- Open Access
Genetic evidence that the Makira region in northeastern Madagascar is a hotspot of malaria transmission
Malaria Journal volume 15, Article number: 596 (2016)
Encouraging advances in the control of Plasmodium falciparum malaria have been observed across much of Africa in the past decade. However, regions of high relative prevalence and transmission that remain unaddressed or unrecognized provide a threat to this progress. Difficulties in identifying such localized hotspots include inadequate surveillance, especially in remote regions, and the cost and labor needed to produce direct estimates of transmission. Genetic data can provide a much-needed alternative to such empirical estimates, as the pattern of genetic variation within malaria parasite populations is indicative of the level of local transmission. Here, genetic data were used to provide the first empirical estimates of P. falciparum malaria prevalence and transmission dynamics for the rural, remote Makira region of northeastern Madagascar.
Longitudinal surveys of a cohort of 698 total individuals (both sexes, 0–74 years of age) were performed in two communities bordering the Makira Natural Park protected area. Rapid diagnostic tests, with confirmation by molecular methods, were used to estimate P. falciparum prevalence at three seasonal time points separated by 4-month intervals. Genomic loci in a panel of polymorphic, putatively neutral markers were genotyped for 94 P. falciparum infections and used to characterize genetic parameters known to correlate with transmission levels.
Overall, 27.8% of individuals tested positive for P. falciparum over the 10-month course of the study, a rate approximately sevenfold higher than the countrywide average for Madagascar. Among those P. falciparum infections, a high level of genotypic diversity and a high frequency of polygenomic infections (68.1%) were observed, providing a pattern consistent with high and stable transmission.
Prevalence and genetic diversity data indicate that the Makira region is a hotspot of P. falciparum transmission in Madagascar. This suggests that the area should be highlighted for future interventions and that additional areas of high transmission may be present in ecologically similar regions nearby.
Approximately 300,000 cases of Plasmodium falciparum malaria are recorded annually in Madagascar, an incidence rate that, at the reported level, places Madagascar and its population of 24.9 million among the lower tier of African countries in terms of malaria burden . Updated estimates of transmission across Africa based on large databases of field surveys and sophisticated model-based geostatistics are now available and are less dependent on clinical reporting. These model-based estimates indicate that the number of reported cases in Madagascar is likely a large underestimate of the true burden, but still rank Madagascar as a low transmission setting relative to much of mainland Africa .
Contrasting with these low estimates for Madagascar are recent longitudinal and cross-sectional cohort studies that have repeatedly found localities with transmission and prevalence rates 3- to 10-fold higher than the national average (for example, see [3–5]). Further, these estimates are comparable with recognized high transmission areas globally. The localities of higher transmission and prevalence observed in Madagascar were often found in rural areas in the eastern part of the country, which is primarily characterized by lowland tropical rainforest. For example, prevalence of P. falciparum was 20.5% in a cohort of pregnant women reporting to antenatal clinics near Manakara  and varied temporally from 19.7 to 35.2% among adults in the Alaotra-Mangoro region . For comparison, the average prevalence estimated from monitoring sentinel health sites was 3.1% nationally and peaked at 4.9% in the eastern part of the country . Additionally, transmission was found to be newly increasing in some areas of eastern Madagascar, with a large outbreak in the Vatovavy-Fitovinany and Atsimo-Atsinanana regions in 2011–2012 as an example .
In terms of malaria transmission, Madagascar is typically divided into four to five zones based on broad climatic and demographic regions: the south, the eastern coast, the western coast, the high central plateau and sometimes with the margins/periphery of the high plateau included as a separate zone [7, 9, 10]. Transmission rates have been found to be highest along the eastern coast (4.9–11.7%) or the western coast (4.6–14.3%), with estimates varying with the age group and seasonality of sampling [7, 9].
The continued reports of localized areas of elevated transmission, sometimes termed foci [11, 12] or hotspots , which far exceed those national or regional level estimates suggest that monitoring efforts, and progress in reducing the burden of malaria, have been unevenly distributed. If unaddressed, such hotspots have the potential to undermine the effect of the recent scaling-up of malaria control in Madagascar [13, 14]. Given the historical context of low intervention coverage and low funding for interventions in Madagascar in comparison to other African countries [1, 15, 16], identifying such hotspots of transmission is also valuable in order to efficiently direct resources to the areas where scale-up is most urgently needed. However, to do this, a better understanding of both the geographic distribution and transmission dynamics of such hotspots within Madagascar is required.
In terms of geographic distribution, a majority of the cohort studies that have measured malaria transmission and prevalence were performed in the southern parts of eastern Madagascar and, although the areas are climatically similar, it is unknown if comparable results are to be expected in the Northeast. Additionally, much of the population of the Northeast lives in rural and remote forested districts that are not well monitored by national surveillance efforts [3, 9].
