ebro Delta: two in the Baix Ebre zone, one on a pig and poultry farm, one situated in a human dwelling in the town centre of Deltebre; two in the Montsia zone, one on a pig farm and one in a human dwelling situated in the centre of the town of Poble Nou (Figure 2). To obtain larval stages eight rice fields were chosen, four in the Baix Ebre zone and four in the Montsia zone, where non-permanent water spots were surveyed at random. Five samples were taken at different spots along the margins of each rice field surveyed. Collected specimens were classified at species level by means of their morphological characteristics and descriptions of local populations and keys [56, 57]. In the case of larval stages, differentiation was carried out considering 1-2 larvae, 3-4 larvae, nymphs and eggs. Species and strain belonging was previously verified by sequencing of selected markers of the nuclear ribosomal DNA by the dideoxy chain-termination method [16, 58]. Present population dynamics of A. atroparvus encountered in the study area was analysed by means of this entomological study.
The potential malaria transmission risk in the Ebro Delta was analysed by means of:
including the minimum temperature required for the development of Plasmodium species in the aforementioned climate diagrams to analyse which months present favourable conditions for the development of the parasite;
calculating the Gradient Model Risk Index (GMR index) applied to forecast the malaria transmission risk [49, 50], i.e. the monthly evolution of accumulated values of the index was analysed to gain insight into possible transmission periods along the year; this index considers only climatic parameters as the minimum mean temperature required for the development of the parasite inside the vector, precipitation (mm) and PET (mm) per month, calculated by the equation:
where GDD is growing degree-days, R is rainfall, and PET is potential evapotranspiration.
The GMR index shows that a transmission risk exists when its value equals 116, the value required for one Plasmodium generation, or is higher. Minimum temperatures required for the development of Plasmodium species are: 15°C for P. vivax and 18°C for P. falciparum[7, 15, 59–61].
The following data shall be emphasized among the results from the climatic analysis of the study area: mean annual temperature of 16.9°C (9.2°C in January and 25.0°C in August); mean annual maximum temperature of 21.7°C (13.5°C in January and 30.2°C in July); mean annual minimum temperature of 12.0°C (4.8°C in January and 19.9°C in August). Accumulated precipitation along the year does not exceed 565 mm. September (84 mm) and October (72 mm) are the rainiest months of the year. Maximum values of potential evaporation are reached in April and September, reaching its peak in July (182 mm) and relative humidity is around 60% in all months of the year, bar April. The wet period is situated between September and June according to the climate diagram created for 26 consecutive years (Figure 3). The dry period lasts from July until August. The climate diagrams corresponding to 2005 and 2006 (Figures 4 and 5) show, when compared to the 1961-1986 period, an increase of the duration of the dry period, which in either year began in March and lasted until August 2005 and September 2006, respectively. The wet period of the two study years is divided into two parts: February and from September until December in 2005; and from January to February and from October until November in 2006.
Terrain characterization by remote sensing data
When analysing the terrain features of the Ebro Delta by means of Eurasia Land Cover, it can be seen that irrigation farming, especially rice cultivation, is predominant (Table 2). NDVI values show a progressive increase from May in the two annual periods analyzed, reaching the maximum NDVI value in July (0.6 in the annual period comprising April 1992 to March 1993; 0.7 in the annual period comprising February 1995 to January 1996), reaching their maximum values in the May-October period (Fig. 6 and 7). These results are similar in the three zones considered, namely the entire Delta, the left hemidelta and the right hemidelta.
Since the beginning of the study in May 2005, a total of 16,130 adult mosquitoes were captured, including 9,978 A. atroparvus (61.86%) and 6,152 culicine species (38.14%) belonging to Culex pipiens, Culex modestus, Ochlerotatus caspius and Culiseta longiareolata. Anopheles atroparvus was detected along the entire study period (May-October). The follow-up of the total number of anophelines captured allowed for the detection of its maximum density in the period from June until August, its decrease in September and a considerable increase in October (Figure 8). The detection of a male A. atroparvus specimens during the first survey on 11th May on a pig farm in Poble Nou (Montsia zone) is particularly noteworthy, especially since larval stages neither of anopheline nor of culicine had been detected before in the surrounding rice fields or in any other parts of the Delta.
