Open Access

In vivo study of Plasmodium falciparum chloroquine susceptibility in three departments of Haiti

Malaria Journal201716:313

https://doi.org/10.1186/s12936-017-1961-2

Received: 9 February 2017

Accepted: 28 July 2017

Published: 4 August 2017

Abstract

Background

Malaria is considered a public health priority in Haiti, with a goal to eliminate by year 2020. Chloroquine is the first-line treatment recommended by the Ministry of Public Health and Population. In order to verify the suitability of chloroquine for uncomplicated malaria treatment, an in vivo study of susceptibility of Plasmodium falciparum to chloroquine was conducted from January 2013 to March 2015 in six localities in the south of Haiti.

Results

Sixty-one patients who presented with confirmed P. falciparum malaria were included in the study and followed until day 28 after having taken 25 mg/kg of chloroquine orally over 3 days. The sample included 28 children under the age of 10, 9 adolescents aged 10–19 years, and 24 adults aged 20 years and over. Among them, 30 were monitored on day 3 (49%) and 33 on day 28 (59%). Clinical and parasitological monitoring was carried out on day 7 on 28 subjects, on day 14 on 13 subjects and on day 21 on 18 subjects. Residual parasitaemia with presence of trophozoites was found in 7 of 30 subjects on day 3 (23%), and in 6 of 28 subjects on day 7 (21%) who had a temperature less than 37.5 °C. These patients can be considered as late parasitological failures. All monitoring performed on day 28 was negative. Gametocytes were found in 3 patients (9%) despite the use of primaquine. The continuing low parasitaemia on day 3 and 7 in more than one fifth of cases raises the question of the efficacy of chloroquine in southern Haiti.

Conclusions

Results suggest a decrease of chloroquine susceptibility for treatment of P. falciparum malaria cases in southern Haiti. Consequently, there is a need to strengthen malaria treatment surveillance and to study the effectiveness of chloroquine in Haiti by monitoring patients after treatment.

Keywords

Malaria Plasmodium falciparum Chloroquine susceptibility Haiti

Background

Malaria is considered a public health priority in Haiti [14], even though the transmission rate is low [5]. In Haiti, infections are believed to be entirely due to Plasmodium falciparum, and strains are believed to be susceptible to chloroquine, which is still often used in therapy, and remains the first-line treatment recommended by the Ministère de la Santé Publique et de la Population (the Ministry of Public Health and Population). Surveillance information of patients treated for malaria in Haiti is very limited. Recent studies have found P. falciparum isolates carrying chloroquine resistant genes [6, 7]. Additionally, therapeutic failures of oral chloroquine treatment have been reported [8]. In order to verify the suitability of chloroquine for uncomplicated malaria treatment, a study of in vivo susceptibility of P. falciparum was conducted from January 2013 to March 2015 in three departments in Haiti (Ouest, Sud-Est, Grande Anse).

Methods

Study sites

The study was carried out in six coastal sites in three geographic departments in Haiti (Fig. 1). In these six sites, patients were recruited from two hospitals: Hôpital Notre-Dame in Petit-Goâve (Ouest Department) and Hôpital Saint-Antoine in Jérémie (Grande Anse Department); from three community health centres: Cayes Jacmel (Sud-Est Department), Corail and Bariadelle (Grande Anse Department); and from a village known as a place of high transmission, remote from any health structure: Anse-à-Bœuf (Sud-Est Department).
Fig. 1

Location of sites where subjects were included in the study of chloroquine susceptibility of Plasmodium falciparum in three departments of the south of Haiti: 1 Petit-Goâve, 2 Corail, 3 Jérémie, 4 Bariadelle, 5 Cayes-Jacmel, 6 Anse-à-Bœuf

Subjects

Study participation included febrile patients and villagers with an axillary temperature greater or equal to 37.5 °C at baseline, and those who had a fever with chills within the prior 24 h. Inclusion criteria were: P. falciparum mono-infection with a parasitaemia ≥to 1000 asexual forms per microlitre of blood (evaluation for mono-infection was by direct microscopy), axillary temperature ≥37.5 °C on the day of the survey or fever and chills within the prior 24 h, no signs of severe or complicated malaria, and no anti-malarial treatment within the previous 2 weeks. Study objectives were explained in Haitian Creole and patients were included after having given their written consent, or that of a parent or legal guardian for minors.