In terms of transmission dynamics, it is also unknown if local hotspots within Madagascar are the result of short-term spikes in transmission triggered by transient changes in ecological or epidemiological conditions, or are due temporally stable transmission. Genetic data can be of great utility in discriminating between the two transmission scenarios without the need for labor-intensive direct estimates of transmission. The discrimination is possible because different levels of transmission intensity and stability are expected to produce different patterns of genetic variation in the Plasmodium parasite population [17–19]. Specifically, high, stable transmission is expected to result in a diverse assemblage of parasite genomes circulating locally, and a high percentage of infections that contain multiple, distinct P. falciparum genomes concurrently (termed polygenomic infections). On the other hand, in situations with low or sporadic transmission, few hosts on average are expected to encounter multiple, distinct P. falciparum multi-locus genotypes (MLGs) during the course of an infection, reducing the proportion of infections that are polygenomic. As a result, when transmission is unstable, opportunities for re-assortment and recombination between parasite MLGs are rare and few distinct MLGs circulate. Sporadic outbreaks, although capable of infecting a large percentage of the population when they do occur, are then expected to be composed of relatively few MLGs (albeit with some at potentially high frequency).
Here, the observation of an apparent hotspot of malaria prevalence in northeastern Madagascar is reported and a pattern of genetic variation consistent with high, stable transmission observed. This is inferred from rapid diagnostic test (RDT) surveys and single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping of 94 P. falciparum positive samples from a prospective cohort study of 698 individuals living in the remote Makira region. These data highlight the need for greater monitoring of a previously understudied area in Madagascar and provide a baseline against which future interventions can be measured.
Study sites and study population
The Makira region is a large rural area mostly within the Analanjirofo administrative region (faritra) in northeastern Madagascar. It contains the protected Makira Natural Park (372,470 ha) and buffer zones (350,000 ha) in the surrounding low- and medium-altitude forest . The park and buffer zones combined have an area of approximately 722,000 hectares and support a population of more than 127,000 people . This area has been previously studied as a part of an effort to understand linkages between the conservation of its extraordinary biodiversity and human health (for e.g., see [20, 22]). Communities in the Makira region consist of small, dense clusters of approximately 50–200 households. Two communities (fokontany) were selected. For the privacy of study participants, the names of these communities are withheld per the recommendations of the ethical body that reviewed the study and in accordance with previous studies that have been performed in these communities . See Fig. 1 for the approximate geographic locations. The two communities are separated by 7.2 km; however, community 2 is at a notably higher elevation (350 m) than community 1 (20 m). Neither community has road access and the distance to the nearest reporting sentinel health site (see Ref. ) is 23–32 km. Households were randomly selected within the communities. All individuals in 97 and 57 households, in community 1 and community 2, respectively, were enrolled for a total of 698 individuals.
Ethical approval was given by the Madagascar Ministry of Health and the Office for the Protection of Human Subjects at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health (IRB 22826). Approval for the study was also sought and obtained from the Maroantsetra regional medical inspector, the mayor covering the region including both communities, and the leader (president-fokontany) in each community. All adults provided informed consent for themselves and surrogate consent for infants and children, while other older children provided assent prior to interaction with the local research staff.
For each individual, a blood sample was obtained by venous blood draw, or by finger-prick or heel-prick in a few cases for younger children. Five microlitres of blood were added to an RDT and approximately 200 ml of blood were added to an FTA card (Whatman FTA Classic, GE Healthcare, Marlborough, MA, USA, cat. no. WB120312) to preserve DNA for later genetic analyses. The RDTs used were: First Response® Combo Pf/Pan (Premier Medical Corporation Limited, Kachigam, UT, India, cat. no. I 16 FRC), CareStart® Pf/Pan (ACCESS BIO, Inc., Somerset, NJ, USA, cat. no. G0131), and SD BIOLINE® Pf/Pan (Standard Diagnostics, Gyeonggi-do, Korea, cat. no. 05FK60)—all of which used the antigens HRP2 and pLDH. All individuals testing positive by RDT were offered treatment with the standard first-line treatment (artesunate + amodiaquine, AS + AQ). Blood spots on FTA cards were allowed to dry and then stored at ambient temperature with desiccant in plastic bags.
Individuals were sampled at up to three time points: time point 1 (July/August 2013), time point 2 (November/December 2013), and time point 3 (March/April 2014). These sampling times correspond to the medium, low and high seasons of rainfall in the area, respectively. The number of individuals with a valid RDT result varied from 495 to 660 per time point; 698 individuals had an RDT result for at least one time point and 408 had an RDT result for all three time points.
DNA extraction and molecular detection of Plasmodium species
For a randomly chosen subset (n = 166) of the samples positive by RDT for P. falciparum, DNA was extracted from the corresponding dried blood spots using the DNA IQ™ Casework Pro for Maxwell® 16 kit. Following DNA extraction, real-time PCR (RT-PCR) assays for P. falciparum, Plasmodium vivax, Plasmodium malariae, and Plasmodium ovale were performed in order to confirm the presence of Plasmodium parasite genetic material. The assay for P. falciparum was as described previously , while the assays for the other three species followed a similar protocol targeting the conserved plasmepsin gene . Plasmodium falciparum, P. vivax, P. malariae, and P. ovale are known to be distributed throughout Madagascar, although P. falciparum is estimated to account for 96% of cases . Assessing the agreement between RDT results and molecular detection of Plasmodium species is warranted, as the specificity of RDTs is known to be variable, especially if multiple Plasmodium species are present [25–28].