Concerning larval stages, of the total of 661 culicid larvae collected, 647 (97.88%) of which were C. pipiens and C. modestus, and only 14 (2.12%) A. atroparvus. The larval stage of A. atroparvus was only sporadically detected, which made it impossible to carry out a larval stage population study of this species. Anopheles atroparvus larvae were first detected during the July rice field survey. However, breading sites were first detected in localities situated away from the rice fields, in the irrigation system belonging to the previously mentioned pig farm and in a puddle.
The results obtained from the climate diagrams and the calculation of the GMR index indicate that a potential malaria transmission risk in the Ebro Delta does indeed exist. The climate diagram concerning the 26-year period (Figure 3) shows that the minimum temperature required for the development of the two Plasmodium species is situated between May and September for P. falciparum, and between April and October for P. vivax. In 2005, the favourable transmission period for the two Plasmodium species considered was between May and October (Figure 4). Only one year later (2006) this period extended from April to November for P. vivax and was the same as in the previous year, namely May to October for P. falciparum (Figure 5).
The monthly evolution of the GMR index concerning the 26-year period places the potential transmission risk in June, September and October for P. vivax (Figure 9), thus allowing for four potential generations, and in September for P. falciparum (Figure 10), allowing for two potential generations.
The aforementioned index for 2005 places the potential transmission risk in September and October for P. vivax (Figure 11), thus making the development of four potential generations possible, and in September for P. falciparum (Figure 12) allowing for one generation. In 2006 the monthly evolution of the GMR index places the potential transmission risk for P. vivax (Figure 13) between October and November. The index, however, does not show any transmission risk for P. falciparum (Figure 14) along 2006.
The analysis of the various classifications of the Land Cover database shows that in the Ebro Delta irrigation farming, namely rice, predominates, which is shown at the end of April and the beginning of May and reaches its maximum growth in July and August, respectively. Monthly NDVI values reach their maximums in July and August coinciding with the dry period in the Ebro Delta, reflecting the growth of rice characterized by irrigation through artificial flooding. Thus, the rice fields in the Delta provide an ideal environment for the development and breeding of A. atroparvus owing to the existence of great masses of clean, motionless water, as already noted long ago [62, 63]. Rice cultivation periods, moreover, coincide with temperatures permitting the completion of the vector cycle, as shown by the detection of A. atroparvus during all the months studied. Mosquito maximum abundance in June, July and August also coincides with NDVI maximum values as well as with maximum growth in the rice fields. The importance of cultures of this kind of crop in the development of malaria vectors has already been noted in other south European countries [33, 38, 42, 64, 65].
A potential malaria transmission risk in the Ebro Delta is revealed when considering the climate data and the characterization of the study area along the 26-year period analysed. The climate diagram indicates that favourable temperature conditions can be found between May and September for A. atroparvus and P. falciparum, and such a favourable period extends from April until October for P. vivax. The results of the GMR index place the transmission risk solely in June, September and October for P. vivax and in September for P. falciparum. The calculation of this index makes it possible to define the period of potential transmission risk, considering climatic factors only, but in a much more precise manner, taking also into account the minimum temperature required for parasite and vector development as well as the presence of rain water needed for the completion of the A. atroparvus life cycle. Nonetheless, the insufficiency of water needed for vector development in the Ebro Delta, typical for the dry period between June and August, is compensated by the artificial flooding of the rice fields. Therefore, the transmission risk period should be extended to May and September for P. falciparum and to May and October for P. vivax.
Relative humidity is another essential factor in malaria transmission. Although Plasmodium parasites are not affected by relative humidity, anopheline mosquito activity and survival are. If the average monthly relative humidity is below 60%, it is believed that the lifespan of the mosquito is shortened to such an extent that malaria transmission does not occur . The climatic analysis of the study area shows that relative humidity is above 60% along the entire year, bar April. Thus, suitable conditions for the development of A. atroparvus and Plasmodium turn the Ebro Delta into an ecosystem with favourable climatic characteristics for malaria transmission.
