- Open Access
Travel to farms in the lowlands and inadequate malaria information significantly predict malaria in villages around Lake Tana, northwest Ethiopia: a matched case–control study
Malaria Journal volume 17, Article number: 290 (2018)
In Ethiopia, malaria has declined in the last decade; only a small number of cases have been reported, primarily from hotspots. The contribution of house proximity to water bodies and the role of migration in malaria transmission has not yet been examined in detail in northwest Ethiopia. Individual and household-level environmental and socio-demographic drivers of malaria heterogeneity were explored contextually in meso-endemic villages around Lake Tana, northwest Ethiopia.
A health facility-based paired age-sex matched case–control study involving 303 matched pairs was undertaken from 10 October 2016, to 30 June 2017. Geo-referencing of case households, control households, proximate water bodies, and health centres was carried out. A pretested and structured questionnaire was used to collect data on socio-demography, household assets, housing, travel history, and malaria intervention measures. Medians (interquartile range) were computed for continuous variables. Pearson’s Chi square/Fisher’s exact test was used to detect significant differences in proportions. Principal component analysis was performed to estimate household wealth. Stratified analysis was used to confirm confounding and interaction. A multivariable conditional logistic regression model was used to detect risk factors for malaria.
Of 303 malaria cases, 59 (19.5% [15.4–24.3]) were imported malaria cases whereas 244 (80.5% [75.7–84.6]) were locally acquired malaria cases. In bivariate analysis, marital status, educational status, and bed net ownership were significantly associated with malaria cases. In multivariable adjustment, travel to malarious lowlands in the preceding month (adjusted mOR = 7.32; 95% CI 2.40–22.34), household member’s travel to malarious lowlands (adjusted mOR = 2.75; 95% CI 1.02–7.44), and inadequate health information on malaria (adjusted mOR = 1.57; 95% CI 1.03–2.41) were predictors of malaria. Stratified analysis confirmed that elevation of households and travel to malarious lowlands were not effect modifiers. Travel to malarious lowlands had a confounding effect on malaria but elevation of households did not.
In this study, travel to farms in the lowlands and inadequate health information on malaria were risk factors for malaria in villages around Lake Tana. This evidence is critical for the design of improved strategic interventions that consider imported malaria cases and approaches for accessing health information on malaria control in northwest Ethiopia.
Malaria still threatens the lives of millions of people, predominantly in sub-Saharan Africa; incidence increased between 2014 and 2016 in the WHO African region . WHO targeted to eliminate malaria from at least 35 countries in which malaria was transmitted in 2015 and prevent re-establishment of malaria in all countries that are malaria free by 2030 through locally tailored interventions . Wide use of effective interventions, including long-lasting insecticidal nets (LLINs), indoor residual spraying (IRS), treatment based on microscopy/rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs), and artemisinin-based combination therapy (ACT) has led to a considerable reduction in global malaria burden . However, delivering interventions that deny the exceptional role of hot spots will extend the time needed for malaria elimination .
Over three-quarters of the Ethiopian landmass is malarious and 68% of the population is at risk for contracting malaria, depending largely on altitude and season . This signifies a critical public health concern in a severely resource-limited country. Malaria has declined in the last decade, with a small number of cases reported, particularly from hotspots . A 2015 malaria indicator survey using microscopy reported 0.4% malaria prevalence among people of all ages who travelled away from their home in the month preceding the survey and 0.5% among those who did not travel . To end malaria, Ethiopia has employed three crucial interventions: distribution of bed nets, IRS in epidemic-prone areas, and enhanced diagnostic testing through RDT and microscopy along with deployment of ACT. As a result of intensive and integrated intervention measures, malaria incidence declined by 50–75% between 2000 and 2015 in the country . This included implementing a program to eliminate locally acquired malaria transmission in 50 districts by 2020. Despite the gains made to date, sizeable residual transmission remains. This localized transmission is determined by demographic, socioeconomic, and environmental factors .
Malaria heterogeneity is multifactorial [7,8,9]. For instance, different environmental exposures increase malaria heterogeneity, particularly in rural settings; these include land cover, altitude, topography, human and vector population densities, and construction of residential houses . Previous studies showed socio-demography [7, 11], household (HH) wealth , housing structure , travel history [7, 14] and intervention measures [8, 15] to be major factors in malaria transmission. Agricultural labourers often travel to malarious lowlands to work on commercial farms . The resultant acquisition of locally acquired and imported malaria in meso-endemic areas hinders effective interventions in midland and highland areas bordering hyper-endemic areas [16, 17]. In addition, house proximity to water bodies has an inconsistent effect on malaria transmission. Some studies concluded that closeness to water bodies increases malaria risk [18, 19] while others reported lower risk near surface water [20, 21]. Some studies asserted the independence of malaria risk and house proximity to water bodies .
The average flight range of the main vector, Anopheles gambiae, is reported to be approximately 500 m . Over the last 15 years, malaria prevalence has been decreasing in most endemic settings, due to the aforementioned integrated control intervention strategy, and in some settings the disease has been confined to hot spots with specific vector ecology conditions . For malaria elimination and eradication, vector ecology is important. However, there are several ecological obstacles to vector control with existing interventions, including variations in mosquito behaviour, insecticide resistance, avoidance behaviour, vector biodiversity, competitive and food web interactions, dispersal and mating behaviour, and environmental change .