Genetic sampling: SNP-genotyping analysis
For the confirmed P. falciparum infections, alleles from a panel of 24 putatively neutral and unlinked genomic loci were typed to produce multi-locus genotypes (MLGs) . Twelve or more loci were typed for 94 samples (see “Results” section). These loci and the SNP-genotyping protocol used have been termed a P. falciparum “molecular barcode” and are described elsewhere [18, 23, 29, 30]. The loci are distributed on 12 of the 14 P. falciparum chromosomes (see Additional file 1: Table S1) and are identical to those of Daniels et al. . Briefly, the presence of a variant allele at the targeted locus causes a difference in the melting temperature of an RT-PCR probe that can be detected using high-resolution melting (HRM) analysis. If, for a sample, two alleles are present at the probed locus, two melting peaks, corresponding to the two alleles present, are observed. As Plasmodium parasites are haploid in the bloodstream stage of their life cycle, observing two alleles for a locus indicates that multiple distinct parasite genomes were present in the host at the time of sampling. Such infections are reported as polygenomic infections. To be conservative, and consistent with previous conventions, an infection is reported as polygenomic if at least two of the loci analyzed for that sample exhibit the two melting peaks indicative of two alleles present [18, 23].
As the concentration of parasite DNA in blood samples can be quite low relative to other co-infecting parasites, or relative to host DNA, a pre-amplification step was performed prior to SNP-genotyping. Pre-amplification was previously shown to increase the success rate and sensitivity of SNP-genotyping (method same as used in Ref. ).
Genetic correlates of transmission
Two genetic parameters hypothesized to reflect transmission dynamics and empirically shown to co-vary with transmission intensity are (1) the percentage of infections that are polygenomic and (2) the frequency distribution of MLGs [18, 19]. When transmission is low or unstable, fewer distinct MLGs are present locally and more individuals contain a MLG identical to one that has already been sampled. This leads to some MLGs being observed at elevated frequencies within the sample. In contrast, at higher and more stable transmission levels, few infections contain repeatedly observed MLGs.
Estimating minor allele frequencies and resolution
In order to evaluate the resolution of our genetic sampling, we first estimated the minor allele frequency (MAF) at each of the 24 loci. To account for the fact that polygenomic samples were present and that the multiplicity of infection within polygenomic samples was unknown, a form of the “predominant allele” approach was used . For polygenomic samples, those loci where multiple alleles were present were not considered, but the loci where only one allele was observed (indicating that the MLGs forming the polygenomic infection had the same allele at the locus) were considered. Tallying predominant alleles has the advantage of allowing the alleles in polygenomic infection samples (which can be a large proportion of the sample) to be taken into consideration when determining MAF. This approach has also been empirically shown to correlate closely with other measures of allele frequency [32, 33], but does include an assumption that allele frequencies at the observed “monogenomic” loci are not strongly biased.
Assuming alleles at a locus are neutral and segregate independently, the probability that two unrelated parasite lineages would be observed to have the same allele by chance is given by MAF2 + (1 − MAF)2. For multiple loci, the probability of observing an identical MLG by chance (identity by state, IBS) is simply the product of IBS probabilities for each locus. As the average MAF for the loci analysed approaches its maximum of 0.5 (indicating 50% of the samples have the alternate allele), the number of loci required for a significant level of resolution decreases. Using a significance cut-off of α = 0.01 and the derived estimate of the MAF for each locus, the number of loci needed to have a significantly small probability (i.e., <0.01) of randomly observing identical MLGs was determined if: (1) the loci with the highest observed MAFs were used, or (2) the loci with the lowest observed MAFs were used. For (1) and (2), these represent the fewest and the most loci needed, respectively, to achieve the chosen level of confidence given the observed MAFs.
Estimating multi-locus genotype frequencies and genetic similarity
To identify any samples with identical MLGs and to estimate the genetic similarity among samples, pairwise percent identity was calculated (using a Python script, available upon request) for all samples and for subsets of samples of interest. For polygenomic infections, we calculated genetic similarity among the P. falciparum MLGs within the infection as the proportion of typed loci for that infection that shared the same allele. To account for differences in the number of pairwise comparisons used to calculate mean genetic similarity for different subsets of samples, bootstrap resampling was used to test for significance with subsamples equal in size to the number of comparisons made in the smallest subset (in R, script available upon request). P values are reported as the proportion of subsamples of a given size that had a mean within the standard error of the mean of the other subset of samples.
High prevalence of P. falciparum infection by RDT
For both communities, prevalence by RDT varied temporally, from a low of 5.7–10.1% in July–August to a high of 17–18% in March–April for each community (see Fig. 2). Overall, 26.3 and 29.9% of individuals for community 1 and community 2, respectively, tested positive for P. falciparum by RDT during the course of the 10-month follow-up. For both communities combined, there were 504 individuals (72.2%) with a negative P. falciparum RDT result at all three time points. Among individuals with a positive RDT result, 169 (24.2%), 20 (2.9%), 4 (0.6%), and 1 (0.1%) individuals were positive at one time point, two consecutive time points, two nonconsecutive time points, and all three time points, respectively. Among children under five, 34 of 134 children sampled (25.4%) were RDT positive. At the household level, 63.0% of households had at least one member of the household test positive for P. falciparum by RDT.