The results obtained agree with old observations , which noted that 99% of all new malaria cases in the Delta were detected at the end of summer, that the first cases tended to appear in July, and that epidemics occurred in August, particularly during the last three weeks of that month with the detection of numerous cases. Our results reveal that the favourable transmission period is currently longer than it was, starting two months before, in May, and lasting until September in the case of P. falciparum and until October in case of P. vivax, respectively. The discovery of larvae in a different place from a rice field (the typical breeding site of A. atroparvus in the Ebro Delta) and the discovery of males in May (up until then no larval stages of Anophelinae and Culicinae had been detected in the rice-fields of the Delta) support the prolongation of the malaria transmission risk until October, although the rice cultivation period is completed by then.
Climate data for 2005 and 2006 show that although an increase of temperatures took place, favouring an extension of the transmission period, at the same time a decrease in precipitation occurs, resulting in an extension of the dry period, which in turn would a priori negatively affect the favourable period for vector development if artificial irrigation water would not be available. Population dynamics of A. atroparvus populations in the Ebro Delta follow a typical thermophilic trend where rice fields ensure a constant presence of water. The highest values were recorded in the period from June until August, when the abundance of the population peaked. Lowest values were recorded in September, but a new peak appeared in October-November. This seasonal dynamics is quite similar to those presented by A. labranchiae in Italy  and A. hyrcanus in France , both assessed during the same biannual period (2005-2006).
Transmission risk analysis for 2005 indicates that conditions for vector development of the two Plasmodium species considered are still suitable in the May-September period for P. falciparum and in May-October for P. vivax. Although the GMR index shows, in the case of P. vivax, a disappearance of the transmission risk in June, it has to be kept in mind that the rice field irrigation counteracts the lack of rain water in that month and consequently the transmission risk persists.
Climate data analysis for 2006 confirms that the increase in temperatures prolongs the favourable period for both vector and P. vivax development, lasting from May until November. Although the climate diagram shows that the risk period starts in April (favourable temperatures), results derived from the GMR index and the fact that rice is not grown in that month, suitable conditions for the completion of the Anopheles life cycle do not exist, and therefore April can not be considered within the potential risk period. However, the GMR index did not indicate a P. falciparum transmission risk in 2006 as a consequence of reduced precipitation in that year. Thus, P. falciparum sees its favourable period limited to May until September, when the rice field irrigation counteracts the lack of rain water required for the completion of the Anopheles life cycle, and temperatures, following the climate diagram, facilitate parasite and vector development.
The evolution of the GMR index shows that the increase in temperatures does not actually mean an increase in the malaria transmission risk if this is accompanied by a decrease in precipitations. Although temperatures favour parasite development, the lack of water prevents vector development. This fact reduces the number of parasite generations as well as the transmission period. Nevertheless, this limitation is offset by the artificial flooding of the rice fields in the Delta. Therefore, the use of this index, which solely considers the existence of breeding sites and periods as a consequence of precipitation, has to be combined with a spatial characterization of the study area, which helps to detect breeding sites and periods. NDVI from remote sensing sources proves to be a good marker for such a purpose when dealing with a rice field area.
The results obtained make it possible to conclude that the Ebro Delta currently presents ecologically favourable characteristics for the re-appearance of malaria if an appropriate malaria strain would be introduced and that the month window period for potential transmission has even widened due to present global warming impact when compared to last century when this area was endemic. This fact makes it necessary to verify whether the Plasmodium strains potentially introducible by infected immigrants, tourists or travellers arriving to Spain could be compatible with the European A. atroparvus. Additionally, factors that might influence vector population dynamics as well as the transmission of Plasmodium (blood preferences of the vector, aggressiveness, gonotrophic cycle, etc.) have, therefore, to be analysed in the Ebro Delta area in question.
Epstein P: Climate Change and Infectious Disease; Stormy Weather Ahead. Epidemiology. 2002, 13: 373-375. 10.1097/00001648-200207000-00001.
Costello A, Abbas M, Allen A, Ball S, Bell S, Bellamy R, Friel S, Groce N, Johnson A, Kett M, Lee M, Levy C, Maslin M, McCoy D, McGuire B, Montgomery H, Napier D, Pagel C, Patel J, Puppim de la Olivera JA, Redclift N, Rees H, Rogger D, Scott J, Stephenson J, Twigg J, Wolff J, Patterson C: Managing the health effects of climate change. Lancet. 2009, 373: 1693-1733. 10.1016/S0140-6736(09)60935-1.