Comprehending heterogeneity in malaria exposure produces opportunities for spatially oriented malaria control . Targeted malaria interventions have direct benefits both for targeted populations and for the whole community. Targeted control efforts are vital tools in malaria elimination when malaria transmission is sustained in hot spots .
Malaria elimination may be facilitated by finer-scale spatial studies. In areas with low malaria incidence, passive case detection (PCD) may lead to the identification of households (HHs) with more infections than others that can be a source of new infections. Determining the distance between HHs and the proximate water bodies where symptomatic malaria cases originate may help to define hotspots of malaria and contribute to improving malaria elimination efforts by optimizing the delivery of limited resources to higher-risk populations [26, 27]. The role of GPS-based house proximity to water bodies on malaria has not yet been documented in northwest Ethiopia, and no studies have traced the potential role of imported malaria in maintaining transmission foci in the country. This study aimed to determine the effect of house proximity to water bodies and other underlying factors on malaria heterogeneity in villages around Lake Tana. Specifically, this study explored the role of socio-demographic characteristics, travel history, HH wealth, housing structure, and malaria intervention measures on malaria heterogeneity. The findings of this study may guide national malaria control and elimination programmes in re-designing programmes for malaria elimination in Ethiopia.
Study area and settings
The study was undertaken in 11 kebeles (the lowest administrative units in Ethiopia) of Gondar Zuriya District and 1 kebele of Dembia District, northwest Ethiopia, from 10 October 2016, to 30 June 2017 (Fig. 1). Out of 37 kebeles in Gondar Zuriya District, eight are not endemic for malaria. In 2016/2017, Gondar Zuriya and Dembia districts had a projected population of 222, 700 and 315, 390, respectively. The area of Gondar Zuriya District is 1108.53 km2, with a population density of 188.4 persons/km2 . Gondar Zuriya District is composed of hilly and plain landscapes, and the altitude ranges from 1750 to 2600 m above sea level over three highland fringe zones. Subsistence agriculture is the main occupation of the inhabitants. In 2016, total rainfall, mean maximum temperature, mean minimum temperature and relative humidity in the study area were 1047.6 mm, 27.4 °C, 14.7 °C, and 45%, respectively . Gondar Zuriya District has seven health centres and 38 health posts that provide health services for the people in the district.
Since 2004, guidelines on malaria case management in the country have recommended treatment based on parasitological diagnosis with microscopy/RDTs. Artemether–lumefantrine is the first-line drug in Ethiopia. Seasonally, large numbers of malaria cases are reported from September to December in northwest Ethiopia, mostly Plasmodium falciparum infections . In Gondar Zuriya District, large number of individuals travel to malarious lowlands to temporarily work on commercial agricultural farms, mainly during the rainy and spring seasons. Males aged 15 years and above are the main travellers to the lowlands. Malaria is a common seasonal disease in the district. A 10-year (2002–2011) trend analysis conducted in a neighboring district’s health centre reported 23,473 microscopically confirmed malaria cases (75% P. falciparum and 25% Plasmodium vivax) with a fluctuating trend and mean malaria cases of 2, 347. From 2010 to 2011, P. falciparum prevalence decreased while P. vivax prevalence was increasing, indicating a trend shift from P. falciparum to P. vivax. Males and those in the age group of 15–44 years were highly affected . Another study conducted at selected health institutions in three districts reported 61.3% prevalence of malaria (72.3% P. falciparum and 27.7% P. vivax) microscopically . There is an annual IRS programme and distribution of LLINs, with replacement being done every 3 years. Bendiocarb and Propoxur has been used for spraying interior walls of houses and LLINs (DuraNet®) have been distributed since September 2005. One study recognized Anopheles arabiensis as a primary vector of malaria around Lake Tana .
The study area has altitudes of 1750–2500 m above sea level . The climate of Lake Tana basin is of the temperate tropical highland type . Most rain falls between June and September . The water of Lake Tana is turbid and the lake’s shores are becoming covered with water hyacinth. Gumara Stream flows from east to west and into Lake Tana, irrigating extensive commercial garlic farms along its course. The irrigation water is pumped using generators, causing a substantial decrease in river flow during the dry season (October to February). The reduction in river flow creates stagnant areas, potential breeding habitats for mosquitoes.
Study design and eligibility criteria
A health facility-based paired-matched case–control study was used. Cases and controls were individually matched by sex. However, frequency matching was done by age (< 15, 15–49, and > 49 years). All patients ≥ 5 months of age who visited Lemba and Makesegnit health centres and permanent residents in the study kebeles were included. Individuals who had no Plasmodium-positive blood film or symptoms of malaria during the preceding month confirmed using patient interview or health centre register were enrolled in the control group. Individuals with new episodes of malaria or people with recrudescent cases that presented after 1 month or more of the initial infection, and those who had taken malaria treatment in the previous 30 days were excluded from the study.
The patients (malaria cases and controls) were included into the study based on the clinical signs and symptoms of malaria and blood slides results. When patients came to the health centres for treatment, clinical diagnosis was performed for malaria. Then, the presence of Plasmodium parasites in the blood samples was confirmed using malaria microscopy. When a malaria case was found, the matched control was obtained from the patients by confirming through clinical diagnosis and slide results within 3 days after the case was diagnosed.
Sample size computation
Sample size was determined using matched case–control study design sample size calculation methods  with an assumption of 95% level of confidence, 80% power to detect exposure difference, odds ratio (OR) of 1.61, one control per case, and assuming that 25% of the control HHs were located within a 250 m radius of water bodies . Based on these assumptions, 333 case–control matched pairs could be included in the study.