For the randomly chosen subset (n = 166) of the samples positive by RDT for P. falciparum that were analysed, the presence of P. falciparum was identified by RT-PCR in 88% of the samples. This supports general agreement between RDT and RT-PCR results and is comparable to other analyses of RT-PCR and RDT concordance in Madagascar (e.g. 79.5% in the national 2013 Malaria Indicator Survey ). Possible explanations for the 12% of RDT positive samples that were not positive for P. falciparum by RT-PCR include: (1) false positive RDTs, (2) a failure to preserve DNA between the time of sampling and the later RT-PCR analysis for some samples, (3) failed RT-PCR reactions and (4) infections due to other Plasmodium species. Apart from P. falciparum, two samples were positive for P. vivax by RT-PCR, one from each community at the third time point. The P. vivax positive sample from community 1 was also positive for P. falciparum and thus a mixed-species infection. Furthermore, two samples from community 1 were positive for P. malariae. The P. malariae sample from time point 1 was found to also harbour a polygenomic infection of P. falciparum. This sample was therefore both a mixed-species infection as well as a complex P. falciparum infection (see more discussion of polygenomic P. falciparum infections below).
Frequency of polygenomic infections
In addition to observing high prevalence, we also observed that a high frequency of infections were polygenomic (68.1%) among the 94 P. falciparum infections that were typed at 12 or more loci (see Table 1; Additional file 2). This observation was replicated across communities, across time points, across sexes, and across subjects’ age groups (range 59.6–79.5%). The percentage of infections found to be polygenomic was also similar among the samples typed at 12–17 loci (68.5%) and the samples that were typed at 18 or more loci (66.7%). The number of SNP positions that were polymorphic within infections (i.e. polygenomic) ranged from 0 to 11. The mean and median number of polymorphic loci among polygenomic samples was 3.95 and 3, respectively.
Although the frequency of polygenomic infections was higher in community 2 (79.4%) than in community 1 (61.7%), this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.612, Fisher exact test for count data). Neither was the difference between polygenomic infection frequency among males (78.0%) and females (59.6%) (p = 0.075) or that between any pair of time points (p > 0.05). The failure to observe a significant difference between time points is notable, as rainfall differs fourfold between time points 2 and 3 and prevalence was observed to change approximately threefold between time points 1 and 3. These data indicate that some factor other than precipitation drives temporal changes in prevalence and that the frequency of polygenomic infections may be seasonally stable.
SNP allele frequency and validation
In order to permit downstream genetic analysis, it was first validated that the loci assayed were polymorphic. Then the number of loci needed for a given level of resolution in distinguishing parasite MLGs was estimated. All 24 loci analysed were found to be polymorphic, with a high MAF on average (mean MAF 0.310, range 0.083–0.500). The alleles and allele frequencies for each locus are shown in Additional file 1: Table S1. The mean number of loci typed per sample was 15.6, with a range from 12 to 22 loci (see below for the use of 12 loci as the minimum cut-off). For no sample were all 24 loci typed, but MAF was calculated from a mean of 61.3 samples per locus for all 24 loci (range 15–87). Loci A6 and A10, with alleles being callable from only 15 and 16 samples each, respectively, had significantly lower reporting rates than the other loci. Inefficient binding of primers or probes for these loci, possibly due to a variant sequence circulating in the population, may explain the lower number of samples successfully typed for these loci.
From the allele frequency data, and assuming independence, we determined the mean number of loci needed for the probability to be <0.01 for observing an identical MLG for unrelated parasite genomes (see Fig. 3). If two parasite genomes were compared at only the loci with the highest observed MAF (and thus the highest resolution), then only seven loci would be needed. Conversely, comparing the parasite genomes at the loci with the lowest MAFs would require typing at five additional loci (12 total) to have the same level of resolution. To be conservative, our analyses subsequently focused on the samples for which 12 or more loci were genotyped (n = 94).
Frequency distribution of multi-locus genotypes: limited evidence of repeat multi-locus genotypes observed between infections
After validating that the loci analyzed could provide a sufficiently high probability of distinguishing unrelated parasite lineages, the frequency of occurrence for the MLGs in the sample set was characterized. The observed MLGs of all samples were compared in all possible pairs, and the samples with the fewest pairwise genetic differences were analyzed further. Notably, there were no instances in which the same MLG was found to be present in more than one individual in our sample. For one individual (individual 1.68.02, see Additional file 2), an identical MLG was observed at consecutive time points. While treatment was offered and provided after a positive RDT result, it is possible that the treatment failed to clear parasites from the bloodstream or was not adhered to by the individual. As a result, we find it more likely that this represents the persistence of a single infection between time points and not a separate infection of this individual with an identical MLG. MLGs were generated at multiple time points for seven other individuals and in each case differed at multiple loci.
