Evidence supporting deployment of next generation insecticide treated nets in Burkina Faso: bioassays with either chlorfenapyr or piperonyl butoxide increase mortality of pyrethroid-resistant Anopheles gambiae
Malaria Journal volume 20, Article number: 406 (2021)
Pyrethroid resistance poses a major threat to the efficacy of insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) in Burkina Faso and throughout sub-Saharan Africa, particularly where resistance is present at high intensity. For such areas, there are alternative ITNs available, including the synergist piperonyl butoxide (PBO)-based ITNs and dual active ingredient ITNs such as Interceptor G2 (treated with chlorfenapyr and alpha-cypermethrin). Before deploying alternative ITNs on a large scale it is crucial to characterize the resistance profiles of primary malaria vector species for evidence-based decision making.
Larvae from the predominant vector, Anopheles gambiae sensu lato (s.l.) were collected from 15 sites located throughout Burkina Faso and reared to adults for bioassays to assess insecticide resistance status. Resistance intensity assays were conducted using WHO tube tests to determine the level of resistance to pyrethroids commonly used on ITNs at 1×, 5 × and 10 × times the diagnostic dose. WHO tube tests were also used for PBO synergist bioassays with deltamethrin and permethrin. Bottle bioassays were conducted to determine susceptibility to chlorfenapyr at a dose of 100 µg/bottle.
WHO tube tests revealed high intensity resistance in An. gambiae s.l. to deltamethrin and alpha-cypermethrin in all sites tested. Resistance intensity to permethrin was either moderate or high in 13 sites. PBO pre-exposure followed by deltamethrin restored full susceptibility in one site and partially restored susceptibility in all but one of the remaining sites (often reaching mortality greater than 80%). PBO pre-exposure followed by permethrin partially restored susceptibility in 12 sites. There was no significant increase in permethrin mortality after PBO pre-exposure in Kampti, Karangasso-Vigué or Mangodara; while in Seguenega, Orodara and Bobo-Dioulasso there was a significant increase in mortality, but rates remained below 50%. Susceptibility to chlorfenapyr was confirmed in 14 sites.
High pyrethroid resistance intensity in An. gambiae s.l. is widespread across Burkina Faso and may be a predictor of reduced pyrethroid ITN effectiveness. PBO + deltamethrin ITNs would likely provide greater control than pyrethroid nets. However, since susceptibility in bioassays was not restored in most sites following pre-exposure to PBO, Interceptor G2 may be a better long-term solution as susceptibility was recorded to chlorfenapyr in nearly all sites. This study provides evidence supporting the introduction of both Interceptor G2 nets and PBO nets, which were distributed in Burkina Faso in 2019 as part of a mass campaign.
Burkina Faso relies on mass distribution of insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) every three years as the primary method of vector control, while indoor residual spraying (IRS) has been implemented in two or three districts per year since 2018 . Millions of pyrethroid ITNs have been distributed in Burkina Faso during the past 20 years which, along with agricultural use of pyrethroids, has increased the selection pressure on malaria vector populations. Pyrethroid resistance was observed in Anopheles gambiae sensu lato (s.l.) populations for the first time in Côte d’Ivoire in 1993 , and within a few years was detected throughout all countries in West Africa, including Burkina Faso, and is now found across all of sub-Saharan Africa [3, 4]. The voltage-gated sodium channel gene (Vgsc)-L1014F mutation (also known as kdr-west) was assumed to be the main mechanism conferring resistance to pyrethroids in West Africa [5, 6], while in East Africa, a different amino acid substitution at the same locus known as Vgsc-L1014S (also known as kdr-east) had been detected . Voltage-gated sodium channel gene mutations were first identified within An. gambiae populations [5, 6] across West Africa before it was detected within Anopheles coluzzii , most likely as a result of introgression, while its occurrence in wild Anopheles arabiensis populations was identified as an independent mutation . While Vgsc mutations are widespread and contribute to phenotypic pyrethroid resistance, metabolic resistance mechanisms are generally more important drivers of high intensity pyrethroid resistance .
Pyrethroid resistance poses a threat to the efficacy of ITNs, particularly when resistance is present at high intensity [11, 12]. In Burkina Faso, pyrethroid resistance has been observed nationwide for several years and there are fears that pyrethroid ITNs may no longer provide the desired levels of individual and community protection . While there are several localized studies in Burkina Faso that have described the genetic mutations involved in pyrethroid resistance, including Vgsc-1014F and 1014S mutations in association with N1575Y mutations and metabolic resistance patterns [13, 14], there is limited bioassay information regarding the relative improvement in mortality provided by piperonyl butoxide (PBO) synergists within wild An. gambiae s.l. populations. Reduced mosquito mortality by pyrethroid ITNs was reported in experimental hut trials in Benin in 2007  and more recently in Burkina Faso  with free-flying An. gambiae s.l. In order to preserve the efficacy of ITNs and other insecticide-based control methods such as IRS, the World Health Organization (WHO) has developed a global plan for insecticide resistance management (GPIRM) . Among the key elements are: (i) rotation of insecticides; (ii) mixtures of at least two different insecticides; (iii) alternating use of at least two insecticides from different classes; and, (iv) mosaic use of insecticides.