Mas-Coma S, Valero MA, Bargues MD: Effects of climate change on animal and zoonotic helminthiases. Rev Sci Tech Off Int Epiz. 2008, 27: 443-452.
Mas-Coma S, Valero MA, Bargues MD: Climate change effects on trematodiases, with emphasis on zoonotic fascioliasis and schistosomiasis. Vet Parasitol. 2009, 163: 264-280. 10.1016/j.vetpar.2009.03.024.
Mas-Coma S, Valero MA, Bargues MD: Climate change effects on trematode and nematode diseases affecting children in rural areas of developing countries. Climate Change and Rural Child Health, Int Publ Health J. Edited by: Bell E. 2010, New York: Nova Science Publishers,
Githeko AK, Lindsays SW, Confalonieri UE, Patz JA: Climate change and vector-borne diseases: a regional analysis. Bull World Health Organ. 2001, 78: 1136-1147.
Gubler DJ, Reiter P, Ebi KL, Yap W. Nasci R, Patz JA: Climate variability and change in the United States: potential impacts on vector and rodent-borne diseases. Environ Health Persp. 2001, 109: 223-233. 10.2307/3435012.
IPCC: Climate Change 2007: Synthesis Report. Contribution of Working Groups I, II and III to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Edited by: Core Writing Team, Pachauri RK, Reisinger A. 2007, Switzerland: IPCC, Geneva
Rogers DJ, Randolph SE: Climate change and vector-borne diseases. Global Mapping and Infectious Diseases. Methods, Examples and Emerging Applications. Edited by: Hay SI, Graham AJ, Rogers DE. 2007, London: Elsevier-Academic Press, 345-381.
Snow K: Malaria and mosquitoes in Britain: the effect of global climate change. Europ Mosq Bull. 1999, 4: 17-25.
Rogers DJ, Randolph SE: The global spread of malaria in a future, warmer world. Science. 2000, 289: 1763-1766. 10.1126/science.289.5478.391b.
Patz JA, Hulme M, Rosenzweig C, Mitchell TD, Goldberg RA, Githeko AK, Lele S, McMichael AJ, Le Sueur D: Regional warming and malaria resurgence. Nature. 2002, 420: 627-628. 10.1038/420627a.
Hay SI, Guerra CA, Tatem AJ, Noor AM, Snow RW: The global distribution and population at risk of malaria: past, present, and future. Lancet Infect Dis. 2004, 4: 327-336. 10.1016/S1473-3099(04)01043-6.
McMichel AJ, Woodruff RE, Simon H: Climate change and human health: present and future risks. Lancet. 2006, 367: 859-869. 10.1016/S0140-6736(06)68079-3.
Lindsay SW, Thomas CJ: Global warming and risk of vivax malaria in Great Britain. Global Change Hum Health. 2001, 2: 80-84. 10.1023/A:1011995115713.
Bargues MD, Latorre JM, Morchon R, Simón F, Escosa R, Aranda C, Sainz S, Fuentes MV, Mas-Coma S: rDNA sequences of Anopheles species from the Iberian Peninsula and an evaluation of the 18 S rDNA gene as phylogenetic marker in Anophelinae. J Med Entomol. 2006, 43: 508-517. 10.1603/0022-2585(2006)43[508:RSOASF]2.0.CO;2.
Capinha C, Gomes E, Reis E, Rocha J, Sousa CA, Do Rosario VE, Almeida AP: Present habitat suitability for Anopheles atroparvus (Diptera, Culicidae) and its coincidence with former malaria areas in mainland Portugal. Geospat Health. 2009, 3: 177-187.
Blazquez J: Entomologic investigation on anophelism in the Ebro River delta. Rev San Hig Publ. 1974, 48: 363-377.
Eritja R, Aranda C, Padrós J, Goula M, Lucientes J, Escosa R, Marqués E, Cáceres F: An annotated checklist and bibliography of the mosquito of Spain (Diptera: Culicidae). Europ Mosq Bull. 2000, 8: 10-18.