Among polygenomic infections, in comparisons between three samples (2.33.04.2, 2.33.08.2, and 1.92.01.2, see Additional file 2), one or more samples were polygenomic but did not exhibit any differences among the loci for which both samples had a single allele. For these cases, it is possible that the MLGs contributing to the polygenomic infection have the same allelic configuration as one present in the other sample. Regardless, such a situation arose in only a small number of comparisons. Due to the lack of definitive instances where independent infections contained identical MLGs, these data strongly indicate that the pattern of repeated clusters of identical MLGs expected from low or sporadic transmission  is not present in the Makira region.
Genetic similarity among polygenomic infections
In order to investigate levels of genetic similarity among the parasite lineages within polygenomic infections, the proportion of loci that differed within polygenomic infections was compared to the average number of differences between randomly selected monogenomic infections. As seen in Fig. 4, a small number of polygenomic infections had significantly fewer shared loci than the average pairwise identity for all monogenomic samples. A possible explanation is that these exceptionally variable polygenomic infections contain more than two parasite MLGs, which would reduce the number of alleles shared by all parasite genomes present in the infection. Despite these few outliers, the distribution of genetic similarity among polygenomic infections was significantly skewed towards higher levels of genetic similarity in comparison to that among monogenomic samples (p < 0.0001, bootstrap subsampling to correct for differences in the number of comparisons, see Additional file 3: Figure S1). This result suggests that parasite genomes in polygenomic infections are genetically more closely related than would be expected, and it is consistent with the co-transmission of multiple, related parasites by the bite of a single infectious vector. It is also noteworthy that no significant difference was observed in the average pairwise similarity between all monogenomic samples from community 1 or community 2. Hence this metric suggests an absence of parasite population structure at the community level.
Plasmodium falciparum is prevalent and genetically diverse in the Makira region
Prevalence of P. falciparum was 5.7–17.6% at each time point for both sites studied, with 27.8% of individuals and more than 60% of households having at least one positive result over the course of the study. Notably, prevalence in both communities, even at its lowest point (5.7%), was higher than the highest prevalence captured by a recent analysis of national sentinel health sites located in eastern Madagascar (4.9%) . Additionally, the observed prevalence among children under 5 years old seen here (25.4%) was much higher than that found in the national 2013 Malaria Indicator Survey study of 1725 children in eastern Madagascar in the same age group (11.7%) . These observations of prevalence and incidence indicate that transmission frequency, and hence the burden of P. falciparum, is much higher at the two sites than would be expected from previous estimates based on regional and national surveillance in Madagascar [1, 2, 7, 35].
Apart from the two study sites, approximately 127,000 people live in the Makira region, all in rural settings with comparable ecological conditions. Additionally, an estimated 86.8% of the 1 million people living in the broader Analanjirofo administrative region (containing the Makira region) also live within similar rural districts . Further, the Analanjirofo region is just one of four such large regions in northeastern Madagascar, which together have a population of over 4.4 million . Accordingly, if the prevalence pattern we observed applies widely across communities/fokontany in the area and the northeastern regions, then this part of Madagascar would be expected to be a significant contributor to the national malaria burden (estimated at a total of 750,000–2,100,000 cases annually ). The policy implications are significant; it is possible that government surveillance has focused on coastal and peri-urban sites that are easier to access, or has relied on clinic-based statistics, which may be misleading for remote regions.
An alternative possibility is that the prevalence and incidence seen at the two Makira region sites studied here merely reflects a transient spike. This possibility seems unlikely, because if transmission were sporadic and we simply happened to observe a temporary, unstable peak in transmission in this study, then a pattern of low diversity, frequently repeated MLGs, and fewer polygenomic infections would be expected in the genetic data. In settings of low, unstable transmission, sometimes termed clonal transmission, few MLGs predominate and the reshuffling of those MLGs by recombination or re-assortment is rare. This pattern of clonal transmission has been observed in locations at the periphery of P. falciparum transmission such as Panama  and in areas of Africa and Asia after interventions have successfully reduced transmission [18, 19].
The pattern observed here is the opposite, as we see very limited evidence of repeated MLGs and a high frequency of polygenomic infections for all subgroups of the sample set (see Table 1). The frequency of polygenomic infections observed in the Makira region was similar, or even higher, than that seen in other high transmission, pre-intervention settings (some examples from studies using SNP-genotyping shown in Table 2).
These indicate that the localities in the Makira region studied here are currently unrecognized foci of high transmission and signal the possibility that other such localities exist in Madagascar. In addition to representing a previously unrecognized source of malaria burden, these localities might serve as sources of reintroduction to areas where interruption of transmission has seen progress. For instance, since the early 1990s the malaria burden has fallen substantially in much of the interior, central plateau of Madagascar [9, 36–39]. Unmonitored hotspots could provide refuges for parasite lineages that could later spillover and compromise these gains. Moreover, recent reports suggest that the burden of malaria has indeed risen broadly since 2011 . This highlights the need for further research and greater surveillance of northeastern Madagascar, and other remote regions currently lacking comprehensive surveillance. Such efforts could determine the extent to which neighboring areas and larger regions also contain foci of elevated prevalence and transmission.