A rapid diagnostic test (RDT) for P. falciparum and non-P. falciparum malaria (First Response®-CareStartTM Malaria Rapid Test) was performed. Questioning and a clinical examination looking for signs of malaria were conducted by the same physician (CPR) among the positive patients included in the study. For each subject, a capillary blood sample was taken from the fingertip to make a thick and thin blood smear. Research, identification and counting of sexual and asexual forms of P. falciparum were conducted at 1000× magnification. Subjects with less than 1000 asexual forms per microlitre were excluded from the study. Blood was collected on Whatman 903® filter paper for genotyping of the parasite strain (results not yet published). Patients were treated with chloroquine and primaquine according to dosage recommended by the Ministry of Public Health and Population, namely, 600 mg of chloroquine and 60 mg of primaquine at baseline (D0) and 300 mg of chloroquine on day 1 and 2 for adults. Children received 10 mg/kg at baseline and 5 mg/kg on day 1 and 2. After administration of treatment, patients were kept under observation for 30 min to verify absence of vomiting. In case of vomiting before 30 min passed, a new dose was administered.

Whenever possible, subjects were monitored on day 1, 2, 3, 7, 14, 21 and 28, axillary temperature was monitored, a clinical exam and a thick smear were performed. The criteria for assessing treatment efficacy were those defined by the World Health Organization (WHO) [9] to distinguish adequate clinical and parasitological response including early failure, late clinical failure, and late parasitological failure.

Laboratory procedures

Thick and thin blood smears were stained using the Giemsa method and examined under a microscope. The count of asexual forms of P. falciparum was performed compared to 200 leukocytes and evaluated by microlitre of blood while considering a number of 8000 leukocytes per microlitre of blood.

Results

A total of 71 volunteers presenting with malaria due to P. falciparum detected by a fever greater than 37.5 °C and/or a positive RDT confirmed by microscopy of the parasite on the thick smear were enrolled. Only 61 patients met the inclusion criteria, nine having too low of parasitaemia levels (between 261 and 933 trophozoites/µL), and one subject was lost after day 1. The 61 retained subjects came from six sites across three geographic regions (departments) in the south of Haiti (Table 1). 33 subjects were male and 28 were female. There were 28 children less than 10 years old, the youngest being 18 months old; 9 adolescents aged 10–19 years; and 24 adults over 20 years of age (Table 2).
Table 1

Sites in which subjects were recruited and the number of subjects reviewed at each monitoring

Department

City

Date

Number of subjects enrolled

Number of subjects examined at each monitoring

Day 0

Day 1

Day 2

Day 3

Day 7

Day 14

Day 21

Day 28

Ouest

Petit-Goâve

January 2013

1

NA

NA

1

NA

NA

NA

1

Grande Anse

Corail

January 2013 

11

NA

NA

6

NA

NA

NA

6

Grande Anse

Jérémie

February 2013 

2

NA

NA

0

NA

NA

NA

1

Sud Est

Cayes Jacmel

March 2013 

3

NA

NA

0

NA

NA

NA

2

Grande Anse

Corail

May 2013 

2

NA

NA

1

NA

NA

NA

0

Sud Est

Anse-à-Bœuf

January 2014

9

5

5

3

6

7

7

8

Sud Est

Anse-à-Bœuf

February 2014

5

NA

NA

0

4

3

NA

NA

Sud Est

Anse-à-Bœuf

June 2014

4

4

4

4

4

3

3

3

Grande Anse

Bariadelle

February 2015

24

21

17

15

14

NA

8

12

Totals

61

30

26

30

28

13

18

33

49%

70%

49%

67%

72%

49%

59%

NA not applicable

Table 2

Distribution of subjects by sex and age

Age (years)

Male

Female

≥50

3

3

20–49

9

9

10–19

6

3

1–9

15

13

Total (range 1–75)

33

28

The parasitic density of asexual forms from the 61 monitored subjects varied from 1000 to 277,227 trophozoites/µL (mean: 48,811.5; median: 14,686). The distribution of patients according to age and parasitic density is given in Table 3. The three patients with the highest levels of parasitaemia were, respectively, 4 years old (201,538 trophozoites/µL), 5 years old (277,227 trophozoites/µL) and 7 years old (262,223 trophozoites/µL).
Table 3

Distribution of subjects by age and parasitic density of trophozoites of Plasmodium falciparum per microlitre

Age (years)

Parasitic density of trophozoites/microliters of blood

1000–9999

10,000–49,999

50,000–149,000

150,000–300,000

≥50

1

3

2

0

20–49

9

4

4

2

10–19

2

1

3

2

1–9

13

7

4

4

1–75

25 (41%)

15 (25%)

13 (21%)

8 (13%)

Of the 61 patients included, 30 were monitored on day 3 (49% of the sample). Seven (23.3%) still showed P. falciparum trophozoites in the thick smear, however, in a smaller quantity than on day 0 and without clinical signs (temperature <37.5 °C). Six out of 28 still had P. falciparum throphozoites on day 7, but with an axillary temperature <37.5 °C.