A limiting factor preventing implementation of these strategies has been the lack of alternative classes of insecticide for ITNs. However, in recent years several PBO synergist nets have received prequalification (PQ) listing by the WHO . PBO is a synergist that acts by inhibiting metabolic enzymes within the mosquito, particularly cytochrome P450s that detoxify or sequester pyrethroids . Although synergists do not typically act as insecticides, they can increase or restore the potency of insecticides by overcoming existing resistance mechanisms [19, 20]. As a result, PBO nets should produce an increased killing effect of malaria vectors where the major pyrethroid resistance mechanisms are due to increased oxidase activity. Two randomized control trials in Tanzania and Uganda have demonstrated a clinical benefit of PBO nets in areas of moderate pyrethroid resistance, with a reduction in malaria prevalence detected for at least six months after net distribution compared to conventional pyrethroid nets [21, 22].
A new ‘dual active ingredient’ net with two different active ingredients (AIs) is Interceptor® G2 (combining chlorfenapyr and alpha-cypermethrin), which received WHO PQ listing in 2018 . Chlorfenapyr is a pyrrole compound with a non-neurotoxic mode of action which shows no cross resistance to existing pyrethroid resistance mechanisms [23, 24]. Experimental hut studies of Interceptor G2 have shown high efficacy and wash durability against pyrethroid resistant malaria vectors in Benin , Burkina Faso  and Côte d’Ivoire .
To guide National Malaria Control Programme (NMCP) decision-making regarding choice of ITN type, it is crucial to regularly gather insecticide susceptibility data for those insecticides used on ITNs, namely pyrethroids with and without PBO synergist, and chlorfenapyr. This study evaluated the level of pyrethroid resistance intensity in An. gambiae s.l. against the main pyrethroids used on ITNs followed by synergist assays to determine whether the synergist PBO restores susceptibility. In addition, the study determined susceptibility of An. gambiae s.l. to chlorfenapyr.
The NMCP of Burkina Faso selected 21 sentinel sites for malaria vector insecticide resistance monitoring studies (Fig. 1). The sites were dispersed nationwide through the three eco-climatic zones of the country (Sahelian, Sudan-Sahelian, Sudan). For security reasons, it was not possible to monitor all 21 sites in 2019, especially sites located in the Sahelian zone and eastern part of country, therefore, the study covered 15 sites located in the three climatic areas, including IRS sites and neighbouring unsprayed control sites (Additional file 1). The Sudanian climatic zone covers the southwestern area (including Orodara, Bobo-Dioulasso, Soumousso, Karangasso-Vigué, Diébougou, Gaoua, Kampti, and Mangodara sites) and is the wettest in the country, with the mean annual rainfall averaging 1,000–1200 mm with most occurring in the rainy season extending from May to November, whereas the northern Sahelian zone (Kongoussi and Seguenega) is relatively dry, with less than 600 mm annual rainfall. In the central Sudano-Sahelian zone (Solenzo, Nouna, Boromo, Ouagadougou, and Kaya), the average yearly rainfall is 600–900 mm per year, with a shorter rainy season than in the southwest, extending from June to September 2019.
Mosquito larval collections were carried out between August and October 2019 during the period of high malaria vector density. Anopheles gambiae s.l. larvae were collected from temporary water pools from all 15 sites before transport to the Research Institute of Health Sciences (IRSS) insectary and were reared to the adult stage prior to use in bioassays. Female An. gambiae s.l. were then used for insecticide susceptibility assays according to WHO procedures . Species composition among the An. gambiae species complex was determined through PCR after completion of bioassay and is described below.
Laboratory testing procedures
Pyrethroid insecticide susceptibility and resistance intensity tests using WHO tube tests
Three pyrethroid insecticides were used for susceptibility tests at their diagnostic concentrations: permethrin 0.75%, deltamethrin 0.05% and alpha-cypermethrin 0.05%. Pyrethroid resistance intensity was monitored in 14 locations (resistance intensity testing was not conducted in Bobo-Dioulasso) with alpha-cypermethrin, deltamethrin and permethrin papers treated at 1, 5 and 10 times the diagnostic concentration using WHO tubes. Prior to the field susceptibility assays, two impregnated papers with each insecticide were randomly selected from each box and tested against a laboratory-maintained susceptible strain of An. gambiae Kisumu to verify the quality of the paper. On average, batches of 20–25 sugar-fed female An. gambiae s.l. aged 3–5 days old were introduced into each WHO tube and exposed to the insecticide-treated paper for one hour  at 27 ± 2 °C temperature and 70 ± 5% relative humidity (Additional file 2). Four replicates were conducted, making a total of approximately 100 mosquitoes tested for each insecticide per site. Negative control bioassays were conducted for each test by exposing a total of 50 An. gambiae s.l. (two replicates of 25) using tubes lined with filter papers treated with silicone oil. Positive control bioassays were also conducted for each insecticide with an insectary colony of susceptible An. gambiae Kisumu (4 replicates per insecticide). The knock-down rates were recorded at 5, 10, 15, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 min after the start of exposure with mortality recorded 24 h after insecticide exposure . All mosquitoes were held for 24 h in laboratory conditions at 27 ± 2 °C temperature and 70 ± 5% relative humidity to evaluate the mortality. Insecticide-treated papers were supplied by the WHO Collaborating Centre of Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM).