Potential confounding effects of co-transmission and spatial heterogeneity
Two potential confounding effects that may limit our ability to infer relative levels of transmission from the frequency of polygenomic infections are co-transmission and small-scale spatial heterogeneity in transmission intensity. Co-transmission, where multiple parasite MLGs are taken up by the same mosquito vector and transmitted to the next host, is a mechanism by which polygenomic infections can result from a single transmission event. If co-transmission is common, then the probability of observing polygenomic infections is less dependent on the number of transmission events. Likewise, high spatial heterogeneity in transmission could also cause an increase in the frequency of polygenomic infections without an increase in the number of transmission events by concentrating transmission events in a subset of the population. Hosts within the subset would have a higher probability of being reinfected during the course of an infection and thus more polygenomic infections would be produced.
If these two confounders were present in this study, then it would be expected to see (1) a higher average level of genetic similarity among polygenomic infections than between monogenomic infections and (2) evidence that P. falciparum infection was not randomly distributed among the sample population. For co-transmission, serial co-passage of two parasite lineages would provide those lineages with multiple opportunities to recombine with each other. It would be expected that repeated recombination between the parasite genomes would result in progeny with MLGs that were more similar to each other than for parasites that had not recombined as often. Accordingly, if co-transmission were prevalent, it would be expected that the average similarity among the MLGs comprising polygenomic infections would be higher than the average similarity between MLGs chosen randomly from the population. Conversely, if polygenomic infections arose from superinfection (the re-infection of an infected host), then it would be expected that the average similarity among polygenomic infections would be similar to the average between MLGs randomly chosen from the population. Genetic similarity among polygenomic infections was significantly higher than the average between monogenomic infections, consistent with the presence of co-transmission.
As evidence against unusually extreme spatial heterogeneity in our sample, a high percentage (63.0%) of households contained an individual infected at one time point or more. Additionally, there was no evidence that genetic similarity was partitioned between communities. It seems more likely that co-transmission and/or spatial heterogeneity are widespread phenomena in P. falciparum populations and therefore their effect is accounted for when comparing populations. Further study of co-transmission and spatial heterogeneity, especially in Madagascar, would serve to better characterize this relationship.
Despite the abundance of estimates for low to moderate levels of malaria transmission on average regionally and countrywide, we show evidence that the Makira region in northeastern Madagascar is a hotspot of malaria transmission. First, RDT surveys, with RT-PCR confirmation generally validating the results, were performed and an overall level of infection approximately sevenfold higher than the national average and 2 to fivefold higher than existing regional estimates was observed. Next, a panel of SNP markers was validated as variable and informative in Madagascar, and these SNPs were used to estimate the allele and MLG frequencies as well as the frequency of polygenomic infections. A pattern consistent with high, stable transmission was observed. Because few previous studies of P. falciparum genetic diversity in Madagascar have been performed, the identification of variable markers, the estimates of minor allele frequencies, and the calculation of the number of loci needed for a given level of resolution will be useful in future studies. Such studies are needed to better define the relative contributions of co-transmission and small-scale spatial heterogeneity to patterns of parasite genetic diversity. Remaining hotspots of P. falciparum transmission pose a threat to the recent gains in malaria control in Madagascar, and across Africa, and a better understanding of the genetic correlates of transmission can provide a better method for their identification and monitoring.
- Faritra :
the largest administrative regions of Madagascar
rapid diagnostic test
single nucleotide polymorphism
real-time polymerase chain reaction
high resolution melting
minor allele frequency
identity by state
WHO. World Malaria Report 2015. Madagascar. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2015. http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/country-profiles/profile_mdg_en.pdf?ua=1. Accessed 5 May 2016.
Bhatt S, Weiss DJ, Cameron E, Bisanzio D, Mappin B, Dalrymple U, et al. The effect of malaria control on Plasmodium falciparum in Africa between 2000 and 2015. Nature. 2015;526:207–11.
Robert V, Le Goff G, Andrianaivolambo L, Randimby FM, Domarle O, Randrianarivelojosia M, et al. Moderate transmission but high prevalence of malaria in Madagascar. Int J Parasitol. 2006;36:1273–81.
Marrama L, Jambou R, Rakotoarivony I, Leong Pock Tsi JM, Duchemin JB, Laventure S, et al. Malaria transmission in Southern Madagascar: influence of the environment and hydro-agricultural works in sub-arid and humid regions. Part 1. Entomological investigations. Acta Trop. 2004;89:193–203.
Maïga-Ascofaré O, Rakotozandrindrainy R, Girmann M, Hahn A, Randriamampionona N, Poppert S, et al. Molecular epidemiology and seroprevalence in asymptomatic Plasmodium falciparum infections of Malagasy pregnant women in the highlands. Malar J. 2015;14:188.
Rabarijaona LP, Randrianarivelojosia M, Raharimalala LA, Ratsimbasoa A, Randriamanantena A, Randrianasolo L, et al. Longitudinal survey of malaria morbidity over 10 years in Saharevo (Madagascar): further lessons for strengthening malaria control. Malar J. 2009;8:190.