By monitoring at a distance, 13 patients were reviewed at day 14, 18 patients at day 21, and 33 patients at day 28 at the end of the study. Two 2-year-old children showed persistence of trophozoites in the thick smear until day 21, but with an axillary temperature <37.5 °C. At day 28, all 33 controlled subjects had a negative thick smear without trophozoites and an axillary temperature <37.5 °C. Only 3 of them were still gametocyte carriers. During clinical follow-up, we observed the appearance on day 28 of a level 1 spleen according to the Hackett classification in a 6-year-old girl and a 72-year-old woman.

Discussion

The results of this study showed a decrease of chloroquine susceptibility for treatment of P. falciparum malaria cases in southern Haiti. Six patients failed therapy. As chloroquine is inexpensive and commonly used in Haiti this study has important implications. As stated by the World Health Organization [10], high parasitaemia is a risk factor for death from malaria. Hyperparasitaemia >250,000 parasites/µL is an additional criteria for severe malaria in non-immune individuals. The relation between parasitaemia and prognosis varies according to the level of malaria transmission. As Haiti is a low-transmission area [1, 5], it seems probable that mortality from acute falciparum malaria increases with parasite densities over 100,000/µL.

Close monitoring of patients during treatment resulted in a rapid decrease of parasitic density in four out of five cases. Two 2-year-old children in Anse-à-Bœuf retained trophozoite parasitaemia on day 14 and 21, but not on day 28 when only gametocytes were found. Throughout the entire follow-up period, their axillary temperature was <37.5 °C. For one patient, parasitaemia decreased dramatically, going from 3579 trophozoites/µL at baseline to 204/µL at day 14–44/µL at day 21. For the other, there were 1280 trophozoites at baseline and parasitaemia remained at this same level on day 7, 14, and 21. These two cases can thus be considered as two late parasitological failures.

Among all patients, the majority or most of the clinical symptoms noted on day 0 disappeared as early as the day 2 or 3 monitoring, except for the pallor of the mucous membranes, attesting to the frequent anemia among children in these villages. The fever decline was rapid: while nearly half of the patients had an axillary temperature between 37.5 °C and 40.8 °C at baseline, only two of 31 patients had, respectively, an axillary temperature of 37.9 °C and 38.1 °C on day 1, only one out of 25 on day 2 (37.5 °C), and one out of 30 on day 3 (38.1 °C). Afterward, all patients that were monitored weekly until day 28 had an axillary temperature of less than 37.5 °C.

Through questioning and examination, the improvement of clinical status was observed among all patients during monitoring, indicating that chloroquine remains effective in Haiti. This study shows that the majority of P. falciparum isolates remain susceptible, in vivo, to chloroquine in Haiti, as was observed some 30 years ago [11, 12] and until recently in Léogane among 49 patients [13].

However, in a recent study [8], the persistence of parasitaemia among 7 out of 60 asymptomatic patients monitored until day 28 and 42 was observed in the Ouest department, and interpreted as late parasitological failures. These recent findings are similar to the results of this study. They likely indicate an onset of decreased susceptibility of this drug in the treatment of malaria in Haiti. These in vivo results should be compared with recent detection of P. falciparum haplotypes carrying chloroquine resistant genes in Artibonite [6].

Two major difficulties were encountered during this study. The first was the recruitment of cases that met the pre-established inclusion criteria. It is currently difficult to recruit malaria cases in Haiti, except in a few specific areas such as Anse-à-Bœuf in the Sud-Est department (N°6 on the map in Fig. 1), and Bariadelle in the Grande Anse department (N°4). This is why these two sites were prioritized to conduct this study, despite their distance from Port-au-Prince, and the difficulty of accessing Anse-à-Bœuf. As for the majority of febrile subjects examined during visits to the health centres, they tested negative by RDT. This confirms that malaria is not the leading cause of febrile illness in Haiti. It is, therefore, essential to achieve precise diagnosis of fevers using the increasingly available rapid tests, to avoid unnecessarily treating all febrile subjects with anti-malarials.

The second limitation concerns the routine monitoring of included subjects. Despite their consent to participate in the study, some subjects were lost and did not return to their follow-up appointments, which resulted in variation of the days where follow-up monitoring was performed. This loss of patients was experienced less in the fishing villages of Anse-à-Bœuf and Bariadelle, where it was easier to find the subjects in their home, in case they missed monitoring appointments. However, despite this limitation, the study still indicates the decrease of chloroquine susceptibility by P. falciparum parasites.

Conclusions

The implications of this study highlight the need to strengthen surveillance of decreasing in vivo susceptibility of P. falciparum throughout the country in order to identify the regions affected by these failures in chloroquine treatment. This information is critical in determining appropriate therapeutic and control measures in Haiti.

Abbreviations

RDT: 

rapid diagnostic test

WHO: 

World Health Organization

Declarations

Authors’ contributions

CR: Designed the study; supervised selection of patients in the field, including the patients’ clinical exams; analysed results; and drafted the article. PB: Took blood samples in the field; calculated the trophozoites on the thick smears; and analysed results. MC: Conducted laboratory analysis. DP: Translated manuscript from French into English; and revised it critically for intellectual content. MZ: Revised manuscript critically for intellectual content. JB: Provided overall scientific guidance for the study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

We thank the World Bank and the Région Haute Normandie (France) who contributed funding to this study, the Programme National de Lutte contre la Malaria and the Organisation Haïtienne de Marketing Social pour la Santé (Haïti) who provided vehicles for the field work, and the patients who participated in this study without financial compensation. Our deepest gratitude goes equally to the health personnel at the selected hospitals and health centres who gave their support and technical collaboration to conduct this study.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Availability of data and materials

The dataset produced by the current study is available from the corresponding author upon request.

Consent for publication

Not applicable.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

This was an official study led by the Laboratoire National de Santé Publique (LNSP) under the auspices of the Ministry of Public Health and Population. The project was approved by the Scientific Committee of the LNSP. The study respected the ethical rules used by the international scientific community, and provided subjects with detailed information in Creole as well as obtained a signed written consent form from each participant, or that of a parent or legal guardian for minors.

Funding

The World Bank and the Région Haute Normandie (France) contributed funding to this study.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.

Authors’ Affiliations

(1)
Laboratoire National de Santé Publique
(2)
Institut de Recherches pour le Développement, Campus international UCAD-IRD de Hann
(3)
The Global Health Initiative, Henry Ford Health System

References

  1. Raccurt C. Le point sur le paludisme en Haïti (in French). Cahiers d’études et de recherches francophones/Santé. 2004;14:201–4.Google Scholar
  2. Boncy PJ, Adrien P, Lemoine JF, Existe A, Henry PJ, Raccurt C, et al. Malaria elimination in Haiti by the year 2020: an achievable goal? Malar J. 2015;14:237.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  3. Adrien P, Boncy JP, Lemoine F, Existe A, Juin S, Amouzou S, et al. Malaria elimination in Haiti: challenges, progress and solutions. Clin Microbiol Infect Dis. 2016;1:63–6.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  4. WHO. World malaria report 2016. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2016.Google Scholar
  5. von Fricken ME, Weppelmann TA, Lam B, Eaton WT, Schick L, Masse R, et al. Age-specific malaria seroprevalence rates: a cross-sectional analysis of malaria transmission in the Ouest and Sud-Est departments of Haiti. Malar J. 2014;13:361.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
  6. Londono BL, Eisele TP, Keating J, Bennett A, Chattopadhyay C, Heyliger G, et al. Chloroquine-resistant haplotype Plasmodium falciparum parasites, Haiti. Emerg Infect Dis. 2009;15:735–40.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  7. Gharbi M, Pillai DR, Lau R, Hubert V, Khairnar K, Existe A, et al. Chloroquine-resistant malaria in travelers returning from Haiti after 2010 earthquake. Emerg Infect Dis. 2012;18:1346–9.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  8. Okech BA, Existe A, Romain JR, Memnon G, Victor YS, de Rochars MB, et al. Therapeutic efficacy of chloroquine for the treatment of uncomplicated Plasmodium falciparum in Haiti after many decades of its use. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2015;92:541–5.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  9. WHO. Evaluation et surveillance de l’efficacité des antipaludiques pour le traitement du paludisme à Plasmodium falciparum non compliqué. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2004.Google Scholar
  10. WHO. Management of severe malaria—a practical handbook. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2012.Google Scholar
  11. Magloire R, Nguyen-Dinh P. Chloroquine susceptibility of Plasmodium falciparum in Haiti. Bull World Health Organ. 1983;61:1017–20.PubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
  12. Duverseau YT, Magloire R, Zevallos-Ipenza A, Rogers HM, Nguyen-Dinh P. Monitoring of chloroquine sensitivity of Plasmodium falciparum in Haiti, 1981–1983. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1986;35:459–64.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
  13. Neuberger A, Zhong K, Kain KC, Schwartz E. Lack of evidence for chloroquine-resistant Plasmodium falciparum malaria, Leogane, Haiti. Emerg Infect Dis. 2012;18:1487–9.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar

Copyright

© The Author(s) 2017

Comments

By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.

Advertisement