PBO synergist assays using WHO tube tests
Synergist bioassays were also conducted by exposing batches from 20 to 25 sugar-fed female An. gambiae s.l. in WHO tubes lined with PBO (4%)-impregnated papers for one hour before being transferred to a second tube with a pyrethroid insecticide (either permethrin (0.75%), deltamethrin (0.05%) or alpha-cypermethrin (0.05%)) impregnated paper for one hour (Additional file 3). The number of dead mosquitoes was recorded 24 h after the end of the exposure period at 27 ± 2 °C temperature and 70 ± 5% relative humidity. Negative controls consisted of two batches of around 20–25 mosquitoes exposed to PBO without subsequent exposure to pyrethroid insecticide and also silicone oil-treated papers. Each test consisted of four replicates. Synergist tests were conducted in all 15 sites with deltamethrin and permethrin but only five sites with alpha-cypermethrin due to insufficient mosquitoes in 10 sites during larval collections.
Chlorfenapyr susceptibility tests using CDC bottle bioassays
During the time of data collection there was no published guidance from WHO regarding chlorfenapyr susceptibility test procedures or diagnostic concentrations. Preliminary bottle bioassay testing by Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) protocol established a tentative diagnostic dose of 100 µg/bottle. Therefore, 250-ml Wheaton bottles were treated in the IRSS laboratory using technical grade chlorfenapyr dissolved in acetone at a dosage of 100 µg/bottle. Mortality rates were assessed at 24, 48 and 72 h after exposure. Four replicates of 25 An. gambiae s.l. were conducted, making a total of approximately 100 mosquitoes tested per site. Tests were conducted during the daytime with effort made to keep testing and holding conditions within WHO guidelines of 27 ± 2 °C and relative humidity of 75 ± 10% .
Molecular assays to determine Anopheles gambiae s.l. species composition and characterization of resistance mutations
After the bioassay tests, all mosquitoes were placed individually in 1.5-ml tubes with silica gel before being stored in a − 20 °C freezer at IRSS until further laboratory analysis. A sub-set of approximately 50 female An. gambiae s.l. per site were tested by PCR to determine species composition. Genomic DNA of mosquitoes was extracted with 2% cetyl trimethyl ammonium bromide (2% CTAB). Species of the An. gambiae complex were identified by PCR as either An. gambiae sensu stricto (s.s.), An. coluzzii or An. arabiensis using the Sine 200X protocol of Santolamazza et al. . Mutations involved in insecticide resistance were identified by PCR using the protocols of Martinez-Torres et al.  and Ranson et al.  for the voltage-gated sodium channel (Vgsc) L1014F and L1014S mutations.
Data were entered into Microsoft Excel and analysed with STATA version 13.0 (College Station, TX 77,845, USA). WHO criteria were used to classify wild An. gambiae s.l. as ‘resistant’ if less than 90% mortality was observed, resistance needing confirmation if mortality was between 90–97% and susceptible if between 98–100% . Resistance intensity was defined as being high resistance intensity if mortality at the 10 × dose was less than 98%, moderate intensity if less than 98% at the 5 × dose but greater than 98% at 10x, and low intensity resistance if mortality was greater than 98% at the 5 × dose .
The results of synergist assays were analysed by insecticide by comparing results of PBO plus pyrethroid versus pyrethroid only. The data were then interpreted following WHO criteria :
Complete restoration of susceptibility following pre-exposure to PBO (i.e. ≥ 98% mean mortality) implies that a monooxygenase-based resistance mechanism fully accounts for expression of the resistant phenotype in the test population.
Partial restoration of susceptibility following pre-exposure to PBO (i.e. mean mortality in the PBO followed by insecticide samples is greater than mean mortality in the insecticide only samples but less than 98%) implies that a monooxygenase-based resistance mechanism only partially accounts for expression of the resistant phenotype and that other resistance mechanisms are likely to be present in the test population.
No restoration of susceptibility following pre-exposure to PBO (mean mortality in the PBO followed by insecticide samples is equal to or lower than mean mortality in the insecticide only samples) implies that the resistance phenotype detected is not based on mono-oxgenase-mediated detoxification.
Descriptive statistics were used to calculate the mean mortality rates and differences between the average mortality rate. Mortality rates from bioassays were calculated with their 95% confidence interval (CI) and compared by ecological zone using Chi-squared test. The knockdown times for 50 and 95% of tested mosquitoes (KdT50 and KdT95) were calculated using a log time probit model  for mosquito exposure to PBO followed by deltamethrin and permethrin exposure. The KdT50 and KdT95 were estimated for sites located in Sudan areas where the mass coverage of PBO-pyrethroid ITNs were targeted. The genotypic frequencies of Vgsc1014F and 1014S in mosquito populations were compared to Hardy–Weinberg expectations using GenePOP software .