Kesteman T, Randrianarivelojosia M, Mattern C, Raboanary E, Pourette D, Girond F, et al. Nationwide evaluation of malaria infections, morbidity, mortality, and coverage of malaria control interventions in Madagascar. Malar J. 2014;13:465.
Kesteman T, Rafalimanantsoa SA, Razafimandimby H, Rasamimanana HH, Raharimanga V, Ramarosandratana B, et al. Multiple causes of an unexpected malaria outbreak in a high-transmission area in Madagascar. Malar J. 2016;15:57.
MIS 2013: Institut National de la Statistique (INSTAT), Programme National de lutte contre le Paludisme (PNLP), Institut Pasteur de Madagascar (IPM) et ICF International. Enquête sur les Indicateurs du Paludisme (EIPM). Calverton: INSTAT, PNLP, IPM et ICF International; 2013.
Mouchet J, Blanchy S. Particularities and stratification of malaria in Madagascar. Sante. 1995;5:386–8.
WHO. Global malaria control and elimination: report of a technical review. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2008. http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/atoz/9789241596756/en/. Accessed 5 May 2016.
Ruktannonchai NW, DeLeenheer P, Tamem AJ, Alegana VA, Caughlin TT, Zu Erbach-Schoenberg E, et al. Identifying malaria transmission foci for elimination using human mobility data. PLoS Comput Biol. 2016;12:e1004846.
Bousema T, Drakeley C, Gesase S, Hashim R, Magesa S, Mosha F, et al. Identification of hotspots of malaria transmission for targeted malaria control. J Infect Dis. 2010;201:1764–74.
Ministère de la Santé Publique, Programme National de Lutte contre le Paludisme. Revue du programme paludisme à Madagascar. Antananarivo; 2011.
Kesteman T, Randrianarivelojosia M, Raharimanga V, Randrianasolo L, Piola P, Rogier C. Effectiveness of malaria control interventions in Madagascar: a nationwide case-control survey. Malar J. 2016;15:83.
Battle KE, Bisanzio D, Gibson HS, Bhatt S, Cameron E, Weiss DJ, et al. Treatment-seeking rates in malaria endemic countries. Malar J. 2016;15:20.
Volkman SK, Neafsey DE, Schaffner SF, Park DJ, Wirth DF. Harnessing genomics and genome biology to understand malaria biology. Nat Rev Genet. 2012;13:315–28.
Daniels R, Chang H-H, Séne PD, Park DC, Neafsey DE, Schaffner SF, et al. Genetic surveillance detects both clonal and epidemic transmission of malaria following enhanced intervention in Senegal. PLoS ONE. 2013;8:e60780.
Nkhoma SC, Nair S, Al-Saai S, Ashley E, McGready R, Phyo AP, Nosten F, et al. Population genetic correlates of declining transmission in a human pathogen. Mol Ecol. 2013;22:273–85.
Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS). Makira forest protected area project: 2005–2013 Project implementation report. 31 August, 2015 v3.0.
Institut National de la Statistique (INSTAT). Madagascar—Enquête Démographique et de Santé 2008–2009. USAID.
Golden CD, Fernald LC, Brashares JS, Rasolofoniaina BJ, Kremen C. Benefits of wildlife consumption to child nutrition in a biodiversity hotspot. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2011;108:19653–6.
Daniels R, Volkman SK, Milner DA, Mahesh N, Neafsey DE, Park DJ, et al. A general SNP-based molecular barcode for Plasmodium falciparum identification and tracking. Malar J. 2008;7:223.
Daniels RF, Deme AB, Gomis JF, Dieye B, Durfee K, Thwing JI, et al. Evidence of non-Plasmodium falciparum malaria infection in Kédougou, Senegal. Malaria J. 2016 (manuscript under review)
Mariette N, Barnadas C, Bouchier C, Tichit M, Ménard D. Country-wide assessment of the genetic polymorphism in Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax antigens detected with rapid diagnostic tests for malaria. Malar J. 2008;7:219.
Ratsimbasoa A, Ravony H, Vonimpaisomihanta J-A, Raherinjafy R, Jahevitra M, Rapelanoro R, et al. Management of uncomplicated malaria in febrile under five-year-old children by community health workers in Madagascar: reliability of malaria rapid diagnostic tests. Malar J. 2012;11:85.
Ratsimbasoa A, Randriamanantena A, Raherinjafy R, Rasoarilalao N, Ménard D. Which malaria rapid test for Madagascar? Field and laboratory evaluation of three tests and expert microscopy of samples from suspected malaria patients in Madagascar. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007;76:481–5.
Ehtesham R, Fazaeli A, Raeisi A, Keshavarz H, Heidari A. Detection of mixed-species infections of Plasmodium falciparum and Plasmodium vivax by nested PCR and rapid diagnostic tests in southeastern Iran. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2015;93:181–5.
Sisya TJ, Kamn’gona RM, Vareta JA, Fulakeza JM, Mukaka MFJ, Seydel KB, et al. Subtle changes in Plasmodium falciparum infection complexity following enhanced intervention in Malawi. Acta Trop. 2015;142:108–14.
Mharakurwa S, Daniels R, Scott A, Wirth DF, Thuma P, Volkman SK. Pre-amplification methods for tracking low-grade Plasmodium falciparum populations during scaled-up interventions in Southern Zambia. Malar J. 2014;13:89.
Daniels R, Hamilton EJ, Durfee K, Ndiaye D, Wirth DF, Hartl DL, et al. Methods to Increase the sensitivity of high resolution melting single nucleotide polymorphism genotyping in malaria. J Vis Exp. 2015;105:e52839.
Anderson TJC, Nair S, Sudimack D, Williams JT, Mayxay M, Newton PN, et al. Geographical distribution of selected and putatively neutral SNPs in Southeast Asian malaria parasites. Mol Biol Evol. 2005;22:2362–74.
Maïga-Ascofaré O, Le Bras J, Mazmouz R, Renard E, Falcão S, Broussier E, et al. Adaptive differentiation of Plasmodium falciparum populations inferred from single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) conferring drug resistance and from neutral SNPs. J Infect Dis. 2010;202:1095–103.
Daniels RF, Schaffner SF, Wenger EA, Proctor JL, Chang HH, Wong W, et al. Modeling malaria genomics reveals transmission decline and rebound in Senegal. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2015;112:7067–72.
Obaldia N, Baro NK, Calzada JE, Santamaria AM, Daniels R, Wong W, Chang H-H, et al. Clonal outbreak of Plasmodium falciparum infection in eastern Panama. J Infect Dis. 2015;211:1087–96.
Ralisoa O, Rasamindrakotroka A, Ravelojana B, Rafarasoa L, Randrianarisoa E, Rakotoson R, et al. Plasmodium falciparum malaria transmission indices in a highland village of the Ikopa River Valley near Antananarivo, Madagascar. Parassitologia. 1991;33:219–23.
Romi R, Razaiarimanga MC, Raharimanga R, Rakotondraibe EM, Ranaivo LH, Pietra V, et al. Impact of the malaria control campaign (1993–1998) in the highlands of Madagascar: parasitological and entomological data. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2002;66:2–6.
Ratovonjato J, Randrianarivelojosia M, Rakotondrainibe ME, Raharimanga V, Andrianaivolambo L, Le Goff G, et al. Entomological and parasitological impacts of indoor residual spraying with DDT, alphacypermethrin and deltamethrin in the western foothill area of Madagascar. Malar J. 2014;13:21.
Roll Back Malaria. Focus on Madagascar. Progress and impact series-country reports. Geneva; 2013.
BLR performed experiments and drafted the manuscript. CDG and SKV designed the field research; EJGA and CDG performed the field research. BLR, CDG, SKV and DLH conceived and designed the analytical methods. CMB performed some of the speciation assays and HRM analysis. CDG and DLH reviewed and edited the manuscript. SKV contributed materials and analysis tools. All authors contributed to the final manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We thank Be Jean Rodolph Rasolofoniaina, Miadana Arisoa Vonona, Rijaniaina Ambinintsoa Ralaiarison, Abdy Roland Berobia, Laurent, Ravaoliny, Berthelemie, and many other MAHERY (Madagascar Health and Environmental Research) collaborators for their research assistance. We also thank the research subjects whose dedication and participation made this work possible. For experimental advice and technical assistance we thank Soa Andrian, Rachel Daniels, Katelyn Durfee, Elizabeth Hamilton and Kalsang Namgyal. We thank Wesley Wong for help with a script to calculate pairwise genetic similarity and for critical discussion of analysis. We thank Danny Milner Jr for critical discussion of study design and analysis and members of the Planetary Health Alliance for general feedback.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and material
SNP genotype data are available in Additional file 2.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Ethical approval was given by the Madagascar Ministry of Health, the Maroantsetra regional medical inspector, the mayor covering the region capturing both communities, the chief in each community, and the Office for the Protection of Human Subjects at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health (IRB#22826).
The authors thank the Health & Ecosystems: Analysis of Linkages (HEAL) program for helping to make this work possible. We are extremely grateful for support provided to HEAL by The Rockefeller Foundation and The Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation who supported the field research to monitor the health of the local Malagasy population in relation to their surrounding ecosystem. This work was also supported, in part, by the James Mills Peirce Fellowship, Harvard University (BLR) and NIH Grants AI106734 and AI099105 (DLH). CMB was supported by funding from the CAPES Foundation within the Ministry of Education, Brazil (Grant No. 88888.033957/2013-00).
Additional file 3: Figure S1. Contains the bootstrap re-sample statistics for comparing genetic relatedness.
About this article
Cite this article
Rice, B.L., Golden, C.D., Anjaranirina, E.J.G. et al. Genetic evidence that the Makira region in northeastern Madagascar is a hotspot of malaria transmission. Malar J 15, 596 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12936-016-1644-4
- Plasmodium falciparum
- Genetic diversity
- Genetic surveillance
- Polygenomic infections