Pletch D: Informe sobre una misión efectuada en España en septiembre-noviembre de 1963 destinada a la certificación de la erradicación del paludismo. Rev San Hig Publ. 1965, 39: 309-367.
Camacho AT, Pallas E, Segura A, Guitián FJ, Olmeda S: Paludismo importado. Rev Diag Biol. 2001, 50: 149-150.
CISID: Centralized Information System for Infectious Diseases (CISID). 2006, World Health Organization Office for Europe, [http://data.euro.who.int/cisid/]
James S: Some general results of a study of induced malaria in England. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1931, 24: 477-525. 10.1016/S0035-9203(31)90068-0.
Shute PG: Failure to infect English specimens of Anopheles maculipennis var. atroparvus with certain strains of Plasmodium falciparum tropical origin. J Trop Med Hyg. 1940, 43: 175-178.
Zulueta J, Ramsdale CD, Coluzzi M: Receptivity to malaria in Europe. Bull World Health Organ. 1975, 52: 109-111.
Ribeiro H, Batista JL, Ramos HC, Pires CA, Champalimaud JL, Costa JM, Araújo C, Mansinho K, Pina MC: An attempt to infect Anopheles atroparvus from Portugal with African Plasmodium falciparum. Rev Port Doen Infec. 1989, 12: 81-82.
Shute PG: Malaria in England. Publ Health. 1945, 58: 62-65. 10.1016/S0033-3506(44)80258-X.
Ramsdale CD, Coluzzi M: Studies on the infectivity of tropical African strains of Plasmodium falciparum to some southern European vectors of malaria. Parassitologia. 1975, 17: 39-48.
Cuadros J, Calvente MJ, Benito A, Arevalo J, Calero MA, Segura J, Rubio JM: Plasmodium ovale malaria acquired in central Spain. Emerg Infect Dis. 2002, 8: 1506-1508.
Kampen H, Maltezos E, Pagonaki M, Hunfeld KP, Maier WA, Seitz HM: Individual cases of authochthonous malaria in Evros Province, northern Greece serological aspects. Parasitol Res. 2002, 88: 261-266. 10.1007/s00436-001-0530-2.
Kampen H, Maltezos E, Pagonaki M, Hunfeld KP, Maier WA, Seitz HM: Individual cases of authochthonous malaria in Evros Province, northern Greece entomological aspects. Parasitol Res. 2002, 89: 252-258.
Baldari M, Tamburro A, Sabatinelli G, Romi R, Severini C, Cuccagna P, Fiorilli G, Allegri MP, Buriani C, Toti M: Introduced malaria in Maremma, Italy, decades after eradication. Lancet. 1998, 351: 1248-1249. 10.1016/S0140-6736(97)10312-9.
Romi R, Sabatinelli G, Majori G: Could malaria reappear in Italy?. Emerg Infect Dis. 2001, 7: 915-919. 10.3201/eid0706.010601.
Di Luca M, Boccolini D, Severini F, Toma L, Mancini Barbieri F, Massa A, Romi R: A 2-year entomological study of potential malaria vectors in Central Italy. Vector-Borne Zoonotic Dis. 2009, 9: 703-711. 10.1089/vbz.2008.0129.
Doudier B, Bogreau H, Devries A, Ponçon N, Stauffer WM, Fontenille D: Possible autochthonous malaria from Marseille to Minneapolis. Emerg Infect Dis. 2007, 13: 1236-1238.
Pomares-Estran C, Delauna P, Mottard A, Cua E, Roger PM, Pradines B, Parzy D, Bogreau H, Rogier C, Jeannin C, Karch S, Fontenille D, Dejour-Salamanca D, Legros F, Marty P: Atypical aetiology of a conjugal fever: autochthonous airport malaria between Paris and French Riviera: a case report malaria between Paris and French Riviera: a case report. Malar J. 2009, 8: 202-10.1186/1475-2875-8-202.
Krüger A, Rech A, Su XZ, Tannich E: Two cases of autochthonous Plasmodium falciparum malaria in Germany with evidence for local transmission by indigenous Anopheles plumbeus. Trop Med Int Health. 2001, 6: 983-985. 10.1046/j.1365-3156.2001.00816.x.