Distribution of Anopheles gambiae species
Of 700 An. gambiae s.l. analysed by PCR, 51.8% were An. gambiae s.s., 30.6% An. coluzzii and 17.6% An. arabiensis. Anopheles gambiae s.s. was the predominant species in the Sudan area (61.6%), except in Kampti and Bobo-Dioulasso where more than 50% were An. arabiensis (Fig. 2). In the Sudano-Sahelian zone An. coluzzii was more common in Nouna and Solenzo, where it was the dominant species (> 50%); however, in Boromo and Ouagadougou, more than 80% were An. gambiae s.s. Anopheles coluzzii was the predominant species in Sahelian area (67.3%). In all three eco-climatic zones, An. gambiae s.s. was found in sympatry with An. coluzzii. Anopheles arabiensis was found in relatively high proportions in the Sudanian zone at 27.4% (95%CI: 0.6–51.3).
WHO tube tests revealed that An. gambiae s.l. were resistant to the three pyrethroid insecticides tested, with mortality rates less than 70% at all sites for deltamethrin, permethrin and alpha-cypermethrin diagnostic doses (Fig. 3). Mean mortality rates across the 14 sites were 33.2% for deltamethrin, 24.5% for permethrin and 19.0% for alpha-cypermethrin (Fig. 3). There was particularly low mortality in Kaya for all three pyrethroids: 11.8% (95% CI:0.1–28.6) mortality for deltamethrin, 13.6% (95% CI:0.1–27.2) for permethrin and 2.0% (95% CI:0.1–7.8) for alpha-cypermethrin. There were many examples of sites having very low mortality rates for individual pyrethroid insecticides. The susceptible An. gambiae Kisumu strain exhibited 100% mortality to all three pyrethroids, therefore confirming that insecticide-treated papers were dosed correctly. Control mortality was less than 5% in all bioassays.
Pyrethroid resistance intensity
The results showed high resistance intensity in all 14 sites to deltamethrin and alpha-cypermethrin (mortality less than 98% at the 10 × dose) with An. gambiae s.l. (Fig. 3A, B). Mortality rates varied between 45.6% in Kaya to 96.0% in Karangasso-Vigue at the 10 × dose of deltamethrin (Fig. 3A). The results with alpha-cypermethrin at the 10 × dose showed mortality rates between 45.8% in Nouna and 96.3% in Kampti (Fig. 3B). The resistance intensity of An. gambiae s.l. to permethrin was more varied with eight sites classified as high intensity, five as moderate and one with low resistance intensity (Diebougou) (Fig. 3C).
PBO plus pyrethroid synergist assays
Pre-exposure to PBO (4%) followed by a pyrethroid insecticide significantly improved mortality rates in all sites for deltamethrin (P < 0.05) although there was great variation between sites (Fig. 4A). PBO pre-exposure followed by deltamethrin restored full susceptibility only in Gaoua but partially restored susceptibility in the remaining sites (often reaching mortality greater than 80%) except Solenzo where the mortality remained below 50%.
PBO pre-exposure followed by permethrin did not restore full susceptibility in any site, but did partially restore susceptibility in 12 sites from the 14 sites tested. However, there was no significant increase in mortality in Kampti, Karangasso-Vigué or Mangodara. While in Seguenega, Orodara and Bobo-Dioulasso there was a significant increase in mortality, but rates remained below 50% (Fig. 4B). Synergist tests with alpha-cypermethrin were only conducted in five sites. Mortality of An. gambiae s.l. reached more than 90% after pre-exposure to PBO followed by alpha-cypermethrin in three of five sites (Ouagadougou, Karangasso-Vigué and Soumousso) (Fig. 4C). In the remaining two sites of Kongoussi and Seguenega there was partial restoration of susceptibility, but mortality rates did not reach 50%.
The analysis of knockdown times (KDT) showed that the pre-exposure of An. gambiae s.l. to PBO reduced both the KDT50 and KDT95 (time needed to achieve 50 and 95% mosquito knockdown) compared to those mosquitoes only exposed to deltamethrin or permethrin. The KDT50 and KDT95 times with deltamethrin after exposure to PBO were 2 to 3 times faster compared to those obtained with deltamethrin only (Table 1). KDT50 and KDT95 values for PBO after exposure to permethrin showed similar trends with two-fold faster knockdown than permethrin only (Table 1).
The results of susceptibility tests performed with An. gambiae s.l. against chlorfenapyr at 100 µg/bottle revealed high mortality (98–100%) 24 h after exposure in most sites. Susceptibility to chlorfenapyr was confirmed in 14 sites using 72 h mortality data, with Boromo the only site where mortality was less than 98% (Fig. 5; Additional file 4).
Frequency of the Vgsc-L1014F and 1014S mutations
The Vgsc-L1014F mutation was observed at varying frequencies between sites and by mosquito species (Table 2). This mutation was found at a higher frequency within An. gambiae s.s. populations with allele frequencies varying from 0.53 in Boromo to 0.98 in Soumousso (for sites where more than 20 samples were tested). The mean frequency within An. gambiae s.s. (n = 310) across all sites was 0.71 for Vgsc-L1014F and 0.13 for Vgsc-L1014S, with 5% of this species having both alleles present.
In An. coluzzii (n = 200), the mean Vgsc-L1014F frequency was lower than that in An. gambiae s.s. at 0.52. The mean Vgsc-L1014S frequency was 0.19 in An. coluzzii. More surprisingly, both allele mutations were also present in An. arabiensis populations at a similar frequency to An. coluzzii, with a mean of 0.52 for Vgsc-L1014F and 0.19 for Vgsc-L1014S. Comparing by climatic zones, the Vgsc-L1014F mutation was higher in Sudanian and Sudano-Sahelian areas (χ2 = 12.91, df = 1.311, P < 0.0001) than that in Sahelian sites.
The L1014S mutation is now widespread throughout the country within An. gambiae s.s. and An. coluzzii and was found in six sites within An. arabiensis populations, although the frequency was relatively low in all sites with 0.29 for An. arabiensis in Kampti being the highest frequency for any site (where > 10 samples were tested).
Significant deviations from Hardy–Weinberg expectations were observed in An. gambiae populations from Kongoussi, Seguenega, Ouagadougou, Boromo, and Kaya, and An. coluzzii populations from Kampti, Gaoua, Solenzo, Boromo, and Seguenega. This was due to strong heterozygote deficits.
This study have demonstrated for the first time, using standardized WHO protocols , that high intensity pyrethroid resistance is not geographically confined to areas of intense agriculture but is widespread throughout Burkina Faso. Given that the primary malaria vector control strategy in Burkina Faso is nationwide universal coverage with ITNs, of particular concern is the high intensity of resistance to deltamethrin and alpha-cypermethrin documented at every site tested. Pyrethroid resistance intensity is an important measure that may indicate the potential for reduced effectiveness of pyrethroid ITNs. WHO suggest that “confirmed levels of resistance, especially at ten times the discriminating concentration may indicate or predict operational control failure and highlight a particularly urgent need to develop an appropriate resistance management strategy” . High intensity resistance was previously only documented in intensive agricultural areas, such as Vallée du Kou, an area of concentrated rice cultivation 25 km from Bobo-Dioulasso, where deltamethrin resistance up to 1,000 fold was reported in An. coluzzii in 2013 compared to the susceptible Kisumu strain of An. gambiae .
To supplement universal coverage with pyrethroid ITNs, which are deployed via mass campaigns every three years, US President’s Malaria Initiative (PMI)-funded IRS with non-pyrethroid insecticides (organophosphates and neonicotinoids) has also been conducted annually since 2018 in three high burden districts (Kampti, Solenzo, Kongoussi) in accordance with the WHO GPIRM recommendations. However, the relatively high cost of IRS makes the prospect of national use of this strategy low and PBO or dual active ingredient nets are likely to be the primary response for control of pyrethroid-resistant malaria vectors. A barrier limiting the purchase of PBO nets by NMCPs and donors is that PBO ITNs cost approximately 40% more than equivalent pyrethroid ITNs . Therefore, it is important to target distribution to locations where PBO synergist bioassays indicate full or partial restoration of susceptibility to pyrethroids. Toé et al.  showed in Vallée du Kou and Tengrela (southwestern Burkina Faso) evidence of synergism but pre-exposure to PBO did not fully restore susceptibility to deltamethrin or permethrin in bioassays or in experimental hut studies. Bayili et al.  also showed in experimental hut studies in Vallée du Kou that deltamethrin plus PBO nets provided additional benefit over the equivalent pyrethroid-only LLINs, but mortality and blood-feeding inhibition rates were relatively low. While these studies provided important information, they were limited in geographical scope. Results from study showed that mosquito mortality rates nationwide significantly increased when An. gambiae s.l. were pre-exposed to PBO in association with permethrin, deltamethrin and alpha-cypermethrin even in areas of high resistance intensity in western part of country (Mangodara, Gaoua, Kampti). In all sites, pre-exposure to PBO also reduced the mean KDT compared to exposure to only pyrethroids. While randomized controlled trials have shown the benefit of PBO nets in Tanzania  and Uganda  in areas of moderate pyrethroid resistance, it is not clear what level of increased mortality in susceptibility bioassays is required to correlate with epidemiological impact. WHO provide limited guidance, stating that the added benefit of pyrethroid PBO nets compared to pyrethroid-only LLINs is expected to be the greatest where pyrethroid resistance is at “intermediate levels”, where mosquito mortality after exposure to a pyrethroid insecticide in WHO test kits ranges from 10 to 80%, but do not state what level of mortality increase is biologically significant . The most recent PMI Malaria Operational Plan Guidance recommends that PBO nets only be considered in areas where PBO increases pyrethroid susceptibility by at least 10% (absolute terms) . Based on results from study, PBO plus deltamethrin ITNs are the most promising option in Burkina Faso as greater than 70% mortality was reached from bioassays in 12 of 15 sites, with susceptibility restored in one site and a greater than 10% absolute increase in mortality in all sites.
Laboratory analysis showed that the frequency of the Vgsc-L101F mutation is moderate or high in An. gambiae s.s., An. coluzzii and An. arabiensis. The frequency of the Vgsc-L1014S mutation is also increasing in frequency compared to prior years, particularly in An. gambiae s.s. . Surprising results found also were the similar allele mutations frequencies in both species An. coluzzi and An. arabiensis. Indeed, this finding could be explained by the colonization of An. coluzzi breeding sites by An. arabiensis species particularly in urban sites exposed to insecticides pressure. Previous microarray analysis of An. coluzzii from Vallée du Kou has implicated several P450 genes including CYP6P3 and CYP6Z2 . Similarly, Toé et al.  found CYP6Z2 and CYP6Z3 the most highly overexpressed genes in Vallée du Kou and Tengrela. This suggests that there are complex underlying resistance mechanisms involved, including target site resistance, metabolic resistance mechanisms and there may be other mechanisms not yet detected, such as increased cuticle thickness. It is important for further studies to be conducted over a wider geographical distribution to do molecular and genetic investigations to have a better understanding of the specific cytochrome P450 enzymes and mono-oxygenases.
While there is a good prospect that PBO plus deltamethrin ITNs will provide greater control than pyrethroid ITNs in most locations of Burkina Faso in the short term, there are already examples in parts of Côte d’Ivoire  and Mozambique  where PBO nets no longer provide additional benefit due to the high intensity of pyrethroid resistance and the resistance mechanisms present. Interceptor G2 may be a longer term alternative for improved control of pyrethroid-resistant mosquitoes as chlorfenapyr has a completely different mode of action and works through oxidative phosphorylation of the cell mitochondria . Large-scale testing of susceptibility to chlorfenapyr at the interim diagnostic dose of 100 µg/bottle was conducted for the first time in Burkina Faso and showed susceptibility in nearly all sites. Experimental hut trials in Burkina Faso , Benin  and Côte d’Ivoire  have shown higher vector mortality with Interceptor G2 even when washed 20 times to simulate field use. The results of randomized controlled trials being conducted in Benin and Tanzania to determine the epidemiological impact of Interceptor G2 nets compared to pyrethroid nets are eagerly awaited before widespread distribution can be recommended by WHO. In the interim, as part of the ‘New Nets Project’, pilot distribution of PBO and Interceptor G2 nets was conducted in parts of Burkina Faso in 2019 . Districts were selected to receive PBO and Interceptor G2 nets based on the results of insecticide resistance monitoring, along with other operational criteria. Given the increased costs of PBO and Interceptor G2 nets it is important to continue monitoring their lifetime durability including physical integrity, residual insecticidal efficacy and chemical retention over three years.
High pyrethroid resistance intensity in malaria vector species is widespread across Burkina Faso and may be a predictor of reduced pyrethroid ITN effectiveness. Pre-exposure to the synergist PBO significantly increased vector mortality, resulting in partial or full restoration of susceptibility in most sites. PBO plus deltamethrin ITNs should be prioritized for distribution in Burkina Faso as this combination provided the highest levels of mortality increase. However, susceptibility was not restored in most sites and dual active ingredient nets, such as Interceptor G,2 may be a better long-term solution.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article and additional files.
Center for Disease Control and Prevention
Global plan for insecticide resistance management
Institut de Recherche en Sciences de la Santé
Indoor residual spraying
- Kdr :
Knockdown times for 50%
Knockdown times for 95%
Long-lasting insecticidal nets
National Malaria Control Programme
US President’s Malaria Initiative
Universiti Sains Malaysia
- Vgsc :
Voltage-gated sodium channel gene
World Health Organization
President’s Malaria Initiative Burkina Faso Malaria Operational Plan FY 2019. https://www.pmi.gov/docs/default-source/default-document-library/malaria-operational-plans/fy19/fy-2019-burkina-faso-malaria-operational-plan.pdf?sfvrsn=3#:~:text=ITNs%3A%20The%20national%20strategy%20for,routine%20antenatal%20care%20and%20expanded. Accessed 25 May 2021.
Elissa N, Mouchet J, Riviere F, Meunier JY, Yao K. Resistance of Anopheles gambiae s.s. to pyrethroids in Côte d’Ivoire. Ann Soc Belg Med Trop. 1993;73:291–4.
Dabiré RK, Namountougou M, Sawadogo SP, Yaro LB, Toé HK, Ouari A, et al. Population dynamics of Anopheles gambiae s.l. in Bobo-Dioulasso city: bionomics, infection rate and susceptibility to insecticides. Parasit Vectors. 2012;5:127.
Moyes CL, Wiebe A, Gleave K, Trett A, Hancock PA, Padonou GG, et al. Analysis-ready datasets for insecticide resistance phenotype and genotype frequency in African malaria vectors. Sci Data. 2019;6:121.
Chandre F, Darrier F, Manga L, Akogbeto M, Faye O, Mouchet J, et al. Status of pyrethroid resistance in Anopheles gambiae sensu lato. Bull World Health Organ. 1999;77:230–4.
Dabiré KR, Diabaté A, Namountougou M, Djogbenou L, Wondji C, Chandre F, Simard F, Ouédraogo J-B, Martin T, Weill M, Baldet T. Trends in insecticide resistance in natural populations of malaria vectors in Burkina Faso, West Africa: 10 years’ surveys. In: Perveen F, editor. Insecticides – pest engineering. Croatia: InTech; 2012. p. 479–502.
Ranson H, Jensen B, Vulule JM, Wang X, Hemingway J, Collins FH. Identification of a point mutation in the voltage-gated sodium channel gene of Kenyan Anopheles gambiae associated with resistance to DDT and pyrethroids. Insect Mol Biol. 2000;9:491–7.