Data collection and quality assurance
Microscopy was used to confirm the presence of Plasmodium species in the clinically diagnosed patients . Microscopy is the gold standard method of diagnosing malaria . Confirmation of positivity or negativity of slide results was assured using standard operating procedures of Giemsa malaria microscopy at the health centres. Thick blood film was used to search for malaria parasites while thin film was used to confirm the malaria parasite species when this could not be done in the thick film. Malaria diagnoses were performed at the two health centres and patients were selected and classified as cases or controls based on the eligibility criteria. Cases were patients who had signs and symptoms of malaria or reported fever during the previous 48 h and were positive for single or mixed Plasmodium species in a blood sample diagnosed by microscopy . Controls were individuals presenting at the health centres whose thick blood smear tests were negative for malaria. Experienced microscopists who were certified by the Ethiopian Federal Ministry of Health double checked all the slides at the health centres.
All tested slides (negative and positive) were stored at the health centres and three quarters of the sample were collected randomly for quality control. Blind examination of the slides was independently performed by a senior technician at the University of Gondar Specialized Hospital Laboratory.
A pre-tested, semi-structured questionnaire was used to collect individual and HH information. The questionnaire consisted of questions on socio-demography, HH assets, housing structure, LLINs, IRS, travel history, visits to traditional healers, and inappropriate home-based management of malaria (HMM). Males who completed grade 12 collected the individual and HH data through HH visits. Data collectors were trained in field data collection for 3 days by the lead researcher. If any case or control was absent at the first visit, the HH was revisited within 2 days. After the second visit, 15 HHs were excluded and 15 subjects refused to be interviewed.
Geo-referencing of case HHs, control HHs, small water bodies, a part of the shore of Lake Tana, and the two health centres was recorded through a handheld GPS device (Garmin’s GPSMAP 60CSx, Garmin International Inc., USA) with an accuracy goal of ~ 5 m. Geo-locations were also recorded in notebooks and checklists. An additional image file shows the characteristics of study villages in more detail (see Additional file 1). Field data collectors were blinded to the malaria status of the enrolled individuals. The questionnaire was prepared in English, translated into the Amharic language, and the responses from the study participants were translated to English by independent language experts.
Variables and measurements
House proximity to water bodies within a 250 m radius was the primary exposure variable. The remaining variables were covariates. The outcome variable was malaria status (dichotomous). Through an ecological survey, two nearby water bodies (rivers, streams, marshes, swamps, stagnant water, natural pools, springs, water holes) were georeferenced for each case HH and control HH (Fig. 2). Then, by observational estimation, water bodies within a 500 m radius of HHs were grouped in Category 1 (water body 1) and those farther away from the HHs were grouped in Category 2 (water body 2).
For analysis, house proximity to water bodies and health centres was computed as Euclidean distance using GPS coordinates [38, 39]. The average flight range of the main vector An. gambiae is reported to be approximately 500 m . For this study, house proximity to water bodies was categorized into three distance bands (< 250 m, 250–500 m and > 500 m) . The Euclidean distance of each HH to the health centre was categorized as a dichotomous explanatory variable (≤ 5 km and > 5 km) .
HH wealth reflects a composite of several dichotomous and polychotomous variables used to indicate the socioeconomic status of the HH. Variables that used for HH wealth index construction were developed on the basis of literature [42, 43] and the Ethiopian Demographic and Health Survey . Longer-run HH assets, housing structure, water supply source, sanitation facility, agricultural land size, having domestic animals, and having a savings account were used to construct the wealth index. The values of the variables were weighted from 0 to 1, indicating the lowest and the highest values, respectively.
Data were double entered, coded, cleaned, and verified using EpiData Version 3.1 software (EpiData Association, Odense, Denmark). Data analysis was carried out using SPSS statistical software version 22 (IBM Corp. IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Armonk, NY, USA) and STATA version 14.0 (StataCorp. Statistical Software: College Station, TX 77845, USA). Descriptive statistics [n (%)], including median IQR (interquartile range), were calculated for continuous variables. For categorical variables, Chi squared or Fisher’s exact test were employed to detect significant differences in proportions. All reported p-values were two-tailed and considered statistically significant if p < 0.05.
Principal component analysis (PCA) was used to estimate HH wealth . Principal component 1 was used to rank the HHs into three groups. Cutoff values/rank categories were set for the three groups. The original variables were transformed into scores having a mean equal to zero and standard deviation equal to one (standardization). The value of each standardized variable was multiplied by principal component 1 and a third variable created from the product for each variable. Finally, a HH wealth score was computed from the sum of the third variables. Based on the cutoff values of principal component 1 ranks, a final three-category HH wealth index variable was developed. The composite score was classified into tertiles, with the higher tertile reflecting higher wealth.
Cochran Mantel–Haenszel stratified analyses were employed to eliminate co-factors, and to discover and describe effect modifiers. Mantel–Haenszel test of equality of stratum-specific ORs was used to identify effect modifiers. First, the equality of stratum-specific ORs were checked to confirm significant differences, which indicate the presence of effect modification between the exposure and other factors. If not different, the presence of confounding was then assessed. The Mantel–Haenszel test produced a single weighed estimate of the predictor by adjusting the effects of the third variable and the crude estimate. Then, confounding presence was ascertained through degree of difference between the crude and adjusted ORs. For confirmation, a relative difference in the effect estimate with a cutoff of ≥ 10% was used for evidence of confounding .