Romi R, Pierdominici G, Severini C, Tamburro A, Cocchi M, Pili E, Marchi A: Status of malaria vectors in Italy. J Med Entomol. 1997, 34: 263-271.
Ponçon N, Balenghien T, Toty C, Ferré JB, Thomas C, Dervieux A, L'Ambert G, Schaffner F, Bardin O, Fontenille D: Effects of local anthropogenic changes on potential malaria vector Anopheles hyrcanus and West Nile virus vector Culex modestus, Camargue, France. Emerg Infect Dis. 2007, 13: 1810-1815.
Ponçon N, Toty C, L'Ambert G, Le Golf G, Brengues C, Schaffner F, Fontenille D: Biology and dynamics of potential malaria vectors in Southern France. Malar J. 2007, 6: 18-10.1186/1475-2875-6-18.
Ponçon N, Tran A, Toty C, Luty A, Fontenille D: A quantitative risk assessment approach for mosquito borne diseases: malaria re-emergence in South East France. Malar J. 2008, 7: 147-10.1186/1475-2875-7-147.
Tran A, Ponçon N, Toty C, Linard C, Guis H, Ferré JB, Lo Seen D, Roger F, De La Rocque S, Fontenille D, Thierry Baldet T: Using remote sensing to map larval and adult populations of Anopheles hyrcanus (Diptera: Culicidae) a potential malaria vector in Southern France. Int J Health Geogr. 2008, 7: 9-10.1186/1476-072X-7-9.
Linard C, Ponçon N, Fontenille D, Lambin EF: A multi-agent simulation to assess the risk of malaria re-emergence in southern France. Ecol Model. 2009, 220: 160-174. 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2008.09.001.
Schröder W, Schmidt G: Spatial modelling of the potential temperature-dependent transmission of vector-associated diseases in the face of climate change: main results and recommendations from a pilot study in Lower Saxony (Germany). Parasitol Res. 2008, 103: S55-S63. 10.1007/s00436-008-1051-z.
Mañá J: El Dr. D. Manuel Vilá Olesa y el saneamiento del Delta. La Zuda. 1964, 1040-1055.
Cartaña P, Canicio I, Fábrega J: Resumen de la campaña antipalúdica realizada en el Delta del Ebro desde el año 1925 al 1932, ambos inclusive. Rev San Hig Publ. 1933, 8: 113-165.
Mancomunitat de Catalunya: Treballs del servei de sanitat 1917 a 1921. El Paludisme. Estat Actual del Paludismo a la Vall de L'Ebre. 1922, Barcelona: Publicacions de l'Institut de Ciències
Foley JA, Defries R, Asner GP, Barford C, Bonan G, Carpenter SR, Chapin FS, Coe MT, Daily GC, Gibbs HK, Helkowski JH, Holloway T, Howard EA, Kucharik CJ, Monfreda C, Patz JA, Prentice IC, Ramankutty N, Snyder PK: Global consequences of land use. Science. 2005, 309: 570-574. 10.1126/science.1111772.
Malone JB, Poggi E, Igualada FJ, Sintasath D, Ghebremeskel T, Corbett JD, McCarroll JC, Chinnici P, Shililu J, McNally K, Downer R, Perich M, Ford R: Malaria environmental risk assessment in Eritrea. Proceedings International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium (IGARRS). 2003, 1000-1003.
Malone JB: Biology-based mapping of vector-born parasites by Geographic Information Systems and Remote Sensing. Parassitologia. 2005, 47: 27-50.
Rogers DJ, Randolph SE, Snow RW, Hay SI: Satellite imagery in the study and forecast of malaria. Nature. 2002, 415: 710-715. 10.1038/415710a.
Loveland TR, Zhu Z, Ohlen DO, Brown JF, Reed BC, Yang L: An analysis of the IGBP Global Land-Cover Characterization Process. Photogram Eng Rem Sens. 1999, 65: 1021-1032.
Fuentes MV, Malone JB, Mas-Coma S: Validation of a mapping and predicting model for human fasciolosis transmission in Andean very high altitude endemic areas using remote sensing data. Acta Trop. 2001, 79: 87-95. 10.1016/S0001-706X(01)00106-1.