Diabate A, Baldet T, Chandre C, Dabire KR, Kengne P, Guiguemde TR, et al. kdr mutation, a genetic marker to assess events of introgression between the molecular M and S forms of Anopheles gambiae (Diptera: Culicidae) in the tropical savannah area of West Africa. J Med Entomol. 2003;40:195–8.
Diabaté A, Baldet T, Chandre F, Dabire KR, Simard F, Ouedraogo JB, et al. First report of a kdr mutation in Anopheles arabiensis from Burkina Faso, West Africa. J Am Mosq Control Assoc. 2004;20:195–6.
Ranson H, Lissenden N. Insecticide resistance in African Anopheles mosquitoes: a worsening situation that needs urgent action to maintain malaria control. Trends Parasitol. 2016;32:187–96.
Churcher TS, Lissenden N, Griffin JT, Worrall E, Ranson H. The impact of pyrethroid resistance on the efficacy and effectiveness of bednets for malaria control in Africa. Elife. 2016;5:16090.
Hemingway J, Ranson H, Magill A, Kolaczinski J, Fornadel C, Gimnig J, et al. Averting a malaria disaster: will insecticide resistance derail malaria control? Lancet. 2016;387:1785–8.
Jones CM, Liyanapathirana M, Agossa FR, Weetman D, Ranson H, Donnelly MJ, et al. Footprints of positive selection associated with a mutation (N1575Y) in the voltage-gated sodium channel of Anopheles gambiae. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2012;109:6614–9.
Namountougou M, Simard F, Baldet T, Diabaté A, Ouédraogo JB, Martin T, et al. Multiple insecticide resistance in Anopheles gambiae s.l. populations from Burkina Faso. West Africa PLoS One. 2012;7:e48412.
N’Guessan R, Corbel V, Akogbéto M, Rowland M. Reduced efficacy of insecticide-treated nets and indoor residual spraying for malaria control in pyrethroid resistance area. Benin Emerg Infect Dis. 2007;13:199–206.
Toé KH, Jones CM, N’Fale S, Ismail HM, Dabiré RK, Ranson H. Increased pyrethroid resistance in malaria vectors and decreased bed net effectiveness. Burkina Faso Emerg Infect Dis. 2014;20:1691–6.
The Global Plan for Insecticide Resistance Management in Malaria Vectors (GPIRM). http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/atoz/gpirm/en/.
List of WHO prequalified vector control products. https://www.who.int/pq-vector-control/prequalified-lists/VCP_PQ-List_26August2020.pdf?ua=1. Accessed 26 Aug 2020.
Moores GD, Philippou D, Borzatta V, Trincia P, Jewess P, Gunning R, et al. An analogue of piperonyl butoxide facilitates the characterisation of metabolic resistance. Pest Manag Sci. 2009;65:150–4.
Tungu P, Magesa S, Maxwell C, Malima R, Masue D, Sudi W, et al. Evaluation of PermaNet 3.0 a deltamethrin-PBO combination net against Anopheles gambiae and pyrethroid resistant Culex quinquefasciatus mosquitoes: an experimental hut trial in Tanzania. Malar J. 2010;9:21.
Protopopoff N, Mosha JF, Lukole E, Charlwood JD, Wright A, Mwalimu CD, et al. Effectiveness of a long-lasting piperonyl butoxide-treated insecticidal net and indoor residual spray interventions, separately and together, against malaria transmitted by pyrethroid-resistant mosquitoes: a cluster, randomised controlled, two-by-two factorial design trial. Lancet. 2018;391:1577–88.
Staedke SG, Gonahasa S, Dorsey G, Kamya MR, Maiteki-Sebuguzi C, Lynd A, et al. Effect of long-lasting insecticidal nets with and without piperonyl butoxide on malaria indicators in Uganda (LLINEUP): a pragmatic, cluster-randomised trial embedded in a national LLIN distribution campaign. Lancet. 2020;395:1292–303.
Oxborough RM, N’Guessan R, Jones R, Kitau J, Ngufor C, Malone D, et al. The activity of the pyrrole insecticide chlorfenapyr in mosquito bioassay: towards a more rational testing and screening of non-neurotoxic insecticides for malaria vector control. Malar J. 2015;14:124.
N’Guessan R, Boko P, Odjo A, Akogbéto M, Yates A, Rowland M. Chlorfenapyr: a pyrrole insecticide for the control of pyrethroid or DDT resistant Anopheles gambiae (Diptera: Culicidae) mosquitoes. Acta Trop. 2007;102:69–78.
N’Guessan R, Odjo A, Ngufor C, Malone D, Rowland M. A chlorfenapyr mixture net Interceptor® G2 shows high efficacy and wash durability against resistant mosquitoes in West Africa. PLoS ONE. 2016;11:e0165925.
Bayili K, N’do S, Namountougou M, Sanou R, Ouattara A, Dabiré RK, et al. Evaluation of efficacy of Interceptor® G2, a long-lasting insecticide net coated with a mixture of chlorfenapyr and alpha-cypermethrin, against pyrethroid resistant Anopheles gambiae s.l. in Burkina Faso. Malar J. 2017;16:190.
Camara S, Ahoua Alou LP, Koffi AA, Clegban YCM, Kabran JP, Koffi FM, et al. Efficacy of Interceptor® G2, a new long-lasting insecticidal net against wild pyrethroid-resistant Anopheles gambiae s.s. from Côte d’Ivoire: a semi-field trial. Parasite. 2018;25:42.
WHO. Test procedures for insecticide resistance monitoring in malaria vector mosquitoes. 2nd ed. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2016.
Santolamazza F, Mancini E, Simard F, Qi Y, Tu Z, della Torre A. Insertion polymorphisms of SINE200 retrotransposons within speciation islands of Anopheles gambiae molecular forms. Malar J. 2008;7:163.
Martinez-Torres D, Chandre F, Williamson MS, Darriet F, Bergé JB, Devonshire AL, et al. Molecular characterization of pyrethroid knockdown resistance (kdr) in the major malaria vector Anopheles gambiae s.s. Insect Mol Biol. 1998;7:179–84.
Finney DJ. Probit analysis. 3rd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1971.
Rousset F, Raymond M. Testing heterozygote excess and deficiency. Genetics. 1995;140:1413–9.
Long-lasting insecticidal net (LLIN) price data. https://www.unicef.org/supply/reports/long-lasting-insecticidal-net-llin-price-data. Accessed 2 May 2021.
Toe KH, Müller P, Badolo A, Traore A, Sagnon N, Dabiré RK, et al. Do bednets including piperonyl butoxide offer additional protection against populations of Anopheles gambiae s.l. that are highly resistant to pyrethroids? An experimental hut evaluation in Burkina Fasov. Med Vet Entomol. 2018;32:407–16.
Bayili K, N’Do S, Yadav RS, Namountougou M, Ouattara A, Dabiré RK, et al. Experimental hut evaluation of DawaPlus 3.0 LN and DawaPlus 4.0 LN treated with deltamethrin and PBO against free-flying populations of Anopheles gambiae s.l. in Vallée du Kou. Burkina Faso PLoS One. 2019;14:e0226191.
Conditions for deployment of mosquito nets treated with a pyrethroid and piperonyl butoxide. http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/258939/WHO-HTM-GMP-2017.17-eng.pdf?sequence=5. Accessed 18 Mar 2018.
U.S. President’s malaria initiative FY 2020 guidance. https://www.pmi.gov/pmi-technical-guidance-5/. Accessed 3 Sept 2020.
Namountougou M, Diabaté A, Etang J, Bass C, Sawadogo SP, Gnankinié O, et al. First report of the L1014S kdr mutation in wild populations of Anopheles gambiae M and S molecular forms in Burkina Faso (West Africa). Acta Trop. 2013;125:123–7.
Kwiatkowska RM, Platt N, Poupardin R, Irving H, Dabire RK, Mitchell S, et al. Dissecting the mechanisms responsible for the multiple insecticide resistance phenotype in Anopheles gambiae s.s., M form, from Vallée du Kou Burkina Faso. Gene. 2013;519:98–106.
Kouassi BL, Edi C, Tia E, Konan LY, Akré MA, Koffi AA, et al. Susceptibility of Anopheles gambiae from Côte d’Ivoire to insecticides used on insecticide-treated nets: evaluating the additional entomological impact of piperonyl butoxide and chlorfenapyr. Malar J. 2020;19:454.
Riveron JM, Huijben S, Tchapga W, Tchouakui M, Wondji MJ, Tchoupo M, et al. Escalation of pyrethroid resistance in the malaria vector Anopheles funestus induces a loss of efficacy of piperonyl butoxide-based insecticide-treated nets in Mozambique. J Infect Dis. 2019;220:467–75.
Black BC, Hollingworth RM, Ahmmadsahib KI, Kukel CD, Donovan S. Insecticidal action and mitochondrial uncoupling activity of AC-303,630 and related halogenated pyrroles. Pest Biochem Physiol. 1994;50:115–28.
Building a stronger line of defense against malaria. https://agriculture.basf.com/en/Pest-Control/Commitment-to-Public-Health/The-New-Nets-Project.html. Accessed 25 May 2021.
Our sincere thanks go to residents of the different regional heath directors and collaborators for their support during the sample collections. Our gratitude also goes to the fieldworkers for their hard work.
The findings and conclusions in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official position of U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, USAID or PMI.
This study was supported by the United States President’s Malaria Initiative through the United States Agency for International Development funded VectorLink Project.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Study sites distributed in three eco-climatical areas with different agricultural practices.
Temperature and humidity conditions of WHO susceptibility and CDC bottle bioassays.
Synergist assays using pyrethroid insecticides and piperonyl butoxide data.
CDC bottle assays using 100ug chlorfenapyr data.
About this article
Cite this article
Hien, A.S., Soma, D.D., Maiga, S. et al. Evidence supporting deployment of next generation insecticide treated nets in Burkina Faso: bioassays with either chlorfenapyr or piperonyl butoxide increase mortality of pyrethroid-resistant Anopheles gambiae. Malar J 20, 406 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12936-021-03936-3
- Insecticide resistance
- Piperonyl butoxide
- Anopheles gambiae
- Insecticide-treated net
- Burkina Faso