The conditional logistic regression model is the standard tool for the analysis of matched case–control studies. It allows for the analysis of data with stratified samples. Like other regression models, it allows for multiple variables, continuous exposures, confounding, and effect-modifying variables to be handled appropriately . Although age was a matching variable, it was included in the model to eliminate the residual confounding effect that may come from broad age categories. Through a matching variable for cases and controls, a matched analysis was employed to explore factors associated with malaria infection. The modelling strategy involved estimating unadjusted matched odds ratio (mOR) and adjusted mOR of the studied variables with malaria infection at 95% CI. A bivariate analysis was executed for each variable; those variables having p < 0.2 along with variables having biological plausibility were included in the multivariable model. β-coefficients, ORs with 95% confidence intervals (CI) and p-values were estimated for the multivariable matched analysis and variables at p < 0.05 were considered as statistically significant and independently associated with malaria infection.
Socio-demographic and household physical characteristics of cases and controls
A total of 606 patients (303 case–control matched pairs) participated in the study, and their HH geo-location was mapped (Fig. 3). Thirty matched pairs were ineligible for the study because they could not be contacted using the addresses they gave to the health centre during diagnosis, finding matched controls for cases within 3 days, and refusal to enroll, giving a response rate of 90.9%. Eight patients refused to participate in the study. The quality control results showed 98.5% inter-rater agreement and kappa coefficient of 0.97 with the results at the health centres (p < 0.0001). Discordant results were reread by a third senior technician and this result was taken as the final result.
The age distribution of cases and controls for matching was as follows: 238 (39.3% [35.5–43.2]) for subjects < 15 years of age, 328 (54.1% [50.1–58.1]), for subjects 15–49 years of age, and 40 (6.6% [4.9–8.9]), for subjects > 49 years of age. Half of the malaria infections, 152 (50.3% [44.5–55.8]), were P. vivax mono-infections while the other half (48.8%) were P. falciparum mono-infections, with only few mixed infections. Of the total malaria cases, 108 (35.6% [30.4–41.2]) occurred between September 15, 2016, and December 15, 2016; 71 (23.4% [19.0–28.6]) occurred between December 16, 2016, and March 15, 2017; and 124 (40.9% [35.5–46.6]), occurred between March 16, 2017, and June 30, 2017. The median (IQR) age of the malaria cases was 18 (4.42–30) years. Of the 303 malaria cases, 199 (65.7% [61.8–69.4]) were males (Table 1).
Travel to commercial agricultural farms and other behaviours among cases and controls
Almost all the study patients, 603 (99.5% [98.5–99.8]), had been active at night (6 pm to 12 pm) outside the home in the preceding month. Seventy (11.6% [9.2–14.4]) took anti-malarial drugs presumptively. In addition, 83 (13.7% [11.2–16.7]) travelled to malarious lowlands (Metema, Shehedi, Abderafi, Abrahajira, Humera, Maikadera, Dansha, Belessa and Fogera) in the preceding month. From those who travelled to malarious lowlands, 55 (66.3% [55.2–75.8]) were engaged in agriculture. The main reason for travel, cited by 75 patients (90.4% [81.7–95.2]), was to seek temporary jobs. Most of the travellers, (82, 98.8% [91.6–99.8]), were males; 58 (69.9% [59.0–78.9]) were 15–29 years of age; 39 (66.1% [52.8–77.3]) had falciparum malaria; and 42 (50.6% [39.8–61.4]) lived at elevations between 1901 and 2100 m above sea level. Of the 303 malaria cases, 59 (19.5% [15.4–24.3]) had imported malaria whereas 244 (80.5% [75.7–84.6]) had locally acquired malaria (Table 2).
Intervention measures of malaria among cases and controls
The median (IQR) distance from house to health centre of the patients was 3.6 (0.9–5.3) km. Fewer than one-third of the patients, 185 (30.5% [27.0–34.3]) owned at least one LLIN per HH. Of those patients who had LLINs, 123 (66.5% [59.3–73.0]) reported having slept under a LLIN the night prior to the interviews. Only 95 (51.4% [44.1–58.5]) of HHs had LLINs that were in good condition. Overall, 451 (74.4% [70.8–77.8]) reported that their houses had been sprayed with IRS in the preceding year (Table 3).
Proximity of case HHs and control HHs to water bodies
Two hundred twenty-four (73.9% [68.7–78.6]) of the case HHs were located at an altitude between 1701 and 1900 m above sea level. Only 18 (5.9% [3.8–9.3]) of case HHs were located within 2 km of Lake Tana. Likewise, 18 (5.9% [3.8–9.3]) case HHs had a water body 1 within a 250 m radius (Table 4).
Mantel–Haenszel analysis for proving co-factors and interaction
The stratified analysis confirmed that there was no significant variation between stratum-specific ORs, indicating no interaction between the predictors and HH elevation or travel to malarious lowlands. Stratified analysis also revealed no disparity between the pooled and adjusted ORs, indicating that HH elevation was not a co-factor for the effect of predictors on malaria. Nonetheless, travel to malarious lowlands was a co-factor for the effects of age, marital status, occupation, educational status, number of rooms, travel history within the study area, HH member’s travel to malarious lowlands, inappropriate HMM, IRS, and HH elevation on malaria (Tables 5 and 6). Additional table files show the determinants of malaria by HH elevation and travel to malarious lowlands (see Additional files 2 and 3).
Multivariable modelling through conditional logistic regression
Multivariable adjustment established that travel to malarious lowlands in the preceding month (adjusted mOR = 7.32; 95% CI 2.40–22.34), HH member travel to malarious lowlands (adjusted mOR = 2.75; 95% CI 1.02–7.44), and delivery of health information on malaria (adjusted mOR = 1.57; 95% CI 1.03–2.41) were independently associated with malaria heterogeneity (Table 7).
Age of patients; marital status, occupation, and educational status of the patient/HH head; HH size; HH wealth index; flooring, roofing, and wall building materials; number of rooms; separate kitchen; window types; open eaves in the roof; tethering of cattle, goats, and sheep at night; travel history within the study area; visits to traditional healers; inappropriate HMM; LLIN ownership; IRS; HH elevation; house proximity to health centre; house proximity to water body 1; house proximity to water body 2; and house proximity to Lake Tana were not significantly associated with malaria infection (p > 0.05). In other words, there were no significant differences between cases and controls with respect to these characteristics (Table 7).
In this study, travel history to malarious lowlands in the preceding month, having a HH member who travelled to malarious lowlands in the preceding month, and delivery of health information on malaria were statistically significant and independent predictors of malaria in villages near Lake Tana, northwest Ethiopia.
Individuals who travelled to malarious areas had higher odds of malaria infection than those who did not travel. This finding agrees with that of other studies in Ethiopia [7, 14] and in Zanzibar . This may be due to the susceptibility of travellers from the midlands to malaria that progresses to severe symptomatic malaria, especially among those travellers who slept without personal protective measures. Infection-naïve individuals are highly susceptible to malaria if exposed to an infectious anopheles mosquito, particularly in hyper-endemic areas . The travels mainly take place during high malaria transmission periods among people seeking temporal job and engaging in social activities. This and other studies showed low chemoprophylaxis and LLIN use during travels . In the hot lowlands, many labourers sleep outdoors and in open spaces without protection from mosquitoes, resulting in high malaria exposure risk. Large numbers of imported malaria cases have been found in the northwestern Ethiopian highlands . Thus, imported malaria is a health risk besides locally acquired malaria in midland villages around Lake Tana. This duality of malaria origins is also indicated by the fact that three-quarters of the malaria cases could not be traced to the lowlands. This epidemiological situation points to a critical obstacle to eliminating malaria through targeted interventions.
Individuals who did not know malaria aetiology, transmission, and prevention methods had an increased odds of risk for malaria infection. The possible explanation for this finding may be the low educational status of the study population or delivery of malaria information independent of educational status, which prevents them from understanding and analysing the information provided to them by community health workers.
In the multivariable adjustment, sociodemographic factors, HH wealth, housing structure, travel history within the study area, visits to traditional healers, inappropriate HMM, LLIN ownership, IRS, HH elevation, and house proximity to water bodies were not associated with malaria. This might be due to low heterogeneity of housing structure, socio-demographic status, HH wealth, proximity to water bodies, elevation of HHs, and delivery of inadequate information on treatment-seeking, bed net use, and other preventive measures by Gondar Zuriya District Health Office. Demographically, educational status did not vary significantly between cases and controls. This corroborates the findings of other studies in Ethiopia  and in Gambia , although advancement in education confers significant protection from malaria . Occupation was not a significant predictor of malaria infection. This may have been due to the small number of non-agricultural workers in the study. However, another study in the Ethiopian highlands showed that agricultural workers were at elevated risk of malaria . The difference in findings may be due to sample size. Interestingly, marital status was marginally significantly associated with malaria infection in bivariate analysis. This may be because mostly unmarried males travel to the malarious lowlands for work. In addition, unmarried people are generally in poorer health and have a higher mortality risk than married people .
In this study, HH size played no significant role in the odds of contracting malaria. This finding is consistent with that of other studies in Ethiopia  and Malawi . Several studies associated larger HH size with malaria . HH wealth facilitates the management of illness, and several studies reported better access to health care by wealthier groups [12, 51]. Nonetheless, HH wealth had no significant impact on malaria in this study.
Housing structure had no significant statistical association with malaria transmission, a finding also reported in previous studies [8, 9]. However, researchers have reported that individuals living in houses with mud walls , thatched roofs , dung plastered floors , and boarded windows had higher risk of malaria . Surprisingly, spatial malaria heterogeneity was not determined by fine-scale environmental factors, particularly water bodies close to HHs. This study is in agreement with a study that stated malaria incidence was not associated with distance to an Ethiopian dam reservoir . Two other studies in Ethiopia reported that the odds of malaria infection were lower in HHs closer to reservoirs than those at greater distances [20, 21]. On the other hand, numerous studies have found large numbers of malaria cases in HHs near various types of water bodies [16, 18, 19]. Possible reasons for these contradictory findings may be differences in the use of LLINs or IRS, socioeconomic and environmental factors in populations, vulnerabilities or transmission dynamics, differential health services accessibility, or imported malaria cases.
In this study, LLIN ownership and IRS had no significant effect on malaria prevalence. This finding is similar to that of studies revealing that LLIN ownership and use as well as indoor wall spraying did not protect against malaria [7, 9, 20, 25]. However, other studies reported a protective effect of bed nets and IRS on malaria [8, 15, 25, 53]. The difference may be due to failure to use LLINs properly and consistently, inadequacy or poor condition of LLINs, or failure to use them during travel. As a result, the protective effect of LLINs could have been negated . Besides, imported malaria, human activities at night outside the home, the spread of insecticide-resistant vectors, and spraying by untrained individuals and substandard insecticides may have reduced the protective effect of IRS.
A matched case–control study was used to eliminate the confounding effects of sex and age, which solidified the conclusions and recommendations. Matched case–control studies have minimal bias relative to cross-sectional and unmatched case–control designs because they compare groups internally. The water bodies proximate to the HHs were georeferenced through direct ecological surveys to increase measurement accuracy despite accessible satellite imagery. To avoid information bias, data collectors were blinded to the malaria status of patients during onsite data collection at the HH level. All other measurements of exposure variables were performed at home through interviews and direct observations. Stratified analyses and multivariable conditional logistic regression were used to control confounding and report interaction effects.
This study has several limitations. It is difficult to establish temporal relationships between exposures and malaria. Employing PCD to measure the effect of house proximity to water bodies on spatial malaria heterogeneity was not efficient due to the presence of asymptomatic and submicroscopic parasite carriers and the treatment of malaria by drug vendors, private clinics, and health posts , which were not studied. The asymptomatic parasite carriage may influence the risk factor analysis, especially if the reservoirs occur more often in controls than in cases. This study failed to obtain information on the size and nature of water bodies. Case and control selection from health institutions can be prone to bias since patients usually do not represent the general population. Recall bias could have been introduced during travel history measurement. The unmeasured residuals were not controlled but the effect on the finding is marginal. Moreover, due to unrest in the study area, the study did not include the month of September, at the end of the main rainy season, when more imported and locally acquired malaria cases occur in northwestern Ethiopia . Even though this is a low transmission setting, travel history associated with malaria does not necessarily identify imported cases.
These study findings emphasize the fact that comprehending the sociodemographic characteristics of individuals who travel to malarious lowlands, travel patterns in individual villages, adequacy of health information on malaria, and taking into account the potential vector breeding sites in mid-altitude villages are central to facilitating malaria elimination strategies.
Seasonal and other short-term migration to commercial agricultural farms in the malarious Ethiopian lowlands is a significant independent risk factor for malaria infection in villages around Lake Tana. In addition, inadequate health information on malaria and marital status, apparently related to the predominance of unmarried young males migrating to the lowlands, are risk factors for malaria infection. There is a need for studies to explore risk factors of imported malaria and locally acquired malaria independently in the midlands of northwestern Ethiopia. In addition, information is needed on the transmission dynamics of imported malaria in the midlands. This information is critical for designing effective and integrated interventions that consider imported malaria cases and approaches to accessing health information on malaria control in northwest Ethiopia and other highland/lowland transitional areas.
artemisinin-based combination therapy
adjusted odds ratio
crude odds ratio
home based management malaria
indoor residual spraying
long-lasting insecticidal nets
Millennium Development Goals
matched odds ratio
principal component analysis
passive case detection
rapid diagnostic tests
World Health Organization
WHO. World malaria report 2017. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2017. http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/259492/1/9789241565523-eng.pdf. Accessed 9 Feb 2018.
WHO. Global technical strategy for malaria (2016–2030). Geneva: World Health Organization; 2015. http://www.truevaluemetrics.org/DBpdfs/Health/Malaria/WHO/WHO-Global-Malaria-Programme-GTS-and-AIM-Board-May-2015.pdf. Accessed 7 Sept 2015.
Lindblade KA, Steinhardt L, Samuels A, Kachur SP, Slutsker L. The silent threat: asymptomatic parasitemia and malaria transmission. Expert Rev Anti Infect Ther. 2013;11:623–39.
Bousema T, Griffin JT, Sauerwein RW, Smith DL, Churcher TS, Takken W, et al. Hitting hotspots: spatial targeting of malaria for control and elimination. PLoS Med. 2012;9:e1001165.
EPHI. Ethiopian national malaria indicator survey 2015. Addis Ababa: Ethiopian Public Health Institute; 2016. https://www.ephi.gov.et/images/pictures/download2009/MIS-2015-Final-Report-December-_2016.pdf. Accessed 20 Feb 2018.
WHO. World malaria report 2015. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2015. http://www.who.int/malaria/publications/world-malaria-report-2015/WMR2015.pdf. Accessed 10 Feb 2016.
Alemu K, Worku A, Berhane Y, Kumie A. Men traveling away from home are more likely to bring malaria into high altitude villages, northwest Ethiopia. PLoS ONE. 2014;9:e95341.
Townes LR, Mwandama D, Mathanga DP, Wilson ML. Elevated dry-season malaria prevalence associated with fine-scale spatial patterns of environmental risk: a case–control study of children in rural Malawi. Malar J. 2013;12:407.
Okebe J, Mwesigwa J, Kama EL, Ceesay SJ, Njie F, Correa S, et al. A comparative case control study of the determinants of clinical malaria in the Gambia. Malar J. 2014;13:306.
Stresman GH. Beyond temperature and precipitation: ecological risk factors that modify malaria transmission. Acta Trop. 2010;116:167–72.
Robards J, Evandrou M, Falkingham J, Vlachantoni A. Marital status, health and mortality. Maturitas. 2012;73:295–9.
Samadoulougou S, Maheu-Giroux M, Kirakoya-Samadoulougou F, De Keukeleire M, Castro MC, Robert A. Multilevel and geo-statistical modeling of malaria risk in children of Burkina Faso. Parasit Vectors. 2014;7:1–13.
Coleman M, Coleman M, Mabaso ML, Mabuza AM, Kok G, Coetzee M, et al. Household and microeconomic factors associated with malaria in Mpumalanga, South Africa. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2010;104:143–7.
Yukich JO, Taylor C, Eisele TP, Reithinger R, Nauhassenay H, Berhane Y, et al. Travel history and malaria infection risk in a low-transmission setting in Ethiopia: a case control study. Malar J. 2013;12:33.
West PA, Protopopoff N, Rowland M, Cumming E, Rand A, Drakeley C, et al. Malaria risk factors in northwest Tanzania: the effect of spraying, nets and wealth. PLoS ONE. 2013;8:e65787.
Cohen JM, Dlamini S, Novotny JM, Kandula D, Kunene S, Tatem AJ. Rapid case-based mapping of seasonal malaria transmission risk for strategic elimination planning in Swaziland. Malar J. 2013;12:61.
Shi Q-Q, Cheng P, Zhang C-X, Guo X-X, Liu L-J, Wang H-F, et al. Epidemiological analysis of 133 malaria cases in Shanxian county, Shandong Province, China. Asian Pac J Trop Dis. 2017;10:802–7.
Kibret S, Wilson GG, Tekie H, Petros B. Increased malaria transmission around irrigation schemes in Ethiopia and the potential of canal water management for malaria vector control. Malar J. 2014;13:360.
Nissen A, Cook J, Loha E, Lindtjørn B. Proximity to vector breeding site and risk of Plasmodium vivax infection: a prospective cohort study in rural Ethiopia. Malar J. 2017;16:380.
Gosoniu L, Msengwa A, Lengeler C, Vounatsou P. Spatially explicit burden estimates of malaria in Tanzania: Bayesian geostatistical modeling of the malaria indicator survey data. PLoS ONE. 2012;7:e23966.
Sena L, Deressa W, Ali A. Dynamics of Plasmodium falciparium and Plasmodium vivax in a micro-ecological setting, Southwest Ethiopia: effects of altitude and proximity to a dam. BMC Infect Dis. 2014;14:625.
Yewhalaw D, Getachew Y, Tushune K, Kassahun W, Duchateau L, Speybroeck N. The effect of dams and seasons on malaria incidence and anopheles abundance in Ethiopia. BMC Infect Dis. 2013;13:161.
Dambach P, Machault V, Lacaux J-P, Vignolles C, Sié A, Sauerborn R. Utilization of combined remote sensing techniques to detect environmental variables influencing malaria vector densities in rural West Africa. Int J Health Geogr. 2012;11:1.
Ferguson HM, Dornhaus A, Beeche A, Borgemeister C, Gottlieb M, Mulla MS, et al. Ecology: a prerequisite for malaria elimination and eradication. PLoS Med. 2010;7:e1000303.
Loha E, Lunde TM, Lindtjørn B. Effect of bednets and indoor residual spraying on spatio-temporal clustering of malaria in a village in south Ethiopia: a longitudinal study. PLoS ONE. 2012;7:e47354.
Rosas-Aguirre A, Ponce OJ, Carrasco-Escobar G, Speybroeck N, Contreras-Mancilla J, Gamboa D, et al. Plasmodium vivax malaria at households: spatial clustering and risk factors in a low endemicity urban area of the Northwestern Peruvian coast. Malar J. 2015;14:176.
Wangdi K, Kaewkungwal J, Singhasivanon P, Silawan T, Lawpoolsri S, White NJ. Spatio-temporal patterns of malaria infection in Bhutan: a country embarking on malaria elimination. Malar J. 2011;10:89.
CSA. National population and housing census of Ethiopia: population projection of Ethiopia for all Regions, at Wereda level from 2014–2017. Ethiopian Central Statistics Agency. http://www.csa.gov.et. Accessed 25 Apr 2016.
NMA. Annual weather report 2016. National Meteorology Agency of Ethiopia. http://www.ethiomet.gov.et/. Accessed 20 Jan 2018.
Alemu A, Muluye D, Mihret M, Adugna M, Gebeyaw M. Ten year trend analysis of malaria prevalence in Kola Diba, North Gondar, Northwest Ethiopia. Parasit Vectors. 2012;5:173.
Alemu A, Fuehrer H-P, Getnet G, Tessema B, Noedl H. Plasmodium ovale curtisi and Plasmodium ovale wallikeri in Northwest Ethiopia. Malar J. 2013;12:346.
Asmare Y, Tekie H, Seyoum E. Effective utilization period of long-lasting insecticide treated nets against malaria vector mosquitoes and the species composition in Northwest Ethiopia. Ethiop J Biol Sci. 2011;10:1.
Animut A, Lindtjørn B. Use of epidemiological and entomological tools in the control and elimination of malaria in Ethiopia. Malar J. 2018;17:26.
Mohamed Y, Van den Hurk B, Savenije H, Bastiaanssen W. Hydroclimatology of the Nile: results from a regional climate model. Hydrol Earth Syst Sci. 2005;9:263–78.
Schlesselman J, Stolley P. Case–control studies: design, conduct, analysis. 3rd ed. New York: Oxford University Press; 1982.
WHO. Parasitological confirmation of malaria diagnosis: report of a WHO technical consultation. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2009. http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/44323/1/9789241599412_eng.pdf. Accessed 4 Mar 2015.
Cheesbrough M. District laboratory practice in tropical countries. 2nd ed. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2009.
Ragan DM. Structural geology: an introduction to geometrical techniques. 4th ed. New York: Cambridge University Press; 2009.
Escamilla V, Chibwesha CJ, Gartland M, Chintu N, Mubiana-Mbewe M, Musokotwane K, et al. Distance from household to clinic and its association with the uptake of prevention of mother-to-child HIV transmission regimens in rural Zambia. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2015;70:e94.
Mala AO, Irungu LW, Shililu JI, Muturi EJ, Mbogo CC, Njagi JK, et al. Dry season ecology of Anopheles gambiae complex mosquitoes at larval habitats in two traditionally semi-arid villages in Baringo, Kenya. Parasit Vectors. 2011;4:25.
Zinszer K, Charland K, Kigozi R, Dorsey G, Kamya MR, Buckeridge DL. Determining health-care facility catchment areas in Uganda using data on malaria-related visits. Bull World Health Organ. 2014;92:178–86.
Vyas S, Kumaranayake L. Constructing socio-economic status indices: how to use principal components analysis. Health Policy Plan. 2006;21:459–68.
Krefis AC, Schwarz NG, Nkrumah B, Acquah S, Loag W, Sarpong N, et al. Principal component analysis of socioeconomic factors and their association with malaria in children from the Ashanti Region, Ghana. Malar J. 2010;9:201.
CSA and ICF. Ethiopia demographic and health survey 2011. Addis Ababa: Ethiopia and Calverton, Maryland, USA, Central Statistical Agency and ICF International; 2012. https://www.unicef.org/ethiopia/ET_2011_EDHS.pdf. Accessed 6 Feb 2015.
Aschengrau A, Seage GR. Essentials of epidemiology in public health. 3rd ed. Boston: Jones & Bartlett Publishers; 2013.
Avalos M, Pouyes H, Grandvalet Y, Orriols L, Lagarde E. Sparse conditional logistic regression for analyzing large-scale matched data from epidemiological studies: a simple algorithm. BMC Bioinformatics. 2015;16(Suppl 6):S1.
Le Menach A, Tatem AJ, Cohen JM, Hay SI, Randell H, Patil AP, et al. Travel risk, malaria importation and malaria transmission in Zanzibar. Sci Rep. 2011;1:93.
Offiah SA, Ekperi O, Igwe F, Nwosu S. Malaria in non-immune travelers: a case report and reminder for increased awareness of the problem. J Med Invest Pract. 2014;9:160–4.
Peterson I, Borrell LN, El-Sadr W, Teklehaimanot A. Individual and household level factors associated with malaria incidence in a highland region of Ethiopia: a multilevel analysis. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2009;80:103–11.
Worku L, Damtie D, Endris M, Getie S, Aemero M. Asymptomatic malaria and associated risk factors among school children in Sanja town, Northwest Ethiopia. Int Sch Res Notices. 2014;2014:6.
Graves PM, Richards FO, Ngondi J, Emerson PM, Shargie EB, Endeshaw T, et al. Individual, household and environmental risk factors for malaria infection in Amhara, Oromia and SNNP regions of Ethiopia. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2009;103:1211–20.
Huldén L, McKitrick R, Huldén L. Average household size and the eradication of malaria. J R Stat Soc Ser A Stat Soc. 2014;177:725–42.
Ayele DG, Zewotir TT, Mwambi HG. Prevalence and risk factors of malaria in Ethiopia. Malar J. 2012;11:195.
Alemu K, Worku A, Berhane Y, Kumie A. Spatiotemporal clusters of malaria cases at village level, Northwest Ethiopia. Malar J. 2014;13:223.
AM, KA, MA and HK conceived and designed the study; AM conducted the data collection; AM and KA conducted data management and data analysis; AM, KA, MA, SR and HK wrote and edited the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We are grateful to Gondar Zuriya District Office for cooperation facilitating the research activities. We also appreciate the University of Gondar Research Center for providing GPS devices. We also want to thank the data collectors and supervisors for their diligent work, and the study participants for their time and cooperation. Ann Byers kindly edited the manuscript at short notice.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
Data and all the materials will be available from the corresponding author upon request.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study protocol was approved by the Ethiopian Institute of Water Resources, Addis Ababa University Institutional Review Board, and the Ethical Review Committee of Wollo University. Informed assent was secured from the caregivers/guardians of study subjects < 18 years of age. Study participants aged ≥ 18 years gave their informed consent after having the nature of the study explained to them. For illiterate caregivers/guardians and participants, thumb-printed consent was obtained in the presence of an independent literate witness. Participation in the study was voluntary and confidentiality of the information was assured during as well as after data collection. Malaria cases were treated according to national guidelines.
Funding for this study was provided by the Ethiopian Institute of Water Resources, Addis Ababa University, and Wollo University. The funders of the study had no role in the study design, data collection, data analysis, data interpretation, or writing of the report.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Study kebeles characteristics. a) A section of the study area bordering Lake Tana. b) A stagnant water potential for Anopheles mosquitoes breeding. c) Use of LLINs for protection of straw. d) An LLIN they showed packed in its plastic bag.
Characteristics of determinants of malaria by HH elevation in villages around Lake Tana, Ethiopia, October 2016-June 2017.
Characteristics of determinants of malaria by travel to lowlands in villages around Lake Tana, Ethiopia, October 2016-June 2017.
About this article
Cite this article
Malede, A., Alemu, K., Aemero, M. et al. Travel to farms in the lowlands and inadequate malaria information significantly predict malaria in villages around Lake Tana, northwest Ethiopia: a matched case–control study. Malar J 17, 290 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12936-018-2434-y
- Locally acquired malaria
- Malaria information
- Matched case–control study