Walter H, Harnickel E, Mueller-Dombois D: Climate-diagram maps of the individual contintents and the ecological climatic regions of the Earth: supplement to the vegetation monographs. 1975, Berlin: Springer-Verlag
Fuentes MV, Valero MA, Bargues MD, Esteban JG, Angles R, Mas-Coma S: Analysis of climatic data and forecast indices for human fascioliasis at very high altitude. Ann Trop Med Parasitol. 1999, 93: 835-850. 10.1080/00034989957844.
Encinas A: Taxonomía y biología de los mosquitos del área salmantina (Díptera: Culicidae). PhD thesis. 1982, Universidad de Salamanca, Centro de Edafología y Biología Aplicada
Schaffner F, Angel G, Geoffroy B, Hervy JP, Rhaiem A, Brunhes J: Les moustiques d'Europe. 2001, Logiciel d'identification et d'enseignement. CD-ROM, Institut de Recherche pour le Développement (IRD). Paris: Editions & EID Méditerranée
Bargues MD, Morchon R, Latorre JM, Cancrini G, Mas-Coma S, Simón F: Ribosomal DNA second internal transcribed spacer sequence studies of culicid vectors from an endemic area of Dirofilaria immitis of Spain. Parasitol Res. 2006, 99: 205-213. 10.1007/s00436-005-0107-6.
Mollineaux L: Epidemiology relevant to distribution and control. Malaria: Principles and Practice of Malariology. Edited by: Wernsdorfer W, McGregor I. 1988, Edinburgh: Churchill, Livingstone, 913-999.
Duncan J: The possible influence of climate on historical outbreaks of malaria in Scotland. Proceedings of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh. 1993, 23: 55-62.
Patz JA, Olson SH: Malaria risk and temperature: Influences from global climate change and local land use practices. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA. 2006, 103: 5635-5636. 10.1073/pnas.0601493103.
Gil Collado J: I Lista de algunos culícidos de España. Bol Real Soc Esp Hist Nat. 1926, 26: 345-349.
Pittaluga G, Perepérez Gutierrez L, Bote Zozaya C, Caratañá P, Gil Collado J: Le paludisme dans les "deltas". (Etudes sur certaines conditions naturelles et experimentales de l'anophelisme dans le delta de l'Ebre, 1926-1930). Arch Roum Pathol Expér Microbiol. 1932, 5: 1-131.
Kaiser A, Jerrentrup H, Samanidou Voyadjoglou A, Becker N: Contribution to the distribution of European mosquitoes (Diptera: Culicidae): four new country records from northern Greece. Europ Mosq Bull. 2001, 10: 9-12.
Faraj C, Ouahbi S, Adlaoui E, Boccolini D, Romi R, El Aouad R: Risque de réémergence du paludisme au Maroc. Étude de la capacité vectorielle d'Anopheles labranchiae dans une zone rizicole au nord du pays. Parasite. 2008, 15: 605-610.
Pampana E: A Textbook of Malaria Eradication. 1969, London: Oxford University Press
Study supported by Projects Nos. GOCE-2003-010284 (EDEN, European Commission, Brussels), Red de Investigación Colaborativa en Enfermedades Tropicales RICET (RD06/0021/0017 of the RETICS Programme), FIS, Spanish Ministry of Health, Madrid, and GVACOMP2007-294 (Generalitat Valenciana), Valencia, Spain. This paper is catalogued by the EDEN Steering Committee as EDEN No. 215 http://www.eden-fp6project.net/.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
SSE and JML gathered and analyzed the data. SSE carried out the spatial analysis. RE and MM contributed in the field study design and analysis. MV participated in the forecast-index analysis. SMC and MDB devised, designed and coordinated the study, and wrote the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Authors’ original submitted files for images
Below are the links to the authors’ original submitted files for images.
About this article
Cite this article
Sainz-Elipe, S., Latorre, J.M., Escosa, R. et al. Malaria resurgence risk in southern Europe: climate assessment in an historically endemic area of rice fields at the Mediterranean shore of Spain. Malar J 9, 221 (2010). https://doi.org/10.1186/1475-2875-9-221
- Normalize Difference Vegetation Index
- Malaria Transmission
- Rice Field
- Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer